Dead Man Reviews - The Princess Bride

Recommended Videos

RoseCoveredCadaver

New member
Dec 24, 2010
56
0
0
In the world of overblown media, there is cliche, and then there are fairy tales. The fanciful lore that is so full of insidious plot holes, overtly unrealistic and nearly robotic characters, and black and white landscapes that they have been burned into our memory with all the violence of a bullet fired into our collective skulls.

Why don't we look at the list of requirements needed to make a fairy tale:
1.) Include the concept of true love, hope, and whatever other imaginary concepts the creatively devoid writer(s) can come up with.
2.) The main character is either a morally perfect commoner or a morally perfect prince that will risk his or her life in a reckless fashion as if it's the new trend in style.
3.) Write in evil antagonists.
4.) Main character(s) is(are) unrealistically physically attractive.
5.) Impossible odds conquered by said hero.
6.) Save the day.
7.) ????
8.) Profit!

The Princess Bride is a frame story-type adventure through yet another overused setting we've all been through before, except - like a hermaphrodite deciding whether to go by "he" or "she" and choosing "shim" as a sad alternative - the entire story doesn't really know whether to make fun of itself or force us to take it completely seriously.

The story begins with a boy playing some old video game when storytelling grandfather enters the room to read the kid a story. While at first this is an interesting beginning, the frame story gimmick gets old quick, but thats for later. After the kid whines profusely about the lameness of being read anything, Grandpa quickly shuts him up, and starts reading anyway.

I won't waste much time on the plot, because there isn't much to speak of and at least a billion people have seen this movie so I'll cut right to the chase.

For a movie that makes fun of itself Monty Python style, it repeatedly tries to tug at the heartstrings and instill a sense of admiration or inspiration in those watching, which can lead to confusing sentiments. Like those very Monty Python films, or anything with James Cameron's name on it, its a joke. It's one of those things that makes sense if you DON'T think about it.

The characters themselves are unbelievably black and white, with the only remotely three dimensional character being the Spaniard, which is just sad. The heroes are heroic, the damsel is in distress, and the king so hideously evil that I'm surprised he's capable of running an entire kingdom at all when he's clearly too busy stalking farm girls or lighting boxes of kittens on fire. Or burning a box of farm girls.

Why is the king so interested in a random common woman anyway? It's like the whole purpose of this is for him to figuratively shout "Ha ha, good guy with abnormally perfect hair! I have your woman! I'm so evil." In fact, upon marrying her, he immediately plots to strangle her that very night for no reason other than for the lulz, the sick fuck.

Why bother trying to be taken seriously when you're cracking jokes about stereotypical fairy tales so much? If they had just stuck with the light humor all the way through, it might have been worth more than one watch. And what's with the kid/grandfather setting constantly interrupting the flow of the story? I understand this was meant to be funny and remind you that it IS a book being read (likely to excuse the randomized serious moments in the tale), but really it just breaks up the action and I find myself wanting to simply ***** slap either the kid or the old man more than once so that they would shut up and let it play out.

The ending was horrible, and gave no definitive end to the story. For instance, if you waltz into a castle, tied the king up, and kidnapped the queen, wouldn't the entire military be on your tail all the way to the border? Instead, this king (while apparently controlling a massive kingdom) has sixty mercenaries at the front door that cut and run when faced with a single stationary target lit on fire and yelling really loudly. And the only armored guards that seem to appear to do anything are the four guards that die in five seconds when the Spaniard "Assassin's Creed"s ever one of them. And then the two lovers kiss and its over. The kicker? The old man's smile reminds me of a child molester and the kid wants to be read the story AGAIN the next day.

Oh, happy day.

The Princess Bride has a few shining moments of humor but other than that it is a sorry rendition of what shouldn't be: a joke with no punchline, a plot as straight as the Spaniard's gloriously curly locks, a reason to pity the writers who have been starved of creativity except for watching 2 AM Comedy Central for inspiration
 

Gildan Bladeborn

New member
Aug 11, 2009
3,044
0
0
You do know that The Princess Bride isn't an original work, right? The entire movie is actually a very faithful adaptation of the novel of the same name, which was a quite clever exercise in 4th wall breaking. See, the only edition of The Princess Bride that you'll find is a 'republished' version by author William Goldman, supposedly an abridged "good parts" re-printing of an older work by author S. Morgenstern, which was originally a satire of the excesses of European royalty. Goldman writes an introduction wherein he recounts being read this story as a child by his own grandfather, and comments throughout the text on the various segments he's leaving out (40 pages about selecting hats, etc), and the bits his grandfather never read him (like the actual ending where all is not necessarily happy).

Except there isn't an original edition of the text, because there is no S. Morgenstern - the entire book is the work of Goldman, and all his notes and recollections/comments about his "actual" life that he writes in the book are also works of fiction. It's a very clever bit of satire, and the film didn't really change much (except to leave certain scenes out), which makes sense considering Goldman also wrote that screenplay.

Also, just throwing this out there, Comedy Central didn't exist until two years after The Princess Bride was released - we are after all talking about a film that came out 24 years ago.
 

Gxas

New member
Sep 4, 2008
3,187
0
0
You quite obviously did not "get" the movie.

Gildan Bladeborn said:
Good Explanation
See that post for my feelings on the matter. Summed it up nicely.
 

RoseCoveredCadaver

New member
Dec 24, 2010
56
0
0
Gildan Bladeborn said:
You do know that The Princess Bride isn't an original work, right? The entire movie is actually a very faithful adaptation of the novel of the same name, which was a quite clever exercise in 4th wall breaking. See, the only edition of The Princess Bride that you'll find is a 'republished' version by author William Goldman, supposedly an abridged "good parts" re-printing of an older work by author S. Morgenstern, which was originally a satire of the excesses of European royalty. Goldman writes an introduction wherein he recounts being read this story as a child by his own grandfather, and comments throughout the text on the various segments he's leaving out (40 pages about selecting hats, etc), and the bits his grandfather never read him (like the actual ending where all is not necessarily happy).

Except there isn't an original edition of the text, because there is no S. Morgenstern - the entire book is the work of Goldman, and all his notes and recollections/comments about his "actual" life that he writes in the book are also works of fiction. It's a very clever bit of satire, and the film didn't really change much (except to leave certain scenes out), which makes sense considering Goldman also wrote that screenplay.

Also, just throwing this out there, Comedy Central didn't exist until two years after The Princess Bride was released - we are after all talking about a film that came out 24 years ago.
Learn something new every day. I couldn't consider myself a writer if I didn't have boundless humility, which I'm exercising to great effect. I can honestly say that I knew none of this, and I will research older topics from now on instead of blatantly spewing forth biased feces from every orifice I have.