Desert Island Discs

Recommended Videos

OmniscientOstrich

New member
Jan 6, 2011
2,879
0
0
Well, since I'm relatively bored and to the best of my knowledge I don't think one of these kinds of things have been done in quite a while I thought I'd take the time to discover what the Desert Island Discs of my fellow Escapists are. For those of you unfamiliar with the concept; for reasons that are left conveniently unexplained, you are stranded on a desert island and must choose 8 songs, along with a single book and luxury item (within reason, you're not getting a bloody speedboat, that would defeat the purpose you snarky git :p) to keep you occupied and curtail (or exacerbate depending on your picks) your impending descent into insanity. :) While I'm normally averse to the idea of assigning pieces of media the label of being my absolute favourite in the medium, I feel this can serve as more of a reflection on which particular songs I feel would best cater to a number of moods and tones I may experience and which I've played over and over enough times to the point where I'm comfortable in saying I won't grow tired of them(I guess what I'm saying in a roundabout way is, even if you're liable to change your mind feel free to play along anyway :D). So, let's begin...


First up is a sweeping prog classic from Canadian bipolar musical mastermind Devin Townsend. As the title would suggest, the song is thematically centred on grievance and though the lyrics appear to be more sullen and pessimistic, the tone of the music seems to exude a sense of catharsis, a sense of surmounting the emotional afflictions that have been plaguing you and to be at peace once more. The intro provides a great lead in, the guitar steadily building up in volume, bolstered by the subtle infusion of the keyboards until the elegantly melodic lead comes in and rings out in an echo, like the ripple of a wave just at the minute mark. Devin?s vocals here really giving power and weight to the piece; both offering moments of quiet, solemn reflection and a soaring expression of frustration and regret, airing out the emotions encumbered by this loss. A tremendous sequence roughly 5 minutes in settles down and gives heed to the faint sound of seagulls, projecting in my mind the vastness of the calming blue ocean, an endless horizon that inundates me with a feeling of liberation. A really amazing piece of music.


This is the song that I play to cheer myself up, one that I can't help but crack a smile any time it's on. :3 There's just something about the energy of this track that really captures a sense of camaraderie and instills me with vigour and optimism, punctuated through Lizzy's trademark twin-guitar harmonies, Lynott's groovy bass and slick, charismatic vocals. Cracking tune and my perfect feel-good song.


Taken from an album who's title translates to 'Taken into the Mountain - A Fairy Tale in 5 Chapters' this track really does have the ethereal beauty and mystical allure of an ancient folk tale. I'll be honest in saying that to this day I haven't a shitting clue what the lyrics of this song actually translate to and I'm sure it probably runs counter to how I perceive this lovely serenade, but I'on't give a FUCK! [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBZMsIfHQF0] To me, it?s always had a soothing aura, something I can just close my eyes to and be lulled in by the beautiful, choir-esque, layered vocal chants of Garm, simple yet smooth bass lines, catchy main riff, brief acoustic passage and majestically melodic solos until it gently fades out at the end. If I were a spiritual person I would call it meditative, but I'm not so I'll just say that it?s serene and sensational song that does wonders in keeping me in a calm state. ^_^


Oh Nick Drake, how you?ve kept me company many a lonely night. And oh how that last sentence sounds kind of dodgy out of context, given you?ve been dead for over 30 years. 0_0 ?Anyway, the song is taken from his third and final album Pink Moon, which exhibits Nick Drake at his most stripped down, most bitter and in my opinion at his best. The lyrics seem to be a prophetic glimpse into the depression that would eventually consume him and drive him to suicide. An expression of a lingering sense that with time he?s becoming ever more dispassionate with life; beaten down into a state of dejected listlessness. His voice like a low, mewling whisper set against the backdrop of the gently strum chords of his guitar, this candid approach has always given me much pause for introspection.


