Fox12 said:
Ryan Hughes said:
I think it's safe, so long as he does some original work with it. If he has some rainbow colored rooms, then yeah, there's a problem, but having a similar concept isn't such a big deal, I think. Poe would probably prefer people to carry on his legacy, even if they don't all reach his heights. If everyone's too intimidated to write in his field then the genre will stagnate, and I don't think anyone would want that, Poe included. Not that you're wrong, I love me some Poe : )
It is not really an issue of how close it is to
Masque so much as. . . well, ok. It is like a musician just getting started and then making a song that sounds even remotely like something composed by Beethoven. . . It is not anyone's fault, and only someone boorish would bring up things like plagiarism, but it also -even under the best of circumstances- invites comparison between the two. Which no one should feel bad for not measuring up to that. So, it is not that they
shouldn't do it, it is just that I would suggest they not. I suppose. Though, that is a rather silly answer, I admit.