So.. yeah, my favourite Final Fantasy.
Weak characters? Seriously, no idea what everyones ranting about. Non-awesome characters, maybe, but these are my favourite characters in any FF, ever. I don't know if everyone merely judges FF characters purely on their base-concept or what, but judging them by their interactions, I was on the edge of my seat to see what happened next. Main plot could get stuffed (but thankfuly, was being driven in large by those interactions, so all the better), I was (for the first time in an FF, ever, to my memory), getting non-exposition character development, and it was good. And best of all the characters were anything but cool and awesome, they were a bunch of admirably developed normals and idiots in a situation over their heads, and the whole game revolved around that.
The combat system? Eh, I enjoyed it. No more nor less than that of any other FF.. okay maybe I enjoyed it a bit more, but only because the character power levels were for once deeply rooted in the plot rather than hand-waved in, and thus didn't hurt believability.
The story? I loved it. No, it wasn't epic-for-epic's-own-sake (for once, thank god); for once it was primarily about the characters; hell, everything was about the characters. One boss fight, I honestly agreed with the enemy's motivations for killing the protagonists. They were fighting purely for their own survival and hoping against hope they could find a way out of their situation instead of just giving up. Even the character power levels made sense in context, for once.
Music? It was nice. No, not FF standard I admit, but still, this is the only point I will ever admit was lacking.
Until FF XIII, for me, the Final Fantasy's were a bunch of epic-for-epic's-sake stories with flat characters, good music, nice opening ideas and some pretty visuals. In other words, they were the videogame equivalent of pre-Dune, non-pulp sci-fi novels, and I hope against hope that they learn a bit from the character and story of Final Fantasy XIII, instead of giving us another whiny nit surrounded by a bunch of McAwesomes of no inherent value bar being there to shove the epic along, that are only good characters by concept with zilch in the active development department.
.. Man I am so gonna get flamed. Oh well, to cover myself a bit, my experience with Final Fantasy is 1, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12. They were fun to play, but nothing special in more than base setting concept and aesthetics. I understand six possesses some of the things I value in an RPG, however, so that'll be my next port of call.
Final Fantasy XIII's staying firmly in my collection.