This song, particularly in its pacing is damn near perfect. I'm sure the immediate thoughts of detractors at this point will be that it's slow, boring, simplistic and drags on too long and well...that's perfectly okay, I can understand though I disagree with that perspective, but it is your opinion so it's not like I can tell you that you're wrong. XD But what I would posit is that this song really needs that time to blossom; to build up that atmosphere, until it slowly envelops you. As though drawn in by the ensorcelling, yet foreboding chimes emanating from a nearby cave, entering with caution, wandering alone and benighted into the depths of the catacombs, becoming more apprehensive the deeper you tread as the tortured, shrieking cries of ghosts long past echo through the caverns. Why yes, that was a rather pretentious passage wasn't it? :3 Really though, it's just the simplest of things particularly in the first five minutes that really blows my mind with this track; the transition between notes on the synths is seamless, the way the guitars are left to ring really do sound like bell chimes, giving off a tranquil, haunting aura, all slowly building up to create the perfect lead in. The timing of the drums kicking in is also exceptional being brought to the forefront of the mix at just under the 3 min mark helping to augment the tension before the guitar takes the lead and we get into the first verse. Truly, a phenomenal piece of work.


Oft considered their magnum opus, Opeth?s longest track is a poignant journey through the purview of a tragic romance. The poetic lyrics are really instrumental (lol, hurr durr) in setting the scene, lines such as ?The moonlight caresses a lonely hill, With the calmness of a whisper? lend a Victorian gothic sense of elegance to the proceedings that really bolsters the melancholic aura it strives to attain. The song is rich with numerous memorable riffs and folky acoustic passages that transition seamlessly from one to the next, silky fretless bass lines and the magnificent vocal performance of Mikael Akerfeldt; ranging from his fervidly bellowed shrieks and growls, tender singing and forlorn whispers heard throughout, all culminating in one of the most moving, passionate, enduring screams ever heard in metal.


This one really hits close to home. :( The song perfectly encompasses my feelings of regret, the time that's been carelessly squandered, how quickly the years of my life seem to be slipping away from me, more and more days passing with so many things left unaccomplished, so many aspirations fallen to the wayside and left alone to wither into ashes, just as I inevitably will like the pathetic, maladroit, dreary, despondent, talent-less wretch that I am. >.> This is further compounded with Gilmour's angry, almost condemning vocals contrasting with Waters soft, crestfallen, yet accepting tone; again rather uncannily reflecting my own mentality partly frustrated and self-flagellating for my shortcomings and partly too jaded and apathetic to care, simply resigning myself to my fate. Along with the scathing, soaring bluesy guitar solo and gospel choir also really doing their part to exacerbate these feelings. Time really is short. =/


This is a really nostalgic one for me. :) I suppose it's kind of odd that a song pertaining to heartbreak is something I think so warmly of, but it's something that my dad used to play as part of one of these soul compilations he brought along on holiday when I was a kid, (in what I suspect was a part of a plan to indoctrinate me to share his tastes :3) so I suppose it's something that's stuck with me a long time. I guess what I like is that it both reminds me of better days, or at least more innocent days before I degraded into the cold, miserable, cynical bastard that I am today, but also that it reminds me of him. And I think that as trite and saccharine as this is going to sound; when listening to this song it really does make me appreciate just what family means to me and just how comforting the thoughts of a loved one can be, which I think would help a great deal with the whole stranded on an island thing. Plus I don't think I could do this list without at least one soul song; adds a nice spice of variety which is always important.

Honourable mentions:

Amon Amarth - Valhall Awaits Me
Black Sabbath - Heaven and Hell
Brian Eno - An Ending
Emperor - The Loss and Curse of Reverence
Ennio Morricone - Deborah's Theme
Faunts - Of Nature
Flogging Molly - Drunken Lullabies
Frank Sinatra - My Way
Lynyrd Skynyrd - Free Bird
Metallica - Master of Puppets
Tool - 10,000 Days (Parts 1 and 2)
Unkle - Lonely Soul

As for what book I would take with me...I might be kind of cheating here, but I would use up both my luxury item and book for a tablet that's only accessible function is to peruse through the entirety (including the bits that are as of now unfinished) of Homestuck, enabling it me to see the flash files and music that I feel are pretty integral to the experience of this webcomic. I think that it's sheer length, levity, endearing characters and engrossing, if convoluted story would do plenty to keep me placated and it's also something from which I would have plenty of material to meticulously analyse and see things that I wouldn't have noticed the first time around, allowing me to reflect upon it in a new light.

Tl; Dr:

Alrighty, so that's what I've picked, kudos to you if you managed to slog through all of that text, you?re a trooper. ;) So now I put it to you my fellow Escapists, which 8 tracks (along with what book and luxury item if you wish) are you most comfortable listening to ad-nauseum and why?
 

SckizoBoy

Ineptly Chaotic
Legacy
Jan 6, 2011
8,681
200
68
A Hermit's Cave
OmniscientOstrich said:
Really? Nobody? Huh...well that's disappointing. >.>
Well, what did you expect posting a thread based on an old fogey BBC R4 show?!?!

