God of War Review Thread

Recommended Videos

hanselthecaretaker

My flask is half full
Legacy
Nov 18, 2010
8,738
5,911
118
Ezekiel said:

The only review I've watched. I think you'll like it, Redryhno, since you posted his earlier video. He basically exposes everything I feared about this bad camera. They have this really inorganic fix, traffic cones. And yeah, removing the jump was a numbskull decision. And yeah, this isn't Kratos.

Also, I like how some of you (Not Hansel.) in this thread and the other acted like my opinion didn't matter because I haven't played the game. Playing it sure changed this guy's opinion. He repeated in this video a lot of his rants from a few years ago. Like I said, I have eyes.

I?m not watching the review because I?ve already seen too much before playing through it myself.

You seem to be wanting confirmation of your own bias for some reason. I could also say Max Payne 3 was ruined by making him slow and oafish, littering the game with obnoxious, flashy cutscenes after every doorway, gimping shoot dodge because you?re limited to mostly corridors (FTR I?ve had less trouble with GoW?s camera than MP3?s cramped quarters causing its own camera issues), and turning Max himself into a pathetic self loathing pity party (ie ?this isn?t Max?), but you?d probably find ways to refute most if not all of that because you?ve actually played - and enjoyed - the game. I also played it and enjoyed it well enough, but wouldn?t have rushed to those conclusions beforehand either, even though there is at least some truth to them. Same with Resident Evil 4, Zelda, Mario, Castlevania, Final Fantasy, for other examples of series that have undergone several changes. Tomb Raider is another, but GoW blows away that reboot effort.

The jumping thing, I?d rather be able to sprint since it?s more useful moment to moment, considering you?re still able to jump when needed for traversal as well as during a few special moves. You just aren?t hopping around like a numbskull anymore. Speaking of numbskulls, Kratos seems to have finally moved past being one himself, which most people have considered a good thing.

IIRC you?ve talked about wanting worthwhile stories in games. Well, here?s one with a character who most people would?ve written off based on previous experiences with him, where he was mostly a one note, unhinged killer. He still has those moments now, but quite a few other new, far more meaningful ones as well.
 

Casual Shinji

Should've gone before we left.
Legacy
Jul 18, 2009
20,519
5,335
118
Ezekiel said:
The only review I've watched. I think you'll like it, Redryhno, since you posted his earlier video. He basically exposes everything I feared about this bad camera. They have this really inorganic fix, traffic cones. And yeah, removing the jump was a numbskull decision. And yeah, this isn't Kratos.

Also, I like how some of you (Not Hansel.) in this thread and the other acted like my opinion didn't matter because I haven't played the game. Playing it sure changed this guy's opinion. He repeated in this video a lot of his rants from a few years ago. Like I said, I have eyes.
So this guy who played the game didn't like it, therefor your bias against it, eventhough you haven't played it, isn't bias at all? Yeah, that makes total sense. You sure proved your point.

Also, this video you posted is by the same guy who made a video praising Resident Evil 6 as a misunderstood masterpiece.
 

BrawlMan

Lover of beat'em ups.
Legacy
Mar 10, 2016
31,484
13,014
118
Detroit, Michigan
Country
United States of America
Gender
Male
Casual Shinji said:
Ezekiel said:
The only review I've watched. I think you'll like it, Redryhno, since you posted his earlier video. He basically exposes everything I feared about this bad camera. They have this really inorganic fix, traffic cones. And yeah, removing the jump was a numbskull decision. And yeah, this isn't Kratos.

Also, I like how some of you (Not Hansel.) in this thread and the other acted like my opinion didn't matter because I haven't played the game. Playing it sure changed this guy's opinion. He repeated in this video a lot of his rants from a few years ago. Like I said, I have eyes.
So this guy who played the game didn't like it, therefor your bias against it, eventhough you haven't played it, isn't bias at all? Yeah, that makes total sense. You sure proved your point.

