Yeah, you're right, there's no way they could make a Lego product based on an existing property [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Lego_themes#Licensed_themes].The Gentleman said:Here's where it will fail. Firefly/Serenity is definitely trademarked and copyrighted (by Fox?) and anything that even potentially infringes on that IP is going to require negotiations with the holder. LEGO will probably not be able to get a deal that would justify placing the product on the market. They may even just stop once they realize it's an existing IP to save on the legal costs.Mike Kayatta said:Now that the project has met Lego's requirement of 10,000 votes, the play set has moved into the review phase, in which the Lego team, well, reviews the idea and determines its logistical, legal, and market feasibility.
So, yeah, I wouldn't hold my breath for this...
The existing property isn't the problem. It's whether or not the necessary agreement to use the IP (which generally involves paying either a lump sum or a portion of the profits to the actual holders) is even worth the cost and effort to do so. The penalty for not doing this can be fairly severe (and expensive to defend). All of those product lines listed have gone through this process. The question is whether or not LEGO Serenity/Firefly will get such an agreement.Zyr said:Yeah, you're right, there's no way they could make a Lego product based on an existing property [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Lego_themes#Licensed_themes].The Gentleman said:Here's where it will fail. Firefly/Serenity is definitely trademarked and copyrighted (by Fox?) and anything that even potentially infringes on that IP is going to require negotiations with the holder. LEGO will probably not be able to get a deal that would justify placing the product on the market. They may even just stop once they realize it's an existing IP to save on the legal costs.Mike Kayatta said:Now that the project has met Lego's requirement of 10,000 votes, the play set has moved into the review phase, in which the Lego team, well, reviews the idea and determines its logistical, legal, and market feasibility.
So, yeah, I wouldn't hold my breath for this...
But isn't there a difference between a "Theme" for Legos and a "Theme" based on something else. I love my "Castle" and "Space" sets. Heck, I even liked the "Agents" line they came out with a while back. I guess I just see the need to have my favorite characters made into Legos and sold to me. I'd rather just a big tub of Legos and MAKE my favorite characters.Swyftstar said:I agree a little but it isn't always the whole point. Lego has always had themes. My first set was a fire station and I enjoyed following the instructions and building what was there (good practice for IKEA). It's after that where the true value of Legos come in because once you get bored with the model, you can break it apart and use your imagination to make all sorts of funky stuff.
9Zhukov said:How do these people have energy to cling on for... what's it been, ten years now?
Clearly these people did not watch Star Wars. Or Pirates of the Caribbean. Or Batman. Or the Indiana Jones movies. Or Lord of the Rings.markljlewis said:Surprise surprise Lego said No....
LEGO produces toys for children. Therefore all LEGO products, regardless of age target, must be content-appropriate for this core audience. With this in mind we have decided that as cool as the Serenity model is, the Firefly TV show and Serenity film contain content that is not appropriate for our core target audience of children ages 6-11. While we know this news will disappoint those who supported the project, we will not be producing this as a LEGO product.
From the site, it looks like theres 3 cuusoo products. Minecraft, Hayabusa, and Shinkai.Stikibunn said:Has anything from Cuusoo actually been accepted by Lego yet?
Agreed, the whole point of Lego is supposed to be creating these things for yourself. It always sticks in my craw, how damn expensive Lego is as well. What happend to the old days when all you needed was a lot of Lego! - these days if you wanted a lot of lego, you'd need a bloody mortgage first.sinboy666 said:I'm I the only one who is getting sick and tired of IP based Lego sets? Seriously, Star Wars was kind of cool when it first came out, but I thought the WHOLE POINT of Lego was it allowed you to make these things on your own. What the hell happened to those days?
Also Lego Legend of Zelda is being "reviewed" (we should know the answer by June) That would be good as Legend of Zelda fits many of Lego's standards for preferred IP's, it's a series aimed at 9-11 year old boys and popular with grownups.Caffiene said:Im interested what exactly is so bad in Firefly that is worse than the "pulling a beating heart out a man" that was in The Temple of Doom...
But mostly Im just interested to have found the Cuusoo site. Im not as big a lego nerd as some people, but thats pretty cool.
edit:
From the site, it looks like theres 3 cuusoo products. Minecraft, Hayabusa, and Shinkai.Stikibunn said:Has anything from Cuusoo actually been accepted by Lego yet?