Let me put this helmet on, and... Kane and Lynch: Dog Days.
No, seriously. It was incredibly atmospheric (yes, I actually liked the youtube stylistics), Condemned-style brutal and dark, the soundtrack fit in greatly, the voice acting was surprisingly good, the story was silly but well-executed, and the whole "taking cover didn't make me invincible!" complaint is just a result of the pussification of games that has been going on for about 8 years now. Yes, it was short and the ending resolved jack shit, but I've always had the feeling it was planned as more of a bridge between K&L and K&L 2 than an actual sequel. Too bad it flopped and we're probably never going to see the real sequel, but oh well.
Also Driv3r. This one is a lot harder to defend because of the inane difficulty curve and bullshit gameplay, but come on, the story was pretty damn good in a cheesy cop show way, and the cutscenes were among the best ones I've seen in gaming (at least for the game's time). Granted, Driver: San Francisco was all that and better.