captainwillies said:
wow. just wow. its only a movie and yet such hate and arrogance is displayed on the christian side. I'm not flamming christians but jesus they linked an 18th century naturlist to "Hitler"? goddamn.
But you know that Charles Darwin had a few views in favour of eugenics. But that doesn't mean that the theory of evolution is bad or untrue.
It's like this: the theory of evolution and the natural selection between species is a sound and reasonable theory which have been supported by a lot of scientific evidence over the years. So far Darwin made a good move.
Then he and some of his supporters started to dabble in a few less-than-sound theories. Like social evolution between individuals in one species. Like saying that poor people in society should blame themselves for being poor, and them being poor and starving to death is only a result of "natural selection", which is bollocks of course.
But that doesn't mean that everything he said must be bollocks now does it?
It's like with one of my countrys famous scientists, Carl von Linnaues. He basically set out to catalogue all living species of plants by name, family, sub-species etc. etc. this would later be used on animals as well. Swedish students are being taught that he's a sort of scinetific national hero in that regard... But what is rarely mentioned is the fact that he's one of the major sources that started racial eugenics in the academic world as well. Hitler had some major influence by Carl von Linnaues, and Carl was even the one who divided human beings into different races, calling some ethnic of black people "Homo Monstrum" for instance, and tried to claim that some "races" of humans were inferior to others in matters of intellect. Meaning of course that Europeans were the "Creme de la creme" of intellectual human species while the rest of the world were somewhere below them.
It's quite easy to see where the sound scientific thinking started, and where it all went overboard into euro-centrism and hostile racism, don't you agree?
Does that mean that Carl von Linnaues efforts to catalouge species of plants and animals along with their characteristics and ways to recognize them? Hell no! It has been one of the most important scientific endavours ever made and it has helped in the fields of natural history, biology, medicine and all manner of scientific branches. It would be stupid to just toss all that out due to no other reason than political correctness.
It's like saying: -"Well he did write some really helpful stuff, but we have to burn it all and forget it was ever written because it has been proven that the author was also a racist bigot as well. To bad..."
So I really can't undestand what's so controversial about Darwin, even among religious people. Religion is about faith anyway, not evidence, so even if he was right about life in general it doesn't really matter if you have faith and stick to the commandments til the day you die. Being religious isn't about being right, it's about believing in an invisible man in the sky and that he means us all well. But this is something that a lot of religious people haven't realized...