Dark Souls: Initial Thoughts

Recommended Videos

IronicBeet

New member
Jun 27, 2009
392
0
0
ghost whistler said:
Shadie777 said:
ghost whistler said:
Disregard what you like. It's your lookout. Im not telling you what to enjoy, I'm telling what's wrong with the game. Unfortunately for the gaming hobby this game has seen fit to insert a crazy fog in people's minds that blinds them to a host of very obvious faults.

snip
please do remember that this is your opinion on what is wrong with the game, it may be a opinion which is shared by some people but it is still an opinion. You obviously do not like this game, that is fine. It happens. But please do not assume that we are being mislead and manipulated. I am not blind to some of the faults in this game, It just does not lessen the experience for me.
Thank you, i'm fully cogniscent of what an opinion is.

I didn't say it was a bad game. I said it was a badly made game.

For instance, if you accidentally attack an npc, there is no cooldown. This means if you accidentally hit a vendor/trainer you are screwed. That might sound amusing, and people may get a good chuckle out of it, but the shortsightedness of that design is embarassing in 2011, and arguing consequences in a game where you can come back to life is a bit fatuous.
Wait, a game that's known for being completely unforgiving in every aspect is unforgiving of you if you hit an NPC? Unthinkable!
 

Itsthefuzz

New member
Apr 1, 2010
221
0
0
ghost whistler said:
How does consistency of opinion = trolling? Get real!

And what does skill have to do with the decision to give one hit kill moves to mobs (and not even bosses)? As if people are supposed to know this is going to happen. Are you going to argue that players shouldn't get hit? Well fuck me, duh! If that isn't the dictionary definition of cheap game design then I don't know what is.

But even that would be acceptable...if the game had a sensible save system.
I think he thought you were trolling since literally 80% of your argument was completely ludicrous...
 

QueenOliver

New member
Apr 25, 2011
42
0
0
Dansen said:
I was just invaded for the first time! Why is this even in the damn game!

He was so lucky I was poisoned too!

How to I report this little $#%#@!
As the other guy said, don't play online if you don't want to be invaded. You also can't be invaded if you are hollowed. And to "report" an invasion you use a special item purchased from the guy in the bell-tower on top of the Undead Church. If you want to avoid invasions it is also rumored that there are certain covenants such as the Way of White that will cause fewer of them.

Edit: Scratch that part about playing online. I was playing offline just now and an NPC black phantom invaded my world. I killed her pretty easily. Afterwards I absorbed 1 humanity, picked up 3 humanity items, and got a decent weapon off of her corpse. BEST GAME EVARRR!!!
 

ImperialSunlight

New member
Nov 18, 2009
1,269
0
0
I've beat all the bosses except 2 and so far I love the game besides the completely messed up online features and the covenant system which I think could have been implemented better. Also there aren't very many viable magic weapons besides those that are made using the upgrade system.
 

Itsthefuzz

New member
Apr 1, 2010
221
0
0
In other news, this game has done the impossible for me. I've never played Demon souls, but thought it looked interesting... after getting this game and playing it for a total of 60 hours, without even beating the game yet, I have decided that this game is now my number one all time favorite.. over the half-life series. I didn't think it was possible.
 

QueenOliver

New member
Apr 25, 2011
42
0
0
s69-5 said:
GZGoten said:
The only thing I don't like are the bosses, I wanted more of a challenge but they're piss easy
So they aren't "Flamelurker hard" then?

Even Demon's Souls bosses get pretty easy once you understand them. False King is actually not too hard once you understand how he moves. That is except Flamelurker. On NG+ (and beyond) he is one hard mofo (he's easy enough in the first playthrough though).

Maybe Dark Souls bosses are like that? Pretty easy on the first go, harder on NG+?

I hope I get this game this weekend...
Odd, even on NG+++ I didn't have much trouble with Flamelurker.

A lot of the bosses are very easy once you know what to do, especially if you have a summon helping you out, but there are still some damn challenging ones. Of the 11 major bosses I've defeated so far, 6 of them were on my first try, but the Great Gray Wolf Sif for example took me about 7 attempts. The Stray Demon took something like a dozen attempts and seemed all but impossible until I upgraded my pyromancy to over 9000.
 

IronicBeet

New member
Jun 27, 2009
392
0
0
ghost whistler said:
Fiz_The_Toaster said:
I'm loving it so far, I'm still in Undead Burg though and I'm just level grinding since that damn Taurus has been kicking my ass.

