Favorite incarnation of The Doctor?

[Mikodite]

(Im thinking f the new series)

Which number is his pony form?

Only saw half of Ep 1 on netflix. I really need to watch the rest.

Matt Smith, the eleventh one. I've seen pics of Doctor Whooves in the bow-tie, that's how I know. There were a few circulating wore a necktie and had brown eyes (so tenth one?), but he's usually eleven.

christopher eccleson, its a shame he didnt last long, I liked him because he was how I pictured a modern doctor being

david tennant just felt..I dont know I couldnt take him seriously

To each their own I guess, but I actually found Ecclesion annoying. His performance seemed forced and I did not like that he was dressed like Julian from Trailer Park Boys. I also didn't like how the bullshit "could the Doctor fall in love" subplot started with him... and don't get me started on Jack. I know the last point the actor couldn't control, but for god's sake he wasn't the right man for the job without a shoddy concept.

 

[Vault101]

(Im thinking f the new series)

Which number is his pony form?

Only saw half of Ep 1 on netflix. I really need to watch the rest.

Matt Smith, the eleventh one. I've seen pics of Doctor Whooves in the bow-tie, that's how I know. There were a few circulating wore a necktie and had brown eyes (so tenth one?), but he's usually eleven.

christopher eccleson, its a shame he didnt last long, I liked him because he was how I pictured a modern doctor being

david tennant just felt..I dont know I couldnt take him seriously

To each their own I guess, but I actually found Ecclesion annoying. His performance seemed forced and I did not like that he was dressed like Julian from Trailer Park Boys. I also didn't like how the bullshit "could the Doctor fall in love" subplot started with him... and don't get me started on Jack. I know the last point the actor couldn't control, but for god's sake he wasn't the right man for the job without a shoddy concept.

I actually liked how he was dressed, david tennants outfelt felt a bit "been there, done that"

anyway I think they would have explored the whole "doctor romance" thing whoever played him..I just wish they would cut it out..its annoying

 

[Robert Ewing]

I'm tempted to say Tom Baker... But that just incites my rookie journalistic instinct to chose the one I grew up with, so therefore he is the best... and I hate that.

So I'm going to go with David Tennant. He was a wonderful doctor, probably the defining one of this generation if I'm not too bold.

 

[MercurySteam]

I've liked all three of the newest Doctors since 2005. Christopher Eccleston, David Tennant and Matt Smith all provide awesome images of The Doctor.

(Im thinking f the new series)

Which number is his pony form?

Only saw half of Ep 1 on netflix. I really need to watch the rest.

The Tenth Doctor, David Tennant.

The fuzzy mane reminds me of No. 10's hair and brown coat probably represents, well, his brown coat:

 

[Rylot]

While I liked Eccleston he never really got a chance nor the budget to compete with either Tennant or Smith. Tennant is probably my favorite despite the dodgy stories in his second season. Smith has grown on me and I like most of his storylines but he still seems so goofy and cocky at the same time that I can't fully take his character seriously, though it has gotten better for the second season.

 

[TheLastSamurai14]

Seems like everyone loves Tennant? Good to know, because I'm thinking of getting into the series and I want to start at a high point.

I do remember watching a single Tenth Doctor episode about 5 years back and liking it a bunch, so I'll give it a go and see how it turns out.

 

[Mikodite]

The Ninth Doctor, David Tennant.

The fuzzy mane reminds me of No. 9's hair and brown coat probably represents, well, his brown coat.

Unless you don't count Paul McGann David Tennant is the tenth Doctor. Its in his name if you need a memory aid. Christopher Eccleston's nine.

And the Whooves pic is not Tennant because the eyes are the wrong colour.

 

[MercurySteam]

Unless you don't count Paul McGann David Tennant is the tenth Doctor. Its in his name if you need a memory aid. Christopher Eccleston's nine.

Yeah, so I forgot a tiny detail. Have me hanged, drawn and quartered if it makes you feel any better. And no I didn't forget Paul McGann. The Doctor Who movie was surprisingly good.

And the Whooves pic is not Tennant because the eyes are the wrong colour.

I'm not saying it all lines up, but if you can find a better example then please do share, though I'm only going off what's been said on the MLP Wikia:

His spiky brown mane and his hourglass cutie mark lend him the appearance of the Tenth Doctor from the popular British TV series Doctor Who, though the resemblance is a coincidence

Posting that pic was a bit extreme, wasn't it? You really do take this shit seriously.

 

[VoidWanderer]

David Tennant. Matt Smith is okay, but because he has Rory, Matt loses points...

 

[TimeLord]

(Im thinking f the new series)

Which number is his pony form?

Only saw half of Ep 1 on netflix. I really need to watch the rest.

10th. Most fans see him as Tennant and most fanfics are written from 10s point of view and on 10s style.

OT: Hard choice. 9 introduced me to Doctor Who. 10 and 11 are both awesome in their own way. I suppose 10 is my favourite, but give Smith another series or two...

I don't have to choose! I have them all on DVD/Blu-ray!

 

[Introspector]

In order; Paul McGann, David Tennant then John Pertwee. I quite like Patrick Troughton, that loveable tramp.

 

[Knight Captain Kerr]

I would say 11th is my favourite followed closely by 10th.

 

[Tanis]

I do love Tom Baker, thank you PBS.
But Tennant is/was a fantastic Doctor.

Also:
Paul McGann (8th) got shafted - his audio books have been great.

 

[SckizoBoy]

The fourth Doctor. I love Tom Baker's eccentrically whimsical approach to the character:

Spoiler

Ha! I'm not a big fan of the Doctor, so I'll answer for my old man. ^^ Good ol' Tom Baker and his bizarre love for jelly babies! XD

 

[Wintermoot]

(Im thinking f the new series)

Which number is his pony form?

Only saw half of Ep 1 on netflix. I really need to watch the rest.

I think the 11th
OT 9th or 10th

 

[Mikodite]

Posting that pic was a bit extreme, wasn't it? You really do take this shit seriously.

Screwing up the order of the actors isn't exactly world destroying, but its kinda insulting to a fan. A fan of the series should know better.

10th. Most fans see him as Tennant and most fanfics are written from 10s point of view and on 10s style.

I find that odd as that pony looks more like Smith. I mean, crazy brown hair? Check, brown coat? Check (I do believe that tweet jacket he wears is brown). Blue eyes?

Fucking check!

I know there are whooves pics where he does in fact have brown eyes (making him Tennant) but that pic is Smith.

 

[The_root_of_all_evil]

In order 4,11,9,5,2,8,7,10,6,3,1

but that can change by my mood.

 

[Jenitals]

So far, David Tennant, with his big eyes and tallness and not-too-much-but-just-right manliness and the hair :3

On a side-note the acting was good and the character was well-played.