Here I'm talking about films you really enjoy that just have a scene, character or moment that makes your insides shrivel up and try to escape from your naval cavity.
To kick this off with an example I am a huge batman nerd, I love me some caped crusader. So obviously I enjoyed The Dark Knight, however the scene with Harvey Dent in the courtroom always makes my soul sad. It's needlessly over the top, and has pointless patriotism thrown in for good measure. For the life of my I can't find a video of the scene but, for those who don't know what scene I mean, Dent is interviewing a witness on the stand who retracts his statement. He then pulls a gun on Dent but it misfires. Here's where it gets a bit daft, Dent takes the gun from the suspect and punches him in the face, then casually strolls over to the defence table, takes the gun apart and says something along the lines of "The next time you try to kill a public official I suggest you buy American". As the judge calls for people to escort the man out of the court Dent stops him saying "But judge, I'm not done yet" cue applause in the audience etc etc.
Now my issue with this is that the ridiculous bravado and patriotism just came off as incredibly forced to me. Also the ending makes no sense. Firstly, you've just knocked the guy flat out, what info are you expecting to get from an unconscious man?? Secondly, even if he was conscious, he's just retracted his statement and perjured himself in court literally 30 seconds ago, what are you hoping will happen by continuing to question him??
So, what films can you guys think of that overall is a great film, but has a moment that is truly awful?
To kick this off with an example I am a huge batman nerd, I love me some caped crusader. So obviously I enjoyed The Dark Knight, however the scene with Harvey Dent in the courtroom always makes my soul sad. It's needlessly over the top, and has pointless patriotism thrown in for good measure. For the life of my I can't find a video of the scene but, for those who don't know what scene I mean, Dent is interviewing a witness on the stand who retracts his statement. He then pulls a gun on Dent but it misfires. Here's where it gets a bit daft, Dent takes the gun from the suspect and punches him in the face, then casually strolls over to the defence table, takes the gun apart and says something along the lines of "The next time you try to kill a public official I suggest you buy American". As the judge calls for people to escort the man out of the court Dent stops him saying "But judge, I'm not done yet" cue applause in the audience etc etc.
Now my issue with this is that the ridiculous bravado and patriotism just came off as incredibly forced to me. Also the ending makes no sense. Firstly, you've just knocked the guy flat out, what info are you expecting to get from an unconscious man?? Secondly, even if he was conscious, he's just retracted his statement and perjured himself in court literally 30 seconds ago, what are you hoping will happen by continuing to question him??
So, what films can you guys think of that overall is a great film, but has a moment that is truly awful?