Games that you thought sucked as opposed to everyone else.

[lukeyk]

Uncharted 2, not because of what Yahtzee said, but because I found everything way too obvious.

Legend of zelda games now-a-days, I know exactly what is going to happen and what the answer to the whole thing is ect.

Mass effect 2: I'm not sure why but I didn't get addicted, I know that sounds strange but if you think about most games draw you in and then you realize its been like3 hours when you were only meant to be playing for 10 minutes, with mass effect I just couldn't get into it, that and it was unbelievably repetitive.

However on the other side of the argument, the whole games you loved but everyone else that they were crap.
Half Minute Hero, Hands down, My game of the year for 2009.

 

[Quorothorn]

God of War: I liked it for a while. But there was this annoying as hell puzzle in 1 that made me rage quit. Never have played it again, never have brought another one either.

The pillars in the underworld, I presume?

-

I find the very strong trends in this topic kind of interesting, by the way. I think the idea behind the topic is diluted somewhat when everyone keeps saying God of War/Modern Warfare/Final Fantasy/Assassin's Creed/Valve games.

Not that I'm bucking that trend, since the first game that came to my mind was Shadow of the Colossus, which I simply couldn't get into, and it's been mentioned here several times already. And also Final Fantasy. >_>

Honestly, I've been pretty good/lucky so far at simply avoiding games I probably wouldn't like.

-

ETA:

However on the other side of the argument, the whole games you loved but everyone else that they were crap.
Half Minute Hero, Hands down, My game of the year for 2009.

Prototype. I see it catch a lot of flak, but it's my favourite current-gen title so far.