Having said that (damn you Daniel deFoe for giving us this stupid program...):

1. Handel's the Messiah (Mozart's translation into the German, preferably), though if I was on the show, I'd play the opening symphony
2. Bach's Passacaglia & Fugue in C-minor, not bothered if it's the Stokowski transcription.
3. Schumann's Piano Concerto
4. Chopin's Etudes (Opus 10), playing No. 1 (fucking awesome piece for the piano)
5. Brilliant Green's Ash Like Snow, the definition of kickass (piss off!)
6. Approaching Nirvana's Dungeon of Deceit, and I haven't the faintest idea why
7. Ilaria Graziano's I Do, because she has the purest and clearest singing voice I've ever heard
8. Rob Dougan's Clubbed to Death 2, just 'cos

Book: Alexandre Dumas pere's le Comte de Monte Cristo, because it's the ultimate revenge story and goes through a whole gamut of emotion and is a literary roller coaster.

Luxury: a PC (with unlimited power supply, of course) with Microsoft Word (above all else), so I can write till my heart's content.

...

Old fogey enough for you, champ?! -_-
 

NightHawk21

New member
Dec 8, 2010
1,273
0
0
Well is there an assumption that the discs come with something to play them on? Like a stereo?

Other than that I would pick 8 songs with gigantic orchestral scores (don't care which as I don't listen to music), but something along the lines of each song >30min so they can play for days and not get repetitive (so that I could get off this stupid island in a timely manner, and initially to keep the animals away).

For my book, since the OP picked a webcomic that is continuously updating, I would pick a journal database, or if that's not allowed, access to a single scientific journal of my choosing.

As for my luxury item I would pick a big self supplying lab with all the materials necessary to harvest genetic information and grow cultures and cell lines, in addition to a good stock of other materials necessary to further my scientific experiments.
 

Guffe

New member
Jul 12, 2009
5,106
0
0
songs:
Iron Maiden: Number of the Beast
Mötley Crüe: Saints of Los Angeles
Crashdiet: Breaking the Chains
W.A.S.P.: Wild Child
Accept: Stalingrad
Rainbow: Man on the Silver Mountain
Kiss: Detroit Rock City
Stratovarius: Stratofortress

Book: Hitch hikers guide to the Galaxy the edition that has all books in one.

Luxury Item: A really big freakin' Mansion. One (HUGE) house = one thing, then I'd craft my own interior stuff from all the forest on the island.
 

Tiger Sora

New member
Aug 23, 2008
2,220
0
0
A mix of classic rock era music, a soundtrack remix from the anime movie Redline, lastly some awesome music created by the Brony community.

Best Of My Love - The Eagles
The Long And Winding Road - The Beatles
Rainbow Demon - Uriah Heep
Bruce Springsteen - Thunder Road
Doucette - Nobody
Redline Day Remix - Machinehead
Tsyolin & WoodenToaster - WoodenOverture
AcousticBrony & MandoPony - Loyalty

For my novel I'll need to chose The Hobbit by J.R.R Tolkien. The way it reads is unlike any other book I've read, thus I shall take it along.

For my luxury item... a hand crank satellite radio. I'll get signals from all over the world, keep up with news, more music, hear of peoples lives and strife. Keep myself entertained on those ohh so lonely nights. And I've no idea how to turn a radio to a transmitter so I doubt I'd be messing with it.
 

Alternative

New member
Jun 2, 2010
271
0
0
songs

1. Snot (live)- Snot
2. Stoopid - Snot
3. Absent (live) - Snot
4. Joyride -Snot
5. Getsome -Snot
6. Unplugged - Snot
7. Tecato - Snot
8. Deadfall - Snot
i may be a bit of a fan of Snot
however if i cant have those 8 songs i would have 8 Tool songs on backup

Book: Jurassic park or The Silmarilion
Luxury item: A computer with a unlimited supply of power with minecraft installed on it.
 

