ScatterBen said:
First: Don't make this so personal. I don't know you and I don't have any beef with you, and I didn't call it a "steaming pile of shit." I called it a development nightmare, which Square-Enix has openly stated that it was. Although, yes, it is a steaming pile of shit.
Second: Tactics is a decent game. Not dissing their past projects, I'm just saying that the main series isn't their thing, which is an honest thing to say. It's just not the type of game they're comfortable designing. It's like having the guys behind the Prince of Persia games make a Grand Theft Auto title, it's a bad idea and it goes against their strengths.
Third: Kitase produced it. He didn't direct it, like he did with past games in the series. He also produces many of the other games Square makes, but that doesn't mean he's the chief creative or systems director for all of them. Nomura did the character designs for the main party members, but not any of the other characters, which fell on the FF12 character artists. The two of them are involved to the extent that they have their names attached to it, and that's basically it. I'm low on proof that Kitase wasn't as directly involved in 13 as he was in previous games, but I feel like I can be reasonably certain of that given that it shows none of the storytelling or game design trademarks of his or Nomura's past games, showing a style more akin to that of FF12 and The Last Remnant--which is the Tactics team. The original FF team as a whole, meanwhile--which is a lot more important than just the two of them--has been working on Kingdom Hearts, the FF7 spinoffs, and Versus 13. So, no, they didn't head this one up. It was definitely the FF12 team again.
Fourth: I don't blame the FF12 team, I blame CEO Yoroichi Wada, the Japanese Bobby Kotick, for his blatant mis-management of Square's assets.
Fifth: Are you aware at how angry Nomura is about the business decisions behind FF13, and how he's threatened to leave the company if Wada forces them to cross-platform Versus 13 in the middle of development? The company's not looking good right now, and I wouldn't be shocked if by the end of V13's development Nomura left for Mistwalker. The writing's on the wall. Check out the article on Versus 13 they published here about a month ago--the one where Nomura states that "although HD graphics are difficult for us to deal with, we're doing our damndest to deliver a game as good as the old ones" (paraphrasing) as opposed to FF13 director Motomu Toriyama's near-constant stream of excuses when it comes to HD graphics and the linearity of the game and its lack of content. If that wasn't an indirect slam on Toriyama, I don't know what was.
If you don't mind, now, I'd appreciate it if you edited your post so as to not publicly call me a liar.