Not a fan of the targeting system, but everything else is great.
level grinding won't help you.
Not if you suck at the game, but if you can learn from your mistakes and persevere (Or even just try to find something you like at all about the game) you'll stand a much better chance against him. Walk onto the bridge, climb the ladder to to the right, kill the archers, plunge him in the head. Run to the other side of the bridge and back, climb the ladder again, repeat plunge. Do that until he's dead. It's not that hard, man.

Honestly, all I'm seeing from you is complaints about every little thing that gets brought up, even as advice that's supposed to help you (Which I'm surprised is still coming in, considering your horrible attitude towards the game). Yes, the plague rats are about a minute away from the bonfire. It does take a long time t grind humanity off of them. It is annoying. Do you know why it's annoying? Because it's grinding. Grinding is not supposed to be fun. You grind so you can get stronger so you can do better at the game so you can have fun.

And yes, 42,000 souls is a ridiculous price to pay to have NPCs forgive you. Just deal with it instead of complaining. You made a mistake, you're being punished for it. I'm sorry the game doesn't hold your hand like almost every other current-gen game does now. It's not bad game design, it's just really, really hard. Yes, the game can be cheap at some points. I will admit that. But that is the case with EVERY GAME EVER. There are always going to be annoying parts to every game that you dread going through. If you find the entire thing unfair, then either A. You're just no good at the game or B. You're not willing to take the red-tinted glasses off and change up your playstyle to suit the situation you're in. Reading your complaints about the game is like watching DarkSydePhil's LPs of it, all you do is criticize From Software and the people who like Demon's/Dark Souls.

If you don't like the game, you're never going to get your money's worth. Trade it in and buy RAGE or something. And if you insist on playing through it, STOP. COMPLAINING. It's okay to get mad, but please, for the love of God, stop whining about every little thing. It's not fun for you, it's not fun for us, it's not fun for anybody.

I think this is the longest post I've ever typed out on these forums.
 

ImperialSunlight

New member
Nov 18, 2009
1,269
0
0
Sram said:
I bought my copy two days ago because this thread made me curious and I'm having fun with it. Never played Demon's Souls so I'm new to the game. Started as a Warrior and I managed to get to the Bell Gargoleys as far as that both of them are infight. I think I'm lacking Stamina, it's around 96, should I grind some Souls to raise it? I'm also using a Halberd I found somewhere because I like it's range and I don't have the Drake Sword.
The most important thing I've ever learned in Demon's Souls and thus dark souls) about melee builds can be represented by a single word: Stamina. Stamina is everything. To succeed with a melee build in demon's souls, you needed around 40 stamina at least and you needed to know how to manage it well because if you use it all attacking but leave none to dodge with, you easily die. So you can never have too little stamina.

Edit: Oops, too MUCH stamina, I mean >.<

Edit 2: And by 40 stamina, I of course mean Endurance
 

QueenOliver

New member
Apr 25, 2011
42
0
0
gof22 said:
When an enemy is killed does that enemy stay dead or does it respawn? I really hate enemies that respawn. When I play a game I want to feel like I am actually making a difference.
The hubs, or checkpoints of the gameworld are the bonfires. Whenever you rest at a bonfire all of the standard enemies respawn. However, bosses, as well as certain very strong enemies/mini-bosses sprinkled throughout each world only need to be defeated once. The levels are also very labyrinthine in design, with paths frequently splitting off in different directions. Exploring different routes will often unlock shortcuts which will allow easier travel to and from bonfires, and you may also uncover new bonfires to make things easier. Progress if often a chipping away process. For example, the Catacombs are full of skeletons that will reassemble themselves after you've killed them. However, once you kill the necromancer that is reanimating them, they will stay dead when killed. This can get very intense as reanimated skeletons chase you down while you try to hunt down the necromancer. But after you kill him, he stays dead, and all of the skeletons in the area become a cakewalk.
 

QueenOliver

New member
Apr 25, 2011
42
0
0
s69-5 said:
QueenOliver said:
Odd, even on NG+++ I didn't have much trouble with Flamelurker.
Even with my level 183 Magician equipped with Crescent Falchion +5 and an extremely high magic stat did not like Flamelurker. Then again, I don't summon blue phantoms ^.^

Last week I decided to play some Demon's Souls multiplayer. Created a Temple Knight and went off to 4-1. Using only melee, I led some newbie by the nose through the level, killing off all of the Black Skeletons, Gold Skeletons, flying mantas, etc... with only my melee weapon (and a longbow for the mantas). He wouldn't even enter fog unless I walked over to it and waited...