Also, this video you posted is by the same guy who made a video praising Resident Evil 6 as a misunderstood masterpiece.
I like Gaming Brit, but sometimes he can be overzealous. I had similar worries about God of War, and was on the hate this, not going to like it territory. Yet I enjoyed. It can't hold a candle to games like DMC3 or Bayonetta, but it does not need to. God of War is a low-full price, it I gave it a rating. That said, there are some problems I can agree with Gaming Brit on.
 

Phoenixmgs_v1legacy

Muse of Fate
Sep 1, 2010
4,691
0
0
Ezekiel said:
The only review I've watched. He basically exposes everything I feared about this bad camera.

Also, I like how some of you (Not Hansel.) in this thread and the other acted like my opinion didn't matter because I haven't played the game. Playing it sure changed this guy's opinion. He repeated in this video a lot of his rants from a few years ago.


So the ONLY review you watched was of a guy that went in hating the game prior to playing, much like yourself, and came out still hating the game? The confirmation bias is very strong in both of you. His original video that I fully watched was so full of logic holes that I'm not even going to bother with the review. For example, in his previous video he said God of War should be about good gameplay yet claimed in the very 1st seconds of the video that classic GOW games were nothing but mashing square and they allowed casuals into the genre while the new game has BETTER gameplay. New GOW is more about good gameplay than old GOW. Also, God Hand exists with the same camera and a great combat system (which is even shown in the video). Thus, camera alone can't dictate a bad or good combat system. Much like saying some upcoming 1st-person platformer will suck because 1st-person platforming can't work while Mirror's Edge exists.

No game element is inherently bad; game elements are only bad when improperly used.

Ezekiel said:
They have this really inorganic fix, traffic cones.
Which you can turn off if you have good situational awareness (which you really aren't good at). It's like complaining that Bioshock has an arrow at the top of the screen that you can turn off.
 

Casual Shinji

Should've gone before we left.
Legacy
Jul 18, 2009
20,519
5,335
118
CoCage said:
I like Gaming Brit, but sometimes he can be overzealous. I had similar worries about God of War, and was on the hate this, not going to like it territory. Yet I enjoyed. It can't hold a candle to games like DMC3 or Bayonetta, but it does not need to. God of War is a low-full price, it I gave it a rating. That said, there are some problems I can agree with Gaming Brit on.
I'm sorry, but the guy is a smug moron. Notice how he mentions people were fooled into liking this game just as they were fooled into liking The Last of Us ('they fell for it again'). Ooh, but he wasn't, no he's too smart for that. How fucking up your own ass can you get.
 

BrawlMan

Lover of beat'em ups.
Legacy
Mar 10, 2016
31,484
13,014
118
Detroit, Michigan
Country
United States of America
Gender
Male
Casual Shinji said:
CoCage said:
I like Gaming Brit, but sometimes he can be overzealous. I had similar worries about God of War, and was on the hate this, not going to like it territory. Yet I enjoyed. It can't hold a candle to games like DMC3 or Bayonetta, but it does not need to. God of War is a low-full price, it I gave it a rating. That said, there are some problems I can agree with Gaming Brit on.
I'm sorry, but the guy is a smug moron. Notice how he mentions people were fooled into liking this game just as they were fooled into liking The Last of Us ('they fell for it again'). Ooh, but he wasn't, no he's too smart for that. How fucking up your own ass can you get.
You have no need to apologize, I completely understand. How you feel is how I feel about people like moviebob, Anita what's her face,and most of Channel awesome. And there are several videos that I'm aware of where he act smug about it, even if he did a point. Do not let his attitude ruin your enjoyment And you are right, he was acting like a smug jackass in that video.
 

