"...but we're just friends"

Recommended Videos

yizas

New member
Nov 19, 2009
89
0
0
Yep it happens to me, im weird im not totally nerd but i dont know what i am, anyhow this girl wich whom i am friends told me the same things, im nice and like a brother bla bla bla and i didnt mind because i wasnt triying to go out with her, but after a couple of weeks of just hanging out she told me she liked me and then backed away and im like WTF. Maybe you need to hang out with other type of women or i dont know just grow a pair and start asking people out, most girls dont like shy boys and the ones that do ... Well they might be a bit to much to chew on if you know what i mean xD
 

WOPR

New member
Aug 18, 2010
1,912
0
0
Siberian Relic said:
Flare Phoenix said:
WOPR said:
Flare Phoenix said:
Any girl who lists reasons why they would so obviously want you, and then follows it with a declaration that they don't want you even though you never asked them if they did want you is a presumptious *****.
I did tell them I like them
then they go into that long rant
and it has happened EVERY time
...friends or not
and if we weren't friends we become friends from it

so what have I learned?

Tell the girl you like here and you're friends for life
Well then maybe the problem is with you. I don't know, but bitching to a group of strangers on the internet isn't going to help matters. Why do people think there is some magical solution out there to get girls that they just were never taught... like there was a "How to get Girls 101" lesson in school they somehow missed?
Dude, chill. He's not looking for your eloquently labeled "magical solution". One of the best ways to deal with a situation that can be personally discouraging is by hearing from others that have experienced the same sort of thing. You don't feel quite so ostracized or weird when you know the experience isn't isolated.
What you said... I don't like feeling weird, I'm weird enough as it is (probably from 18+ years of being single *cough*)

anyways, yeah I'll be fine, I'm not crazy, I'm just wondering why this happens EVERY SINGLE TIME

but yeah, I'm okay- and yes this did just happen today (like 3 hours ago... from a girl I've been friends with for 4+ years) which is what brought it to my mind
 

Kae

That which exists in the absence of space.
Legacy
Nov 27, 2009
5,792
712
118
Country
The Dreamlands
Gender
Lose 1d20 sanity points.
No, but I would have preferred to be her friend than what actually happened, which is weird because after we supposedly became a couple nothing happened not even a kiss cause I am way too shy and nervous, the only thing that happened is that we stopped talking cause everyone would look at us when we were together thus making the situation way too uncomfortable and considering she's been my only girlfriend I guess I have not really had a girlfriend now, although she says that since we never officially broke up we are still together though I have not seen her in years, heard she became quite the beautyful woman though.
 

Monkfish Acc.

New member
May 7, 2008
4,102
0
0
Well this thread is certainly leaning dangerously into Nice Guy territory.
Unless it is already in there and shaking hands with the local chieftain and I have just missed it. I don't know. I've had a lot to drink.

Anyway, no. I have never gotten a friendship speech. Mostly because I never want to be anything more than friends.
I have had to dish out a few myself, though.
 

crudus

New member
Oct 20, 2008
4,415
0
0
WOPR said:
sounds 99% right

...only instead of it being one "job interview" it's roughly 26? 28?
and the only "jobs" that considered "hiring me" couldn't because they're on the opposite end of the country.
Mine is usually something like "no, I don't want to date you. Even a one night stand would be weird. However, I will drunkenly nail this guy slightly to your left, swap numbers, and he will longingly/creepily text me constantly at all hours of the day, complain to you what a horrible mistake that was, rinse, repeat". Like, what the hell. Then the ones who do want to date me have angry boyfriends who try to kill me. No joke.
 

RaphaelsRedemption

Eats With Her Mouth Full
May 3, 2010
1,409
0
0
WOPR said:
Flare Phoenix said:
WOPR said:
Flare Phoenix said:
Any girl who lists reasons why they would so obviously want you, and then follows it with a declaration that they don't want you even though you never asked them if they did want you is a presumptious *****.
I did tell them I like them
then they go into that long rant
and it has happened EVERY time
...friends or not
and if we weren't friends we become friends from it

so what have I learned?

Tell the girl you like here and you're friends for life
Well then maybe the problem is with you. I don't know, but bitching to a group of strangers on the internet isn't going to help matters. Why do people think there is some magical solution out there to get girls that they just were never taught... like there was a "How to get Girls 101" lesson in school they somehow missed?
umm... not trying to "whine"
trying to explain when things are asked
the primary question still stands

"Are there any other people that have been in this situation, or do I just suck at life?"

I'd say maybe it is with me, but (not trying to sound full of myself) I am a good person... sure I'm not uber beefy, and I'm a bit on the nerdy side, but so what?

anyways

see question

now to make this funny

blurrrrrrrraaaaaaaaaaaaaa- *choking sounds*
So maybe other people have the same issue. It's really not relevant. What seems to be bothering you is that your friends seem to want you as a friend, while you want more.

Maybe you need to be more overt about what you actually want from a woman. No girl's going to come jump into your arms and say "You're wonderful, be mine!" Whether you like it or not, the social norm for Western society is that the guy does the initial pursuing, while the girl responds.

What DO you want from girls? It doesn't seem to be friendship, otherwise you'd be ok with them telling you that you're nice and would be good for an intimate relationship with someone else. You'd probably think, "Oh, how good that they are clarifying that we are both just friends. That's exactly what I wanted".

I assume what you want then is a relationship. Are you pursuing that goal? Or are you hoping one of the girls you know casually will magically turn into a girlfriend? It takes effort to get to know someone; and bravery. Don't think girls don't notice how much it takes for you to gather up the courage to ask them out; a lot of them do. And if they're not interested, they may feel pretty bad about saying no.