So experience/skill is not what I lack there I don't think. I just don't like Flamelurker. Once he becomes enraged (about 25% health) he is a beast!

Edit: Also, my level 103 Priest with Large Sword of Moonlight versus the Red Eye Black Knights in 1-3... fun as hell. I don't even have to dodge - the sword cuts through them like butter...
It's certainly fun starting a new character in Demon's Souls after you've beat the game repeatedly with one character. You wonder sometimes how you ever had so much trouble in certain places.

As for the Flamelurker, I have no clue what that's about. I usually use my meat cleaver, learn his attack patterns well, and just take a slice out of him when the opportunity presents itself. That, and I cast soul arrows at him. It's been a while since I played Demon's Souls, but I really don't remember Flamelurker being much of a pain, other than on my first playthrough when I didn't know what to do.

The False King on the other hand was a massive pain in the nuts. Possibly because I try to keep my distance with him for fear of getting a soul level sucked out of me.
 

newguy77

New member
Sep 28, 2008
996
0
0
Sram said:
I bought my copy two days ago because this thread made me curious and I'm having fun with it. Never played Demon's Souls so I'm new to the game. Started as a Warrior and I managed to get to the Bell Gargoleys as far as that both of them are infight. I think I'm lacking Stamina, it's around 96, should I grind some Souls to raise it? I'm also using a Halberd I found somewhere because I like it's range and I don't have the Drake Sword.
Why not get the Drake Sword then? Just go to the merchant in the firstish area in the Undead Burg, buy a bow and some arrows (around 50 of any kind should be enough I think) and go under the bridge with the Hellkite Dragon. Whale on the tail with the arrows (aim for the part where it joins his body, it doesn't move much there) and bam! Drake Sword.

OT: Rented this game for yesterday and I had to return it today. Really liked it, got the first bell rung and started going to the sewers. I got to the Gaping Dragon, but didn't go through the fog because I had a relatively large amount of souls. Hopefully it will be cheaper around Black Friday and I'll pick it up then. If not, probably wait until Christmas.

Question Time: Does the Zweihander scale with the attack levels, or would I just be better off staying with the Drake Sword when I get back to the game? I'm at around 17 str and 14 dex.
Also, is there any way to sell stuff, or do I just drop it and hope it's not important?
 

QueenOliver

New member
Apr 25, 2011
42
0
0
Daystar Clarion said:
Are you just trolling now?

Because this post is nearly identical to the several other attempts to critise the game.

You confuse your own lack of skill with poor game mechanics, the camera is absolutely fine, I've had no problems with it whatsoever. I'll admit that the lock on is rather finnicky, but nothing unmanageable. Defence is a toss up between maneuverability and being built like a brick wall. Heavy armour allows you to shrug off attacks (you won't flinch), so if you're trying to go for a backstab, even if an attack manages to hit, you should still be able to carry on moving to get an attack in.

Everything else you've stated it purely subjective, and not evidence of poor game design.
To be fair, the camera did take some getting used to for me. It doesn't bother me at all now, though I still notice the little unpolished bits with it. For example, go from the bonfire in the Depths and travel down to the shortcut that leads to the Gaping Dragon in the area beside where the giant rat used to be. If you swivel the camera around a bit you'll see it goes right through the bars. The bars will block your view like this. However, it's not like there are any enemies there to defeat, and I haven't found any issues like that in areas where you have to fight. It's just one of those little areas that lack polish that every game has. Heck, I had way more problems with Ninja Gaiden's camera back in the day, and that's one of the best hack 'n' slash games of all time.

We have full agreement on everything else though of course. :p
 

QueenOliver

New member
Apr 25, 2011
42
0
0
Magefeanor said:
Googenstien said:
Magefeanor said:
Googenstien said:
Has a hellish day yesterday! Im at a stage where the game amps up its difficulty again so I decided to kill all the things I couldnt earlier. I took out afew Blue Wyverns, 3 Black Knights, Havel the Rock, The Hydra and then the Golden Golem.