Phoenixmgs_v1legacy

Muse of Fate
Sep 1, 2010
4,691
0
0
CoCage said:
Casual Shinji said:
CoCage said:
I like Gaming Brit, but sometimes he can be overzealous. I had similar worries about God of War, and was on the hate this, not going to like it territory. Yet I enjoyed. It can't hold a candle to games like DMC3 or Bayonetta, but it does not need to. God of War is a low-full price, it I gave it a rating. That said, there are some problems I can agree with Gaming Brit on.
I'm sorry, but the guy is a smug moron. Notice how he mentions people were fooled into liking this game just as they were fooled into liking The Last of Us ('they fell for it again'). Ooh, but he wasn't, no he's too smart for that. How fucking up your own ass can you get.
You have no need to apologize, I completely understand. How you feel is how I feel about people like moviebob, Anita what's her face,and most of Channel awesome. And there are several videos that I'm aware of where he act smug about it, even if he did a point. Do not let his attitude ruin your enjoyment And you are right, he was acting like a smug jackass in that video.
I didn't watch his review of God of War but his initial reaction video, and his logic made no sense. I really don't care about smugness much, I care about argument strength and there was none. Hell, hbomberguy is extremely smug but he makes good points from time-to-time. I like MovieBob, still watch his stuff because his internal logic makes sense to me and he usually does give a different take or at least different reasons for liking/disliking something vs most critics. The worst I can say about MovieBob was his Game Overthinker stuff got weird.
 

Kitsune Hunter

What a beautiful Duwang!
Dec 18, 2011
1,072
0
0
Ezekiel said:

The only review I've watched. I think you'll like it, Redryhno, since you posted his earlier video. He basically exposes everything I feared about this bad camera. They have this really inorganic fix, traffic cones. And yeah, removing the jump was a numbskull decision. And yeah, this isn't Kratos.

Also, I like how some of you (Not Hansel.) in this thread and the other acted like my opinion didn't matter because I haven't played the game. Playing it sure changed this guy's opinion. He repeated in this video a lot of his rants from a few years ago. Like I said, I have eyes.
After having watched it, all I can say is, the word 'contrarian' is tossed about quite a bit nowadays, but with this "review", between saying DmC was better and that everyone who praises the game got duped just like with TLoU, the guy comes across as a text book contrarian and an obnoxious one at that. It really takes away from what legitimate criticism he does make when he just comes across as being a smug git about it.

Casual Shinji said:
CoCage said:
I like Gaming Brit, but sometimes he can be overzealous. I had similar worries about God of War, and was on the hate this, not going to like it territory. Yet I enjoyed. It can't hold a candle to games like DMC3 or Bayonetta, but it does not need to. God of War is a low-full price, it I gave it a rating. That said, there are some problems I can agree with Gaming Brit on.
I'm sorry, but the guy is a smug moron. Notice how he mentions people were fooled into liking this game just as they were fooled into liking The Last of Us ('they fell for it again'). Ooh, but he wasn't, no he's too smart for that. How fucking up your own ass can you get.
Not to mention he complaints about the length of the cut scenes and how it tries to be a film and how much it takes away from the game play and yet he made a separate video that defends MGS4, a game that's notorious for the length of its cut scenes and sparse game play. It's a bit of a contradiction.
 

BrawlMan

Lover of beat'em ups.
Legacy
Mar 10, 2016
31,484
13,014
118
Detroit, Michigan
Country
United States of America
Gender
Male
Phoenixmgs said:
CoCage said:
Casual Shinji said:
CoCage said:
I like Gaming Brit, but sometimes he can be overzealous. I had similar worries about God of War, and was on the hate this, not going to like it territory. Yet I enjoyed. It can't hold a candle to games like DMC3 or Bayonetta, but it does not need to. God of War is a low-full price, it I gave it a rating. That said, there are some problems I can agree with Gaming Brit on.
I'm sorry, but the guy is a smug moron. Notice how he mentions people were fooled into liking this game just as they were fooled into liking The Last of Us ('they fell for it again'). Ooh, but he wasn't, no he's too smart for that. How fucking up your own ass can you get.
You have no need to apologize, I completely understand. How you feel is how I feel about people like moviebob, Anita what's her face,and most of Channel awesome. And there are several videos that I'm aware of where he act smug about it, even if he did a point. Do not let his attitude ruin your enjoyment And you are right, he was acting like a smug jackass in that video.
I didn't watch his review of God of War but his initial reaction video, and his logic made no sense. I really don't care about smugness much, I care about argument strength and there was none. Hell, hbomberguy is extremely smug but he makes good points from time-to-time. I like MovieBob, still watch his stuff because his internal logic makes sense to me and he usually does give a different take or at least different reasons for liking/disliking something vs most critics. The worst I can say about MovieBob was his Game Overthinker stuff got weird.
My problem with MovieBob is that he acts like most of his opinions are facts, and anybody that says or acts different is either lying, "blind to the truth", or stupid. And there were many times where Bob did not back up his arguments while acting like a smug ***** in a box stand..I used to like him, but that changed around 2013/14. His attitude on Twitter was not helping (which got him fired on the The Escapists; the ************ did not quit). I'm surprised he was able to find another job, because of his unprofessionalism. If I need a movie critic that badly, I can think two infinitely better ones: Double Toasted and Vern. Bob's GameOver stuff was always self indulgent, it just got worse as the years went on.





