Good or Bad?

[VaudevillianVeteran]

Depends solely on the game. If it's something like Bioshock then I always go for the good route. I just can't harvest for some reason.
Meanwhile on games like Fallout, I seem to lean far more on the evil side (Although I have one save completely dedicated to being good while the other-more fun- save dedicated to being the meanest ***** in all the Wasteland).

 

[Gir1yG4m3r]

Without really trying, I will fall into being paladin-like( pretty much do everything to help people)for the first time I ever play an rpg game. I will then be able to go a bit more neutral, and then maybe evil.

I feel bad for doing certain things, and it will usually take a lot of willpower for me to do bad things and not feel horrible afterwards. Sometimes, being evil will get you certain rewards/followers, so that's a payoff. I have a hard time maintaining my evil ways for the most part...

 

[Samuel Adams]

I'm only bad if there is an achievement that requires so.

 

[silver wolf009]

Good with a hint of badass.

this

 

[Urgh76]

good because of one thing:

KARMA BITCHES!

 

[Valkyira]

I try and be a Jack Bauer type of character. His/her ethics may be a little extreme but he has the greater good in mind.

 

[Not-here-anymore]

Mostly good, but if I have to be bad to get things done, I'll resign myself to it... e.g "persuading" a shop owner in KOTOR to sell me HK-47 for cheap because I had no money, or abandoning the workers during Zaeed's loyalty quest in ME2 because I wasn't sure if I could swing his loyalty otherwise. Most moral choice games are far too binary though

 

[manythings]

The worst I can be is Morally ambiguous. Villainy is just not something I want to have a hand in, even fake villainy. It tooke me about ten seconds to desecrate the artifact in the temple in Dragon age and even then I only did it to get a save so I could have the achievement and specialization it gives. I went right back to my other save and chose good then.

Mass Effect had the first morality system that didn't feel like villain or hero. When you went renegade you could still do what was right even though it was a very ends "justify the means" kind of way. I also love the idea of the interrupt system. With my Full renegade character I imagine there are a lot of punchings I can dish out without remorse.

 

[MetalDooley]

I'll generally be the most virtuous hero possible first time round.If I play through a second time I'll stray towards evil.The one exception is Bioshock where I harvested all the little sisters on my first playthrough.

 

[GameOverGoblin]

I usually go for evil unless the evil move will make me less of a badass and more of a just plain asshole.

 

[mik hardcore]

Usually good. The Warriors is a great game to play since mugging people is your main source of income, so you end up thinking "Well I don't like being bad but really I haven't got much choice, so I'm just gonna go with it".

 

[jozeevis]

Usually I'm good, except I steal almost everything I can find and if there is a giant explosion involved, I'm in.

 

[SnootyEnglishman]

I switch between the two depending on what will benefit me the most.