OmniscientOstrich

New member
Jan 6, 2011
2,879
0
0
SckizoBoy said:
OmniscientOstrich said:
Really? Nobody? Huh...well that's disappointing. >.>
Well, what did you expect posting a thread based on an old fogey BBC R4 show?!?!
Well I was thinking more along the lines that people might be familiar with the concept rather than a community mostly comprised of teenagers and 20 somethings also happening to be habitual listeners of Radio 4. :p Still thank you helping to ensure this thing didn't start growing cobwebs just yet, 'tis much appreciated. ^_^
 

neonsword13-ops

~ Struck by a Smooth Criminal ~
Mar 28, 2011
2,771
0
0
Lawl, Big List
and just to throw some more depression wood on the stranded out in the middle of no-where fire...
Skip to 0:56 for the good stuff
 

Olaf the Oaf

New member
Jun 4, 2012
18
0
0
Songs
1. Sunny Afternoon - The Kinks
2. Message in a bottle - The police
3. All Along The Watchtower - Jimi Hendrix
4. Black Rose - Thin Lizzy
5. Highwayman - Johnny Cash, Willie Nelson, Kris Kristopherson and Waylon Jennings
6. Born To Run - Bruce Springsteen
7. Tomorrow Never Knows - The Beatles
8. Spaceport - TimeSplitters Future Perfect Soundtrack


Book
The SAS survival guide. Or Robinson Crusoe well, because I'm stuck on a desert Island.

Luxury Item
An unlimited supply of notebooks and pens/pencils.
 

Total LOLige

New member
Jul 17, 2009
2,123
0
0
Songs(in no particular order)
1. Pixies - Where is my mind?
2. Kasabian - Doberman
3. Feeder - Yesterday Went Too Soon
4. Stone Roses - Sally Cinnamon
5. The Who - I Can See For Miles
6. Smashing Pumpkins - Muzzle
7. Feeder - Radiation
8. Pixies - Hey

A Book
Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy

Luxury Item
A mountain of pornography An unlimited supply of Kendal mint cake.
 

xplosive59

New member
Jul 20, 2009
969
0
0
OmniscientOstrich said:
Really? Nobody? Huh...well that's disappointing. >.>
Devin Townsend - Bastard (The main riff is probably one of the best ever recorded, also pure atmosphere and absolutely crushing).

Cynic - Textures (Probably the best example of a Metal/Jazz hybrid other than Trioscapes).

Frank Zappa - Apostraphe (pretty much a jam session with a memorable riff and an amazing bassline).

Burzum - Det Som En Gang Var (Pretty much the ultimate black metal track, guitars like chainsaws, an ethereal atmosphere and pure melody).

X Japan - Art Of Life (kinda cheating here as the song is just under half an hour long and takes up the entire album, but my god is it good, an avant-garde speed metal masterpiece).

Soft Machine - Moon In June (Awesome 20 minute Prog-Rock/Jazz piece that you need to listen to multiple times before you understand parts of it).

Pink Floyd - Echoes (Need I say anything really? This is the absolute defining Floyd track!).

Nokturnal Mortum - Valkyrie (Very powerful Black Metal track, proves that even newer Black Metal is still as good as the early 90's).

Book: An Encyclopedia, for knowlege.

Luxury Item: Acoustic guitar and Plectrum.
 

ItsAChiaotzu

New member
Apr 20, 2009
1,496
0
0
1. Nightingale - The Reign of Kindo
2. No God - The Dear Hunter
3. Lillian - The Dear Hunter
4. We've Got A Score to Settle - The Dear Hunter
5. When I Met Death - Right Away, Great Captain
6. Stargasm - Mastodon
7. Passion - Utada Hikaru
8. Call Me Maybe - Carly Rae Jepsen

Book: Hard to say, probably a really good joke book, can't imagine needing any other book more than that if I was stranded.

Luxury item: Some very nice Taylor or Martin acoustic guitar, just to relax with.
 

OmniscientOstrich

New member
Jan 6, 2011
2,879
0
0
xplosive59 said:
OmniscientOstrich said:
Really? Nobody? Huh...well that's disappointing. >.>
Devin Townsend - Bastard (The main riff is probably one of the best ever recorded, also pure atmosphere and absolutely crushing).

Cynic - Textures (Probably the best example of a Metal/Jazz hybrid other than Trioscapes).

Burzum - Det Som En Gang Var (Pretty much the ultimate black metal track, guitars like chainsaws, an ethereal atmosphere and pure melody).

Pink Floyd - Echoes (Need I say anything really? This is the absolute defining Floyd track
Some really awesome picks there. :3 I haven't heard the other half of your selections so I'll have to give them a look up. And on a side note; in regard to Metal/Jazz Fusion groups, I would reccomend checking out Exivious if you aren't already aware of them.