Kitsune Hunter said:
Ezekiel said:

The only review I've watched. I think you'll like it, Redryhno, since you posted his earlier video. He basically exposes everything I feared about this bad camera. They have this really inorganic fix, traffic cones. And yeah, removing the jump was a numbskull decision. And yeah, this isn't Kratos.

Also, I like how some of you (Not Hansel.) in this thread and the other acted like my opinion didn't matter because I haven't played the game. Playing it sure changed this guy's opinion. He repeated in this video a lot of his rants from a few years ago. Like I said, I have eyes.
After having watched it, all I can say is, the word 'contrarian' is tossed about quite a bit nowadays, but with this "review", between saying DmC was better and that everyone who praises the game got duped just like with TLoU, the guy comes across as a text book contrarian and an obnoxious one at that. It really takes away from what legitimate criticism he does make when he just comes across as being a smug git about it.

Casual Shinji said:
CoCage said:
I like Gaming Brit, but sometimes he can be overzealous. I had similar worries about God of War, and was on the hate this, not going to like it territory. Yet I enjoyed. It can't hold a candle to games like DMC3 or Bayonetta, but it does not need to. God of War is a low-full price, it I gave it a rating. That said, there are some problems I can agree with Gaming Brit on.
I'm sorry, but the guy is a smug moron. Notice how he mentions people were fooled into liking this game just as they were fooled into liking The Last of Us ('they fell for it again'). Ooh, but he wasn't, no he's too smart for that. How fucking up your own ass can you get.
Not to mention he complaints about the length of the cut scenes and how it tries to be a film and how much it takes away from the game play and yet he made a separate video that defends MGS4, a game that's notorious for the length of its cut scenes and sparse game play. It's a bit of a contradiction.
I know what you mean. It was one of the rare times where I said fuck you to Gaming Brit. The other time was that pointless dis he made at Legend of Korra. I did not enjoy the game, and have mixed feelings with the show, but I can't help but feel that he was trying to heavily pander to people who never liked the show to begin with, or hate anything anime inspired in general. Which is really hypocritical as the Japanese and the West have taken so many influences from each other.
 

hanselthecaretaker

My flask is half full
Legacy
Nov 18, 2010
8,738
5,911
118
I get the impression that some of these youtubers have to put out controversy-seeking videos just to retain subs and attempt to stand out if nothing else, because this GB guy's standards seem to be all over the place from the few posts I've read above.
 

Johnny Novgorod

Bebop Man
Legacy
Feb 9, 2012
19,347
4,013
118
Ezekiel said:
You people implied my opinion is invalid because I haven't played it.
More like outright told you.
Now I'm wondering. On average how many of the games you talk about for good or bad have you actually played? Do you do this with the movies you review as well? Do you apply this lucky guess school of criticism to other fields? This is interesting.
 

