Ampersand said:
The first missunderstanding you have is that you seem to think that athiesm is some sort of oganisation that is ploting against religious groups, that is not nor has it ever been the case. What I stand for ( and what every athiest i've ever met have stood for) is educations. Improving people knowledge and understanding of the world, and it has been religious groups who have stood in opposition to that for thousand of years. It's only when religious groups start actively retarding the progress of man kind of man kind for the sake of perpetuating their own personal beliefs (or worse, interfering with the education of young children) that I start having a problem with them.
Secondly: I've never seen anyone become a better person as a result of finding religion, however i've seen alot of people become better people as a result of loosing religion. In my experience as soon as people realise that they no longer blindly follow dogma they obtain a much better understanding of what is actually wrong and what's right, (I know i did).
Saying that religion makes people more moral is like saying that the death penalty makes people more moral, It just keep people afraid so that they behave themselves. Religion great if you want to keep people under your thumb or motivate them to go to war but from a moral stand point it's utterly useless.
thirdly: "There is not a single person I know who has ever had a fear of God" That is wrong, plain and simple. I'm only 20 years old so the worst of this was over before i was born but i've seen people do aweful things out of fear of god. I've seen people hate and ridicule other groups of people and even kill because they're afraid that if they don't it will compromise thier beliefs.
Also it's not just that people are afraid of thier god either, many people like that they think they understand the world and are terrified that they might find out that they don't, it can make people very agressive and even dangerous.
I don't know where you live but if you've never seen this it must be a very nice place.
I take no pleasure in telling you this but you're wrong about that. ( I wish it was just a line)
Fourth: You can't do something in the name of athiesm, that doesn't make sence. By it's definition it is the default position of all consious living things (we are all born athiest)
However religion is an invention of man kind, it can be used as a tool. It can be used to build something(on a foundation of falsehood and fear) or it can be used to reek unimaginable destruction and suffering, which it has done many times. In my opinion that is a tool we don't need. There are alot of much better ones that don't have as high a cost.
Finally(this is getting long, frankly I wouldn't blame you if you haven't read this far.)
No i certainly did not know what the caste system was.
I would ask you to never( and i mean never) dare to say that war is part of human nature. Because first of all it isn't true and secondly that kind of attitude on a global scale is part of what enable it to continue. Ego and greed can be part of human nature and they can leed to war but as hard as it may be they can be overcome.
I've studied war and martial arts for years and the only thing it's tought me is that fighting is hard, distructive (inconvenient) and ultimatly pointless.
I'm not that smart, if I can figure out, that violence the worst way of resolving a conflict, then anybody can And the more people who reasize this the closer we will be to being free from it.
I'd ask you to please think about that because to me there arn't alot of things more important.
No, I don't think that. But, it is fast becoming what you think it isn't. And I agree with you to an extent; atheism should be a personal choice, something that revolves around you beliefs in a complex and tricky field. However, it's just becoming another religion, and organisation that suffers blindness, hypocrisy and dangerous zealotism. It saddens me to say that, it really does, but it's true. It's now being described as a "movement". A fucking movement? Most of the people who
actively identify as atheist are anti-religion, and, despite their dear-held beliefs, are actually morons with no capacity to think on such a grand scale.
And I still don't see where you're coming from with the whole "Religion is in the way of understanding the world". How? The only things I can think religion has ever stood in the way of recently is a tiny sliver of stem cell research, and that hardly affected the overall research. Besides, humans will never understand. It's kind of funnyand kind of sad that we think we ever will. How arrogant.
Man, you've got to stop trotting out the "afraid of God" thing, because it doesn't exist. Maybe in the Dark Ages, but sure as shit not any more. It's utterly ridiculous that you can claim religion cannot motivate a person to become more moral. Mother Theresa is a grandiose example here, but fits. Your death pentalty analogy is flawed as
noone is scared of God/punishment.
So, you're saying my personal experience is wrong? My life, the people I know and what I've seen is
wrong? That's a hefty claim there buddy. I've got no idea where you're from, since you haven't felt like putting your country on your profile, but down where I live, there is no "fear of God", anywhere. Hell, I don't think there ever has been in our history. "...many people like that they think they understand the world and are terrified that they might find out that they don't, it can make people very agressive and even dangerous." Jesus, I think you just described a shitload of atheists there. That's true of anyone dumb enough to think they hold solid answers. The fact is that I haven't. Between priests, nuns, everyday Churchgoers and people of different faiths, I can honestly say I've never met someone with a fear of God. That goes for this country and others I've visited. It's just not the way religion works here.
Bullshit. The minute the fundie faggots turned atheism into a movement, a "cause", you can do something in the name of it. I've seen people burn down Churches and attack people in the name of atheism. How does it feel being judged on the actions of someone who identifies in the same area as you on a philosophical and theological level but bear no other similarities? Because that's what I go through every time some dipshit tells me I hate gays, or want to spread AIDS, or some other nonsense.
Religion is highly capeable of good, and the general lack of willingness to see that troubles me, always has. It's like there's just a general urge to demonise it; let alone the compulsion to ignore how it works on an individual level. All the charity, social support, the community built, these are all poitives. I've never seen a fight over religion, not once. The worst I ever see is the fucking bogans trying to cast Muslims out of our country, and I can tell you what, they're sure as hell not religious.
Thr caste system is disgusting and I cannot believe it exists in our day an age. But it is not my culture and not my right to do anything.
I'm sorry, but it's true. I understand your personal feelings on the matter but I respectfully disagree. War is inevitable. It has never been about resolving conflict. Children fight. It is natural. Unfortunate, but natural. You know, like suicide or something. Humans love fighting. Conflict isn't used to resolve other conflict, it's used to gain something. Ego hardly ever comes into it. We will never be free from war, global or local. Fuck, the best we can hope for on a global scale is a stalemate, but that just leads to Cold Wars. As long as there are two groups in the world, there will be fighting.