I've been in the same boat somewhat, and as someone who's spent many years trying to introduce a parent to anime/comics/newer forms of entertainment, I can tell you that sometimes it's just not going to happen. I'm not saying it's not worth trying to convert him, but it's just a possibility to be aware of.
Depending on the age of you and your father, well...different generations are different in terms of accepting of new/different ideas or concepts. For example I know a group of folks where I work that they're in their fifties or so and they are stubborn towards most new things. They're old-fashioned guys and they believe all guys should be as such. Show too much emotion? You're "being like a woman". Don't like/didn't play sports? What the hell were your parents teaching you? I could go on but I think you get the idea. There's nothing wrong with it (despite it being aggravating when they loudly speak about it in reference to people like myself), but it can be darn disappointing to have to deal with people who are simply 'old-fashioned'.
Set yourself a limit. A sort of 'I give up' point. Yes, this is something you want to share with him, but all kids want to share things with their parents and oftentimes what the kids what to share doesn't sync up with what the parents want to engage in. (Ask many of us who have tried introducing our parents to gaming!) If you go past the 'give up' point, don't take it as a failure, but just as a sign to stop wasting your time and energy on trying to bond with him over this, and a sign to move on to finding something different or better to bring you two together. It can take a few attempts, but it can be done. However being stubborn and prolonging the attempt when it's clear it's not going to work is just going to hurt things.