BrawlMan

Lover of beat'em ups.
Legacy
Mar 10, 2016
31,484
13,014
118
Detroit, Michigan
Country
United States of America
Gender
Male
Ezekiel said:
hanselthecaretaker said:
I get the impression that some of these youtubers have to put out controversy-seeking videos just to retain subs and attempt to stand out if nothing else, because this GB guy's standards seem to be all over the place from the few posts I've read above.
If you watched his review to the end, you'd see he's sincere. I didn't get any impression he was doing it for clickbait. He ends it by telling people who suggest he stop playing new games that he barely plays any new games. I get where he's coming from. There's so much sameness and emphasis on artsy-fartsy movie crap.
I would never call him an attention seeker, but their are moments where he gets his panties in a bunch, because people are enjoying a game he did not like. See his original DmC 2013 video (though I 100% agreed with on that one in terms of the gameplay and story). This is rare whenever he goes on these hissy fits. I know he's passionate about games and does research better than most individual critics on YouTube and "professional" reviewers, but there are times I want to tell him to calm down to his face when he goes overboard.
 

Casual Shinji

Should've gone before we left.
Legacy
Jul 18, 2009
20,519
5,335
118
Ezekiel said:
You people implied my opinion is invalid because I haven't played it. He had many of my same complaints. He played it. His complaints were confirmed. You can have an informed opinion on ANY game you haven't played. Actually, I did watch one other review, now that I think about it, but it wasn't very good. It's refreshing to see a video that's 80 percent gameplay analysis.
Your opinion isn't invalid; dislike the game as much as you want, but any criticism -- baring the visuals and voice acting... without playing the game, yeah, that's pretty much invalid in any discussion about said game.

And his complaints were confirmed? By what, the court of law?
I get where he's coming from. There's so much sameness and emphasis on artsy-fartsy movie crap.
Again though, this is the same guy who defended Metal Gear Solid 4; a game that has a 90 minute-long "artsy fartsy" cutscene (ontop of the other 20 to 30 minute-long ones).
 

Hawki

Elite Member
Legacy
Mar 4, 2014
9,651
2,179
118
Country
Australia
Gender
Male
Looks at thread...

Damn, Eris really did a Golden Apple didn't she?
 

hanselthecaretaker

My flask is half full
Legacy
Nov 18, 2010
8,738
5,911
118
Ezekiel said:
hanselthecaretaker said:
I get the impression that some of these youtubers have to put out controversy-seeking videos just to retain subs and attempt to stand out if nothing else, because this GB guy's standards seem to be all over the place from the few posts I've read above.
If you watched his review to the end, you'd see he's sincere. I didn't get any impression he was doing it for clickbait. He ends it by telling people who suggest he stop playing new games that he barely plays any new games. I get where he's coming from. There's so much sameness and emphasis on artsy-fartsy movie crap.
He may be sincere, but probably also misguided. Especially since he admits he barely plays any new games, which means he's partial to old games and the way they're made. That's fine, but different doesn't automatically mean crap.

For all the criticizing of the new direction the series took, no one really explained how they would've done it. They say what it shouldn't have been, but whether new IP or continuation of an old one, it sounds like they'd just end up making the same old game if it was up to them; in which case, why bother? It was made clear the old formula wasn't cutting it anymore.
 

Samtemdo8_v1legacy

New member
Aug 2, 2015
7,915
0
0
You know while you guys are still arguing with Ezekiel's opinions, I still haven't gotten the answer to my own question about 50 posts ago:

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.1051678-God-of-War-Review-Thread?page=2#24233795
 

Casual Shinji

Should've gone before we left.
Legacy
Jul 18, 2009
20,519
5,335
118
Samtemdo8 said:
You know while you guys are still arguing with Ezekiel's opinions, I still haven't gotten the answer to my own question about 50 posts ago:

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.1051678-God-of-War-Review-Thread?page=2#24233795
Answering those questions would result in spoiling the shit out the game. This new game is pretty stuffed with massive reveals.
 

Samtemdo8_v1legacy

New member
Aug 2, 2015
7,915
0
0
Casual Shinji said:
Samtemdo8 said:
You know while you guys are still arguing with Ezekiel's opinions, I still haven't gotten the answer to my own question about 50 posts ago:

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.1051678-God-of-War-Review-Thread?page=2#24233795
Answering those questions would result in spoiling the shit out the game. This new game is pretty stuffed with massive reveals.
I want to be spoiled, I don't have a PS4 at the moment.