Gamer identity: what is a "gamer"?

Recommended Videos

Stephen St.

New member
May 16, 2012
131
0
0
Hey everyone.

This is a topic that, in light of the recent GG discussions, has given me a bit of thought. But not for the usual reasons, so this is not a GG, a feminism, or social justice thread. This is a thread about what games mean for us and what calling ourselves "gamers" is supposed to communicate.

So a gamer is someone who plays games. That's simple, but it's also not an identity per-se. You can define yourself by something you do, of course, but this doing something must then be somewhat central to the way you see yourself. And with regard to gaming, I find it actually somewhat problematic to call myself a gamer. Not because I don't spend a lot of my time gaming. Not because gaming doesn't shape the way I organize my free time. But rather because gaming does these things, and I am never sure if this was and is something positive that I should elevate to something of an identity.

Gaming has been a major part of my life, but it has also been a major time sink, and as such I hold it responsible for some major failings in my life. I do sometimes wonder what I could have done with all that free time that I invested in some savegame that is forever lost, or some MMORPG that I no longer play. This makes me conflicted about defining myself in any way with recourse to games, i.e. saying that I am a "gamer". I am not sure what I would like to communicate with that, because for me it carries the implication that I waste a lot of time. It's an accurate description, but hardly something I'd like to write into my resume.

So does anyone else feel conflicted about being a "gamer" in a similar way? What do you think has gaming done for you? What would you like people to think of you when you call yourself a gamer?
 

Aurion

New member
Dec 21, 2012
79
0
0
Nope. The perception/"identity" that goes along with being called a "gamer" that you mention is externally imposed.

I really don't care very much what someone thinks of me characterizing myself as a gamer (I enjoy video games, sue me), as cold as that may sound. If they want to stereotype me, that's their problem.
 

PsychedelicDiamond

Wild at Heart and weird on top
Legacy
Jan 30, 2011
2,197
1,102
118
Really, it's just someone who regularly plays video games. Period. Personally I think gamer as it is used in the media is mostly a marketing term to project the image of some sort of hip, exclusive subculture but that's just not what it is. Sure, some are more experienced and therefore more knowledgeable about video games than others but that doesn't make it part of some shared identity.

Video games are a medium and like every other medium it has a passionate audience who appreciate it for different things, be it entertainment, escapism or artistic value. But there are no requirements other than playing video games to be a gamer.

I mean, I am also a film enthusiast and a lover of good literature and music but I also treat those as hobbies rather than as an identity.
 

Zhukov

The Laughing Arsehole
Dec 29, 2009
13,769
5
43
Depending on context, a person who plays games or a person who plays games and identifies themselves as a gamer.

Anything beyond that is waffle.
 

tippy2k2

Beloved Tyrant
Legacy
Mar 15, 2008
14,870
2,349
118
A gamer is someone who plays video games and wishes to identify themselves as such

That's it

Something that I think the "Hardcore" (which I feel has taken over what "Gamer" used to mean) need to realize at this point is that gaming is no longer the niche hobby that it used to be. You no longer have to fight a computer to get a game to work. You no longer have to worry about games being far too complicated for a normal person to use. You no longer need to sink a ton of time and money into the hobby in order to get some use from it.

Gaming at this point is becoming as mainstream as TV, movies, and books. Just like you don't have TVers, moviers, and bookers, the term gamer is quickly becoming unnecessary.

Gamers are dead; long live gaming
 

Dragonbums

Indulge in it's whiffy sensation
May 9, 2013
3,307
0
0
Someone who loves playing videogames. That's it.

KazuhiraMiller said:
And no, "Gamer" as an identity is not exclusive, rather it's inclusive
It's a nice thought, but it's simply not true.

Every other month there is a new enemy of gaming and gamers.

One day it's "bro gamers" ruining videogames, then it was "fake geek girls", then eventually it was casuals ruining gaming, and then other days it's "feminazis" and SJW's.

For a group that considers itself inclusive, it sure likes to make divisive enemies revolving around playstyle, personal viewpoints, and how genres.
 

J.McMillen

Senior Member
Sep 11, 2008
247
0
21
tippy2k2 said:
A gamer is someone who plays video games and wishes to identify themselves as such
Fixed that for you.

Some gamers are taking about tabletop games, not video games. I've met plenty of them over the years, my self included.
 

shrekfan246

Not actually a Japanese pop star
May 26, 2011
6,374
0
0
"Gamer" is whatever you make of it.

Unfortunately, far too many "gamers" seem to believe that it means "you must devote your entire life to video games and the video game industry, and anything less renders you 'casual'". Basically, that comparison above about Trekkies and "gamers" is not a proper equivalence, because "gamer" is a far more general term and shouldn't just be used for enthusiast consumers.

