I bet a ton of people are gonna put Pyramid Head and I'll admit that I've never played SH2, but I'm aware of what makes him scary.
For me, I would have to vote for SawRunner from the Cry of Fear mod. The dude stalks you through the entire game appearing 4-5 times and he chases you every single time, and the point of him is to make you run away. His last appearance is in pitch black woods, so you need to use the sound of his chainsaw to determine where you run from until he gets like within two feet of you. He also made a horrifying screech.
I'd rank this dude up there with central enemies from a horror game even though he didn't, to my knowledge, represent any kind of deeper meaning like Pyramid Head.
For me, I would have to vote for SawRunner from the Cry of Fear mod. The dude stalks you through the entire game appearing 4-5 times and he chases you every single time, and the point of him is to make you run away. His last appearance is in pitch black woods, so you need to use the sound of his chainsaw to determine where you run from until he gets like within two feet of you. He also made a horrifying screech.
I'd rank this dude up there with central enemies from a horror game even though he didn't, to my knowledge, represent any kind of deeper meaning like Pyramid Head.