I think the only genre I've really fallen out with over the years has been FPS games. They just went in a direction that really didn't interest me at all.
I can sort of relate, I was just getting into the genre when suddenly all the aspect of it I liked started disappearing.Clive Howlitzer said:I think the only genre I've really fallen out with over the years has been FPS games. They just went in a direction that really didn't interest me at all.
Can you elaborate on that OP?remnant_phoenix said:My guess is that studying the art of storytelling in college (creative writing major here) soured me on a LOT of video game storytelling. It becomes exceedingly apparent how poor video game story writing is when you've studied the craft, and the JRPG genre is one of the biggest offenders.
Thanks for the feedback.Fox12 said:I don't typically like to quote the OP, but I felt like saying that your post pretty much nailed down my experience, right down to the college major. That said, the Persona series really reignited my love of the genre. It's not Faulkner, that's certain, but it's clear that the creators put a ton of though into the themes of their games. Personas, shadows, Jungian archtypes, mythology, religion, and a million other things for lit nerds (like myself) to gush over. I would certainly recommend getting around to it, as it was the first JRPG in ten years to hook me. Also, kind of a random recommendation, but if you haven't played Silent Hill 2, then I would try it out. If you're anything like me then you'll have a blast going through the layers of symbolism.remnant_phoenix said:Granted, I haven't played any of the Persona games yet (on my backlog, I swear!), so maybe that's what I need to appreciate the genre again.
Anyway, I find myself going wherever the story is. Right now it seems to be in action RPG's and Adventure Games. That means a lot of Dark Souls, Mass Effect, Naughty Dog, and Telltale. I've also tried some VN, with mixed results. Japan seems to be stepping up its game (finally!) so this may change in the coming generation.
Honestly, I'll just tell you what I've told other people. Watch a mature lets play, and then visit the wiki or watch the lore videos. It's got a pretty active community, kind of like dark souls. Just don't take anyone's word as gospel. I love Matt and Patt, for instance, but they got a lot wrong.remnant_phoenix said:And yeah, I've heard a lot about how Silent Hill 2 employs storytelling in a way that is unique to the video game medium. Me being who I am, that sounds like just my kind of thing, except that I have a very finicky relationship with survival horror.
When I said that "the JRPG genre is one of the biggest offenders", what I meant is what you said: that most, but not all, are badly written.Lazule said:Can you elaborate on that OP?remnant_phoenix said:My guess is that studying the art of storytelling in college (creative writing major here) soured me on a LOT of video game storytelling. It becomes exceedingly apparent how poor video game story writing is when you've studied the craft, and the JRPG genre is one of the biggest offenders.
I'm quite interested. To me not all J-RPGs are badly written but most indeed are... *cough* all Final Fantasies *cough* except for maybe Final Fantasy Tactics which is supposedly based on the historical: "War of the Roses".