I guess what I'm trying to say is: when you get to know girls "just as a friend", but with a hidden agenda of wanting a relationship, you are basically lying to the people you're hanging out with. A better plan may be to try to hang out in mixed groups, get to know girls as friends in a friends setting, and if you meet one you click with, ask her out on a date. That way, both of you know where you stand.

You say you are a nice guy. You also say people are backing you up on that statement. So why are you unhappily asking for support over the internet? Do you think you're nice, really? Because if you did, maybe you wouldn't be spending so much time sitting on the net talking about how you haven't got a girl and more time hanging out with real people, or even on dates. With a girl.
 

pretentiousname01

New member
Sep 30, 2009
476
0
0
Sorry but this comic came to mind, spoilers for largeness

[img src="http://www.vgcats.com/comics/images/100708.jpg" /img]

As for actual advice, words of wisdom. Don't pine over these girls. They aren't going to suddenly change their minds and start suddenly being all into you.
 

Instant K4rma

StormFella
Aug 29, 2008
2,208
0
0
I feel ya on this one. I've had this happen to me probably... Five times? Apparently I'm a damn good friend, because that's all girls want to be with me. Oh well. I'll figure it out some day. Or maybe I won't. I probably won't...
 

WOPR

New member
Aug 18, 2010
1,912
0
0
RaphaelsRedemption said:
You say you are a nice guy. You also say people are backing you up on that statement. So why are you unhappily asking for support over the internet? Do you think you're nice, really? Because if you did, maybe you wouldn't be spending so much time sitting on the net talking about how you haven't got a girl and more time hanging out with real people, or even on dates. With a girl.
1) I'm not asking for support I'm asking if I'm the only one (so clarification because this feels like a weird situation)

2) I'm unhappy? sure it's a depressing topic but right now I feel rather indifferent, my mind isn't "woe was me" it's more of "really? again? dang."

3) Spending lots of time on the net? I've been here for like an hour, because it's 10 and I'm getting ready to go to bed because I need to get up early in the morning; I've been out and about all day today

4) I've asked girls out, made the intentions clear, shot down every time

5) ...only one girl ever felt bad about saying no... sadly it was the one that happened today, and we've been friends for a long time... I just hope she and I still are friends
 

WOPR

New member
Aug 18, 2010
1,912
0
0
pretentiousname01 said:
Sorry but this comic came to mind, spoilers for largeness

[img src="http://www.vgcats.com/comics/images/100708.jpg" /img]

As for actual advice, words of wisdom. Don't pine over these girls. They aren't going to suddenly change their minds and start suddenly being all into you.
No worries I'm not... I think... I'm still a little unclear on what "pine" means

either way I'm happy with being friends, I just wish it were something more **isn't a jealous person** now then, back to work I go... freaking robotics in the morning... no wait tomorrow is friday... freaking community service projects for EAST program... *grumbles* at least I get to play the piano
 

The Rockerfly

New member
Dec 31, 2008
4,649
0
0
Had the problem when I was a bit younger, just distance yourself from those girls. I'm talked a good few months so their image of you will change, not just a few days.
Don't become so emotionally attached next time
Try and be cool, suave, hygienic and overall not be miserable around them. If they start talking and you're at a party just say, can talk about it another time lets just enjoy ourselves.

It's worked for me, might be a little different for you but at least give it a try
 

brumley53

New member
Oct 19, 2009
253
0
0
pretentiousname01 said:
Sorry but this comic came to mind, spoilers for largeness

[img src="http://www.vgcats.com/comics/images/100708.jpg" /img]

As for actual advice, words of wisdom. Don't pine over these girls. They aren't going to suddenly change their minds and start suddenly being all into you.
The worst kind of finisher...

OT: I've been told by a friend it's about being charismatic and not just nice, I can hardly comment though because all I've gotten is the friend zone and some other awkard excuses, although the idea of making it more obvious that you like her before you become really good friends sounds like it would work.
 

SodaDew

New member
Sep 28, 2009
417
0
0
I have had this situation... in fact when ever I remember it it almost brings me to crying. I had been wanting to ask a girl out for 3 years, and finally I did and she said the EXACT thing the OP said.(There is a really dark story which happened after this)...yea but its the past now.
 

dorkette1990

New member
Mar 1, 2010
369
0
0
Nerdy guys are amazing! Well, not so much for the cuddling, but if both of us were aloof, that ruins the magic, yeah? So, I don't mind if they cuddle me, I'm just not so much a curl up sorta girl. I like nerdy boys, except the lack of romance part (maybe it's just mine, though... he keeps telling me I'm "not girly enough to like the romantic stuff).
 

008Zulu_v1legacy

New member
Sep 6, 2009
6,019
0
0
Asking a girl out isnt one of those chess games that takes months to play out, its one of those 5 minute blitz games. If you cant ask a girl out after 5 minutes of talking to her, then odds are you wont be able to.

I know that reads as harsh, but if you want results, you gotta change your game plan.
 

Kurt Cristal

New member
Mar 31, 2010
438
0
0
Used to happen but I've changed with how I react to. If I am genuinely okay with being just friend, I come to accepting it, because in some few cases it IS the case. However, sometimes, I have little interest in being friends, I want to date. If I get fed that line, I challenge it. I tell them "try". Or I tell them I'm not interested in being just friends. If they don't like that then oh well, I go find someone else and don't talk to them any more. As of now I'm currently dating someone so I'm not too bitter about anything at the moment.
 

Stryc9

Elite Member
Nov 12, 2008
1,294
0
41
Yea, it's happened to me before and guess what, she is still to this day nearly 15 years on the best friend I've ever had. Just because you're put into the "friend zone" doesn't mean you still can't have a close and loving relationship.