ToTaL LoLiGe said:
A mountain of pornography
Hey, I won't judge. ;) It's gonna be pretty damn lonely on that island. XD
 

SckizoBoy

Ineptly Chaotic
Legacy
Jan 6, 2011
8,681
200
68
A Hermit's Cave
OmniscientOstrich said:
Well I was thinking more along the lines that people might be familiar with the concept rather than a community mostly comprised of teenagers and 20 somethings also happening to be habitual listeners of Radio 4. :p Still thank you helping to ensure this thing didn't start growing cobwebs just yet, 'tis much appreciated. ^_^
Hey, I'm a 20-something and a habitual listener of Radio 4... FFS, I wake up to Today, listen to News Quiz as much as I can, and actualy enjoy the Write Stuff... and incidentally, last week's episode was about Daniel deFoe, so go figure! -_-

Granted, I listen to their more niche panel shows, and seem to have a pseudo-mancrush on Jeremy Hardy's disembodied voice, but give us some credit! ¬_¬

ToTaL LoLiGe said:
An unlimited supply of Kendal mint cake.
...?! Do you want a dentist to go with that, or shall we just pull your teeth out now?! Gawd, I haven't had that stuff in ages...
 

Total LOLige

New member
Jul 17, 2009
2,123
0
0
SckizoBoy said:
ToTaL LoLiGe said:
An unlimited supply of Kendal mint cake.
...?! Do you want a dentist to go with that, or shall we just pull your teeth out now?! Gawd, I haven't had that stuff in ages...
Hmmm Maybe. When my teeth fall out I'll just gum it. I'll make some dental supplies from desert island materials.
 

xplosive59

New member
Jul 20, 2009
969
0
0
OmniscientOstrich said:
Some really awesome picks there. :3 I haven't heard the other half of your selections so I'll have to give them a look up. And on a side note; in regard to Metal/Jazz Fusion groups, I would reccomend checking out Exivious if you aren't already aware of them.
Thanks for the recommendation :) I havn't heard of them before (not really looked into Cynic sode projects) but this is awesome from what I have heard so far.

If you are looking for something simular to Ocean Machine btw I suggest The Omega Experiment http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5L6jJlcgUXg&feature=related these guys supported Devin a while back and were actually really good.
 

RanD00M

New member
Oct 26, 2008
6,947
0
0
Can't find it on youtube. Shame




I will not pick an 8th song for I feel that these seven should suffice.

Books. Well I'm not much a reading man, but Dante's Inferno seeing as how I have all the time in the world to get through it.

I would chose a good carving knife for a luxury item provided I get a stone to sharpen it on. If not then a bottle of Cognac, I want to go out in style.
 

shrekfan246

Not actually a Japanese pop star
May 26, 2011
6,374
0
0
OmniscientOstrich said:
I realize that it's part of the spirit of the game, but I have to question why I only get 8 songs when I have an MP3 player that's smaller than two of my fingers which can hold over 800 songs.

But to not be a party-pooper:

Perfect for sitting on a sandy beach, watching a sunset.
Yes, I will stubbornly refuse to take any one of the parts by itself.

As for what book I would take, probably a fictional collection that included The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings trilogy, and The Silmarillion all bundled together.

Luxury item? Well, assuming I'm allowed the ability to summon any one magical item of my wishing, either an attractive person of the female persuasion, or a laptop with an undying battery, an unlimited hard drive, and an amazingly good Internet connection for being stuck on an island in the middle of nowhere. Which... could kind of invalidate the whole "Only 8 songs" thing too, I imagine...
 

Fiz_The_Toaster

books, Books, BOOKS
Legacy
Jan 19, 2011
5,498
1
3
Country
United States
Song3:
1. Marilyn Manson- No Reflection
2. Bach- Toccata and Fugue in D Minor
3. Borodin- Polovtsian Dances
4. Vivaldi- Four Seasons
5. Iron Maiden- Phantom of the Opera
6. Ozzy Osbourne- Let Me Hear You Scream
7. Bach- Violin Concerto in E Major
8. Corelli- Christmas Concerto

Book? Alexandre Dumas Count of Monte Cristo. I love that book and I've read that book many many times and I wouldn't mind reading it for a long time, it's so good.

Luxury item, let me see... a knife. My dad taught me to always carry a knife when I'm traveling and out and about, you never know when you're gonna need one.