I appreciate that Bob had the guts to say it: Sissy Spacek is a plain girl and Chloe is not. So, her outcast role doesn't fit. At best, they could go for the "She's All That" thing: have her undolled up, and then let her shine through.
EDIT: A girl can add so much to herself to make herself desirable, including attitude. I mean no disrespect to Ms. Spacek.
But, they didn't even try to make Chloe plain. And it would have been hard work to try. She just doesn't fit here.
But She is very plain. She CAN doll herself up. Even by the end of Carrie, she looks nice. But she is still a plain girl dolled up enough to look nice.bartholen said:Sissy Spacek wasn't a swamp witch either. Just look up some pictures from her early career, she's a fine looking lady. The problem here, as Bob mentioned, is the direction. And it has to be the direction, because Grace-Moretz was just in Kick-Ass 2 where she played for most of the movie a high school reject, and she did it really well. The devil's in the details like make-up, mannerisms and body language.
EDIT: A girl can add so much to herself to make herself desirable, including attitude. I mean no disrespect to Ms. Spacek.
But, they didn't even try to make Chloe plain. And it would have been hard work to try. She just doesn't fit here.