Gasaraki said:
So, I just found this brilliant piece of fear-mongering
and I just have no idea what to say.
Are people seriously this paranoid?
That's not fear-mongering. I don't think you know what that term means.
Fear-mongering is stuff like "Hurr! Xbox is gunna turn your daughter into a lesbian communist!"
This video was more "caution-mongering" it encourages the staff to act calm, professional and inquisitive? They let him stay, but it IS weird to carry around that much in cash. I mean what if they got mugged, they'd lose a vast sum of money and absolutely zero chance of getting it back (Credit cards are insured against fraud/theft). What if he bought/made a load of counterfeit money and is to afraid to put it in a bank where they will link him to an address, so he ranks up a huge hotel bill and make off before they find out.
Hotels like to know who they have in their hotel, it's pretty bad for business if they are criminals and malefactors using their facilities. Also they have a certain amount of responsibility to go to some effort to check out who they are harbouring.
If you were kind enough to charitably invite a stranger into your home to stay, wouldn't you like some issue of accountability or guarantee they aren't a fugitive on the run? You wouldn't ask them a few questions or want to check them out in some way? Hotels have always been about privacy but what you fail to realise is this means they have ALWAYS CHECKED THEIR CUSTOMERS ID! Ever since the 19th century when con-men would write fake cheques to pay off huge bills the Hotels have never taken a guest without making sure they could be held accountable in some way.
I mean, how do you think police manhunts work? It is relatively easy to get a hold of cash (mugging, beg from confederate, or counterfeit) then check into a hotel to lay low, but with a credit cards (again, stolen, lent from known associate or ripped off) and check into a hotel and the cops are on your ass within minutes.
This is law-enforcement 101. US Marshals get court orders to monitor the financial activity of a fugitive's associates and stolen cards and so on.
And yes, he'd BETTER pay in advance if he is using only cash, or he could check in, rack up a huge bill then walk out the door. Remember, room service isn't charged per item, it is put on a tab and if you have zero accountability like linking back to an credit card or verifiable address then these hotels can be ripped off blind.
It GENUINELY is odd to not have a credit card, you cannot hire a car nor buy so many things without a credit card and that is not for ease of accounting, it is a matter of personal accountability. They don't want to give someone a $10'000 car for a rent of $200 only to never see that car again!
You know what OP, welcome to the REAL WORLD of commerce and paying for stuff. Credit cards are part of the trust equation, and hotels trust you SO MUCH when they invite you to stay with them. Without a credit card for accountability there is a huge unbalance of trust.