I still play it, they ruined PVP for a lot of players, but I didn't even use it that much so I don't care. The graphics are far better then when I first started. It doesn't have anything on other MMOs, but they're nice enough now. The holiday events provide enough intuitive for me come back every Christmas, Halloween, Thanksgiving, Easter, and the occasional April Fools Day event. The quests are still beautifully done. Your skills level up when you use them, none of that lvling your combat lvl crap from most other MMOs and a wonderful crafting system to compliment it. Censors have been toned down. ...and a new skill just came out.
Did I cover everyone's complaints?
Edit: New Skill is f2p, and I've never paid for membership.