300lb. Samoan said:
That's just fucking silly. Doom 3 was only a step forward technologically, and even if it did have double the texture resolution I think people will agree that the faces in Half-Life 2 are MUCH easier on the eyes. It was a technical marvel, and the physics gameplay was brand new and blowing people's minds, and even though many games had attempted it none had really accomplished the immersive quality that Half-Life 1 possessed, while Half-Life 2 managed to improve it considerably. Highly irrelevant, that's a fucking laugh. I'm positive it wasn't just me and my friends chomping at the bit when this thing finally came out.
Doom 3 actually took advantage of it's technical achievement to create an incredibly creepy, immersive environment. Doom 3 actually tried to do something different with the FPS formula, making it into a quasi-survival horror. I can actually point at games like, say, Dead Space or Bioshock and comment on the similarities. Half-Life 2 just used it's tech to try to look as realistic as possible.
Look at other shooters coming out at the time and look at shooters coming out now. It's not Half-Life they're modeling themselves after. Half-Life 2 was based off of FPS tropes that were dying at the time, and most people who go back and play them after having played more modern shooters first will note how dated they feel. Doom 3, which certainly not revolutionary, at least still stands up well.
JimmyBassatti said:
What is so wrong with liking Valve?
Let me give you the cynical answer: Valve is one of the last of the true PC developers in a world that's increasingly console-first. One inevitable effect of this is that they attract PC fanboys who hype them up beyond what they really should. When Halo, a dirty console shooter, was at the top of the FPS world, Half-Life 2 is what they rallied around.
The deification of Half-Life 2 gets kind of annoying after a while, especially when it comes from self-styled "hard core FPS gamers" whose experience with the genre seems to be limited to Half-Life and nothing else.