Yeah, I don't really call myself a "gamer". I don't feel indignant outrage whenever somebody "attacks" my hobby. I don't think that the curse of mobile gaming is going to hamstring the industry. I don't believe that Nintendo should die because they only make kiddie games (that's a can of worms we shouldn't get into). I don't feel that the only way to express my negative feelings toward a company is to FOREVER BOYCOTT ALL THEIR THINGS EVER!!! I don't believe that the only "true way" to play PC games is by manually soldering together your own tower so that you can play games at 4k resolution and 500 FPS. I'm sick to death of this really entitled belief that physical game stores need to die out so that everything can go digital, because everything is basically already digital anyway and a large number of people can't handle the size of modern games on their internet; advocating for the killing of an entire section of product isn't the way to protect consumers.

And those are just the nice things I could say about "gamer" stereotypes. Sure, sure, #notallgamers, blah-de-blah, but I'm still not going to bring up video games in casual conversation with somebody if I don't know they play them. And I'll generally let them get that nugget of information out by themselves. I really just can't be bothered with all of the negative connotations anymore. Nobody else ruined the term "gamers" than "gamers" alone.
 

small

New member
Aug 5, 2014
469
0
0
to be honest i used to say its just a term that describes someone who plays games, but yeah lately its starting to have a gut negative reaction
 

Stephen St.

New member
May 16, 2012
131
0
0
Well thanks for all the replies so far!

Zhukov said:
Depending on context, a person who plays games or a person who plays games and identifies themselves as a gamer.

Anything beyond that is waffle.
Sure, but what does "identify themselves as a gamer" mean? What are the attributes of a gamer?

Aurion said:
Nope. The perception/"identity" that goes along with being called a "gamer" that you mention is externally imposed.

I really don't care very much what someone thinks of me characterizing myself as a gamer (I enjoy video games, sue me), as cold as that may sound. If they want to stereotype me, that's their problem.
Well, it might have been externally imposed for the longest time, but hasn't that changed recently? Many people seem to want to take this identity and turn it into something positive for themselves.
 

Zhukov

The Laughing Arsehole
Dec 29, 2009
13,769
5
43
Stephen St. said:
Well thanks for all the replies so far!

Zhukov said:
Depending on context, a person who plays games or a person who plays games and identifies themselves as a gamer.

Anything beyond that is waffle.
Sure, but what does "identify themselves as a gamer" mean?
It means they say, "I am a gamer", or something to that effect.
 

ron1n

New member
Jan 28, 2013
401
0
0
It's generalising word that has ceased to have any relevant meaning now days.

If you break it down to the most basic meaning of: 'someone who plays games' It becomes too watered down because the vast majority of people under (lets say 35) are probably going to play games of one sort of another on a semi-regular basis in their lives.

It's been pointed out before, but you don't call people who watch films 'movie watchers' because film has become so commonplace in our culture that everyone not living under a rock will probably see films in their life.


If you take it to the other extreme and say it refers to 'enthusiasts' or 'hardcore players' it's equally as useless as even in the community of those who may consider themselves 'enthusiasts' you are going to have a multitude of vastly different sub-groups and wildly varying personalities.

For example: A competitive SC2 players vs an anime obsessed Nintendo fan. The only thing the word possibly ties together is the fact they might both spend more than X hours playing games. Otherwise, completely different beasts.

Unless you are referring to something as universally popular as say a Convention, it's always being used incorrectly in my opinion.
 

Mahemium

New member
Apr 18, 2013
19
0
0
Well, I always thought "Gamer" was a term similar to "Film Buff", "Metalhead" or "Football Fanatic" to differentiate from the average fan, in that it's a primary hobby and passion. I just thought because the medium is becoming increasingly mainstream, it's kind of a non-sequitur for the average player of games to identify as a "Gamer" just as it doesn't make much sense for the average film goer to call themselves a "Film Buff" or every joe who bought a Metallica CD a "Metalhead".

Well now that I know that's not the case from people here, what is the gaming equivalent for "Film Buff", "Metalhead" and "Football Fanatic"?
 

StriderShinryu

New member
Dec 8, 2009
4,987
0
0
As a few others have already said, a gamer is a videogame enthusiast. It's the videogame equivalent of a car nut or a cinephile/movie buff. Many people drive cars and most people watch movies, but there is a very obvious extra level of interest and dedication in the enthusiasts just as you see in gamers regarding games. This is the definition I have used for a long time, and big wigs at The Escapist have stated that they agree with it as well.