Vault101 said:
[b/]1. I call bullshit[/b] I get the impression this may in fact be a "cover" for people, they never have to try, so they never have to fail. They can sit there with a sense of smug supirioty without ever having to show anything for it, its a delusion that's very easy to have among a certain demographic of people *cough*. I get the feeling if half of thease people actually tried they'd realise they were in fact normal and not super special (of coarse I think in some cases the dedication and will to work for it is just as important as the ability being htere in the first place.)
[b/]2. its nothing to be proud of[/b] even if there was truth in the statement, again as I said, the dedication and will to work towards being "brilliant" is just as important. I don't see it as a bragging point because I think personally I just see it as wasting what you have...[b/]and acting like its a fucking good thing[/b]...or I dont know..some kind of "cool and rebellious" thing...
now I admit I am by no means perfect, I've been burned before by my own lazyness and attitude not to different from this, mabye its a kind of jealously really,
so what do you think? do you know anyone like this? do you agree/disagree?
I totally get this, and both sort of agree and disagree. I've had experience with the sort who utilise it as a sort of cover (Easily spotted by their derision of the work as simple or easy, and their failure to excel at it), but I'd actually consider myself as an example of this (Pitchforks away people, hear it out, yes, I know how stupid it sounds).
I used to be a good student, and I used to get good marks. I'm on a couple of academic scholarships. But I'm not good at applying myself, because being smarter than most of the people in my previous schooling meant I only had to do the bare minimum to excel. Now I have to actually work, and I'm alongside people who were either as smart as I am, or who worked harder, and I don't understand how to do the extra work necessary to get by, and I don't try as hard. It's like the start of Winger's speech at the end of the first episode of community.
I literally had one thing I couldn't do in my first 12 years of schooling, and that was circular trigonometry. So I spent 8 hours over a couple of days learning it all from scratch, until I had it. That was the only time I studied for a test. I was that jerk who got by without revising, because I pretty much knew it all after a once over.
It's frustrating, because I know I want to do it, but I can't get things organised and accomplish my goals. Point 2 covers this. It's not something to be proud of. I'm profoundly disappointed by my lack of work ethic, and my lapse in dedication. It's not something to brag about, and yeah, it's probably going to cost me a few thousand dollars if I have to pay my University fees if my scholarship gets revoked (Yes, this sounds very similar to one of the people in the video). I'm self-aware enough to realise that failing at applying myself well is not a particularly intelligent thing, but I can't get the attitude right. I think it really is an attitude thing. I don't know if it's depression or something, but I've been feeling very fucked up and apathetic. Whilst realising how stupid that is, which feeds back into it. Yay! Emotions!
So I wouldn't say that the idea is inherently wrong, but the people who truly have intelligence and lack the capacity to make the best of it, are usually intelligent enough to see how stupid that dilemna is, and are ashamed of it, and that those who would use it to excuse their performance with an appeal to an undemonstrated ability, are probably just ordinary in the most boring possible way.