Raso719 said:
That was a good response. At the end of the day my criticisms are more about the lack of substance I perceive in your average anime Mech battle; as I was saying in Code Gease, at the start taking fire was an issue, cover was important, quick tactical moves using the rollerskates were used to out-flank etc etc. However, by the end everyone was flying and magically evading all incoming fire indefinitely - there was no sense to danger, or threat, they just magically never got hit, relying on huge quantities of plot armour whilst they slaughtered the nameless hordes of grunts around them. I just find it hard to get too excited about that sort of thing.
I've watched my fair share of anime and know that that sort of hero worship is pretty much the thing they do, but because I don't like it and it's become so entrenched with the mecha design the two are synonymous. As soon as you see those exaggerated eye-brow whiskers, you just know it's going to be a pretty-light-spitting, untouchable, flying, mass-murdering magic machine piloted by a teen suffering from an identity crisis, not a mech with substance and weight that will make even a semblance of an attempt at maintaining internal logic with the rest of it's universe.
What I'm more interested in are not
realistic mechs - as you pointed out, we're talking about giant robots (that chicks may or may not dig) - but mechs that maintain a logic and limitations with the universe that they're in, without using handwavium or unobtanium to make a couple with are literally infinitely more powerful than any other object in the entire universe. I must confess to having watched only one of the long Gundam series all the way through, but from the odd episode of other series I've seen, if you have a mech with a weapon that can literally slice a full-sized space battleship in half, why don't you give more mechs similar weapons and slice ALL of their battleships in half, rather than just the one? 'Gundanium alloy' surely doesn't affect the powersources for weapons that you can have available? Same with beam cannons whose shots are visible from outside of the galaxy. Give EVERYONE one of those and I'm pretty sure the war would be over pretty sharpish, one way or another.
I can enjoy something for the fun of it, sure, but in the same way the Power Rangers wouldn't be on my list of best warriors, Gundams are a long way from my list of best mechs.