Choose three game you would erase from your mind just so you could play them again!

[kickyourass]

Dragon Age Origins, the first time I played that game I made SUCH an atrociously, embarrassing mess of it I feel like I personally insulted the game, Bioware, and the RPG genre as a whole. Getting to do that over would be nice.

Shadow of the Collossus, now that I've matured a bit and am far less of a moron I'd probably keep it this time around.

Skyrim, cause it's Skyrim.

 

[Casual Shinji]

Resident Evil 4
Okami
Half-Life 2

I remember these games blowing my brain out of my skull and across the moon the first time I played them.

 

[Necroid_Neko]

Ever 17 (we're counting visual novels as games here, yes?).

Remember 11

Jade Empire

 

[dyre]

Baldur's Gate 2
Witcher 2
Arcanum

not necessarily the best games I've played (though, all in my top 5), but I think they had the highest "enjoyment from first playthrough" : "enjoyment from following playthroughs" ratios.

 

[Aurora Firestorm]

Chrono Trigger, my first RPG ever.
Metal Gear Solid 3, so I can experience that "trigger-pull" ending for the first time, again. I cried so hard.
System Shock 2, so I can have played the games in order and really get that visceral "oh HELL" stomach-dropping sensation when SHODAN pops up in the Deck 4 hologram room.

 

[Rheinmetall]

Hehe! very easy answer.
Final Fantasy VII
Silent Hill
Metal Gear Solid

 

[Soulfoodman]

Bioshock because it was one of the first games in my memory where my mind was blown.

Fallout 3 because it introduced me to the Fallout universe.

Any of the first generation of Pokemon because that's a big piece of my childhood.

Runner-up:

Tales of Symphonia (I've played through it 2 1/2 times now and it is one of the few JRPG's I have ever cared about)

 

[Baconator96]

Assassins' Creed 2, Mass Effect 2 (mostly because I spoiled all the big revelations for myself), and Red Dead Redemption

 

[dj Facchiano]

I'm gonna go with persona 4, The digital Devil saga's, and metal gear solid 3.

 

[95spartans]

Assassins creed 2: the best of the assassins creed series. Has a brilliant story and ending. I've played it about 4 times through.

Haze: not the best game but I loved the multiplayer (I even prefered it any other fps multiplayer) but eventually got bored of it.

Heavy rain: Good story but you can't play it more than once when you know the ending

 

[JasonKaotic]

Final Fantasy VIII (So.. so many times)
Final Fantasy IX
Silent Hill 2

I've drained all the enjoyment I can possibly get out of the first two, but there's still some left for Silent Hill 2. I'll play that again at some point.

Edit: Actually, Final Fantasy VII instead of Silent Hill 2. Then I could erase everything the fanboys/girls spoiled for me before I played it and probably enjoy it more.
Seriously. Fuck. Them.

 

[Stein Inge]

When I started reading the thread I was all like "Three games? No problem!" now its more "There are too many games!!"
Mind you I would have to also erase all the games I´s played since because I´d want to be sure nothing would tarnish that "Oh hell yesssss" feeling I got the first tim I played these games...

If I had to choose (and I do) it would have to be:

Shadow of The Colossus

The Portal games (Don´t make me choose between them! Please!)

Die Hard Trilogy. (Not trying to cheat here but looking back I honestly miss this game! The third part in particular).

 

[pffh]

Pffff that's easy Morrowind, World of Warcraft and Knights of the Old Republic.

 

[jdogtwodolla]

The Elder Scrolls 4 Oblivion: I had it on the xbox and played a fefty amount of it before getting it for the PC. Now I'm just not that into it like I should be.

Timesplitters 2: I loved that feeling when I was... 10 to 13 when I played this as my first "hardcore" (I hate that word) game. I had trouble controlling my character, I didn't know what a lot of the terminology meant or what things did. And i stumbled blindley through the arcade maps not even seeing the overall layout of the maps , just running around thinking of how it was some sort of maze. Boy was that a fresh experience.

GTA San Andreas: pretty much the same reason as my oblivion pick except I always had this for the pc.

 

[Zeetchmen]

Katawa Shoujo, Skyrim, and Beyond Good and Evil

Get those first time feels all over again.

 

[mgirl]

Amnesia: The Dark Descent - So it can be as scary as it was the first time I played it.

Portal 2 - I had the ending spoiled for me before I played it, so I wish I could play it clean without that spoiler.

Half Life 2: Episode 2 - Same as above, I had the ending spoiled before I played it.

 

[ZeroMachine]

Alan Wake is number one on that list. Hands down.

Number two, I'd have to say Portal 2, just for that insane ending.

Three... I don't know. It would have been KoTOR if I was still majorly into Star Wars, but... I'm not. Maybe Chrono Trigger.

EDIT: Oh, shit, duh, Amnesia: The Dark Descent. I've still yet to actually beat it, but I'd like to experience it fresh when I go back to it again.

 

[esperandote]

Silent Hill 1, Silent Hill 2 and ... Silent Hill 3.

Also, Fatal Frame III