I did this to farm up some souls and while I killed all those mobs I lost a ton of souls too and gained no ground soul level wise :-/

I guess I am going to have to stick it out in Blight Town and find a way to cure that disease or whatever those first few mobs give you. I have to use all 10 of my flasks and run back to the Depths Bonfire to restock.
Golden Golem? Wheeeeeereeeeeeeee??????
I want to beat it!
At the Hydra follow shoreline around the left side all the way in the back and he is there. He isnt all that hard either.
Thanks a lot, on my way to beat him now!
Be aware that when you kill the golem and free that magic teacher inside, she will disappear for the rest of the game if she takes a single hit. So when you summon her with her golden summon sign back at the shoreline, make sure you've taken out all the golems there or you risk missing out on some useful sorceries.
 

Itsthefuzz

New member
Apr 1, 2010
221
0
0
newguy77 said:
Sram said:
I bought my copy two days ago because this thread made me curious and I'm having fun with it. Never played Demon's Souls so I'm new to the game. Started as a Warrior and I managed to get to the Bell Gargoleys as far as that both of them are infight. I think I'm lacking Stamina, it's around 96, should I grind some Souls to raise it? I'm also using a Halberd I found somewhere because I like it's range and I don't have the Drake Sword.
Why not get the Drake Sword then? Just go to the merchant in the firstish area in the Undead Burg, buy a bow and some arrows (around 50 of any kind should be enough I think) and go under the bridge with the Hellkite Dragon. Whale on the tail with the arrows (aim for the part where it joins his body, it doesn't move much there) and bam! Drake Sword.

OT: Rented this game for yesterday and I had to return it today. Really liked it, got the first bell rung and started going to the sewers. I got to the Gaping Dragon, but didn't go through the fog because I had a relatively large amount of souls. Hopefully it will be cheaper around Black Friday and I'll pick it up then. If not, probably wait until Christmas.

Question Time: Does the Zweihander scale with the attack levels, or would I just be better off staying with the Drake Sword when I get back to the game? I'm at around 17 str and 14 dex.
Also, is there any way to sell stuff, or do I just drop it and hope it's not important?
The Zweihander does scale with strength, but I think there are some better 2 handers that scale with strength you get by the time the drake sword loses its power.
 

QueenOliver

New member
Apr 25, 2011
42
0
0
newguy77 said:
Question Time: Does the Zweihander scale with the attack levels, or would I just be better off staying with the Drake Sword when I get back to the game? I'm at around 17 str and 14 dex.
Also, is there any way to sell stuff, or do I just drop it and hope it's not important?
As you increase your stats, weapons with a scaling attack grade (E,D,C,B,A or S) for that stat will do more damage. Just look at the item description for the Zweihander. Sticking with the Drake Sword will become difficult after a while, since it will only ever do 200 damage unless you upgrade it, which requires rare dragon scales.

After you ring the second bell you'll get a new NPC at Firelink who will give you souls for items. Items that you drop will turn into Vagrants in other people's worlds. Vagrants are small crab looking creatures that are fairly easy to kill. I've only encountered one so far. Sadly I didn't realize what he was at the time and don't recall what he dropped. I believe they are supposed to drop something valuable, so if you ditch excess items you'll probably be doing another player a favor. This is still rather uncertain though.
 

newguy77

New member
Sep 28, 2008
996
0
0
QueenOliver said:
Just look at the item description for the Zweihander.
I returned the game today to the redbox, so I can't check the stats myself, but thanks for the explanation for the letter grades, I was wondering what those were for.
Also I think I found a vagrant, it's basically an upside down jellyfish that shoots homing missiles at you, right? If that's it, it gave me a humanity so yeah, pretty good reward. Thanks for the advice.
 

RedEyesBlackGamer

The Killjoy Detective returns!
Jan 23, 2011
4,701
0
0
s69-5 said:
GZGoten said:
The only thing I don't like are the bosses, I wanted more of a challenge but they're piss easy
So they aren't "Flamelurker hard" then?

Even Demon's Souls bosses get pretty easy once you understand them. False King is actually not too hard once you understand how he moves. That is except Flamelurker. On NG+ (and beyond) he is one hard mofo (he's easy enough in the first playthrough though).

Maybe Dark Souls bosses are like that? Pretty easy on the first go, harder on NG+?

I hope I get this game this weekend...
I suck at games like this, but I'm handling the bosses just fine. That is a sign that they aren't too hard. Except for Orstein and Smough. That fight is coming up for me and I've seen people die at it. A lot.