hang on a minute, is this a strawman in the making

Recommended Videos

lacktheknack

Je suis joined jewels.
Jan 19, 2009
19,316
0
0
Quigglebert said:
I was playing it for about 15 days straight.
I'd believe that she'd react adversely after playing for FIFTEEN DAYS STRAIGHT, even allowing for school and food. Yeesh, where are her parents?!
 

SenseOfTumour

New member
Jul 11, 2008
4,514
0
0
It's entirely fair, sad that they can't mention the positives tho, such as gamers increasing their problem solving skills thru gaming, by applying their gaming skills to real world problems.

No, much better headlines to say 'gamers go a bit mental.'

It's a shame as the BBC is usually so much better than this. I expect more from them.

Hell as others have admitted to, I've had thoughts of wanting to cut the guy in front of me in half just for walking slowly, but I don't do it, and it's not related to playing Mortal Kombat. If it was, I'd do it in a more interesting way.
 

Aprilgold

New member
Apr 1, 2011
1,995
0
0
Zyst said:
I think it's an exaggeration, but I totally know what they mean.

It REALLY REALLY sucked when I played Portal, since I was all like "Oh if I open a portal here then one there I would..." Then I'd get sad, because I still had to walk.
I'm with you, why don't we have Apeture now in days, scientists, STOP with the Jetpacks, perfect the technology of portal, WAAAAAYY more praticual.
 

Tselis

New member
Jul 23, 2011
429
0
0
I have to ask, how many of these people are being serious and how many are just fucking with the researchers?
 

Valagetti

Good Coffee, cheaper than prozac
Aug 20, 2010
1,112
0
0
It has happened to me after playing several hours of L4D2. Its really interesting. Can't wait until the media puts a negative spin on it.
 

ScrubberDucky

New member
Feb 17, 2011
212
0
0
That article is so full of shit I can smell it from the next country over. Yeah, it is a strawman in the making.
 

Hero in a half shell

It's not easy being green
Dec 30, 2009
4,286
0
0
I have friends who love Period dramas, and they equate everything to Jane Austen, "Oh, this object kind of looks like a fan, I feel just like Elizabeth Bennet!" I know guys who play a lot of golf, and they often find themselves absent mindedly practicing their golf swings, especially if they are holding a long thing.
Personally, yes, I have private jokes with my friends about good sniper positions and other game related stuff, but it is a harmless facet of human nature shared by everyone. No matter what your hobby is, you will spend a lot of your free time thinking about it. If that hobby is games it doesn't mean you're any more likely to shoot up a school.
 

aashell13

New member
Jan 31, 2011
547
0
0
Is it peer-reviewed? no? well, lots of nonsense gets published in mass media. why should I regard this any differently?
 

madmatt

New member
Jan 12, 2010
135
0
0
They are baiting us (the gamer community), which is cheap for the BBC. Look, it is already on their most read page. Yes it is a strawman argument, and I don't think most of the responses are serious. But most of all, if people do replicate what they see without thinking - then it is they who have a problem, not the medium. Those same people would be effected by movies etc.
 

NoOne852

The Friendly Neighborhood Nobody
Sep 12, 2011
843
0
0
RT-Medic-with-shotgun said:
Ok then that little girl is an insane ***** that needs therapy. I played a game where i stomped turtles to death, ate mushrooms, and stole coins when i was 5. I have the urge to do none of those things. I go on frequent gaming binges and don't feel like shouting 'Burn heretics" and lighting mothers up with a bolter... I did scream that loudly in the mall once just to gauge funny looks i got.

As for wanting to use fictional technology? I WANTED A HOLO-DECK WHEN I WAS A KID! I WOULD HAVE LOVED TO HAVE A CHAINSWORD! Why? Because they would have made an aspect of my life easier. OH NO! Kids are using video games to get ideas on how life could be easier! I would love a portal gun. I would love to find and regroup with friends in an instant; or find something i misplaced. But why is this a bad thing to want? I would have adored half the technology from games; the features from them but is it a bad thing to do so? Know what? i have wanted more things from books and movies than video games. I wanted to do what i read in books more than i wanted to do what i did in video games.

I mean Grungi Damnit BBC you are having a bad year keeping my respect.
And it would be neat if you rub someone with a phoneix feather, they'd come back to life, but I dont think I would actually try to implement it.

That said, the media has been and will continue to rip on video games. They want a reason to why kids misbehave and they figure "Well video games are full of adult content, so that must be why they act out of line." Yet the thing is this: KIDS SHOULDN'T BE PLAYING THOSE KIND OF GAMES TO BEGIN WITH. Sorry, but I get tired of hearing stories like this. I know this isn't directed soley at childern, but I thought I should make the point while I was along the path.
 

daftalchemist

New member
Aug 6, 2008
545
0
0
Whenever I draw, I always wish there was an Edit>Undo command for my paper and pencil. I guess that means being a digital artist makes you unable to tell the difference between reality and fantasy.
 

tthor

New member
Apr 9, 2008
2,931
0
0
its called the Tetris Effect, its already a well known and well documented occurrence. But the effects are harmless and shortlived. i doubt it could ever cause a person to actually act out violently unless said person suffered from schizophrenia

for more info, http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TheTetrisEffect

(and the more boring wiki, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetris_effect )
 

SnipeHunter11

New member
Nov 9, 2009
29
0
0
That article doesn't really say much. Sure, people might have tried using a gravity gun to pick stuff up. But who can honestly tell me that, after having watched Star Wars, you didn't try picking up something with your mind? You know we've all done it! It doesn't mean that we're deluded enough to think that we actually can, or even try it every single day. Well. Most of us don't do that.
 

TheDooD

New member
Dec 23, 2010
812
0
0
DeadlyYellow said:
Playing Grand Theft Auto, then going outside and assaulting someone is not the game's fault.

However playing Grand Theft Auto, the going outside and driving slightly more erratic than usual is. But this is more an effect of the game slightly altering your instinctual patterns, not you know... making you loony.
Don't shooting up a city block, then using your phone to summon a car and when you get home you runover a few hookers after servicing you of course to get your money back.
 

espada1311

New member
Sep 19, 2010
59
0
0
This article is silly. For the most part, they are trying to use people's fantasies as their evidence. Every damn person on the planet has a fantasy, an ideal self-image and a superior goal. Which, as impossible as they may be, we all strive for it. Games tend to offer us the attainment of our fantasy in means that do not have an impact on our real life. so of course we allow some sentiments to spill over, because it feels damn good, and if it's fun for an adult to pretend, then that kinda proves that society in a non-fun, and crappy place to live in already. Doesn't it?

This idea of game thought spilling into our real lives has been going on forever, literally thousands of years. Chief example? Religion. A "created world" that had becomes an all-consuming goal of idealistic self and surroundings by which requires the total immersion of a person's mind, body and soul into their objective. Pretty strong resemblance, I'd say. Does this mean we should give shit to religion because they cause bad behaviors sometimes? We've had more religious nuts bomb and massacre people in the name of religion in the past 30 years than there have been killers who have heard the term "video game" in the past 100 years.

It's an asinine thought that either video games OR religion or ANYTHING materialistic causes people to become more violent or murderous. People who are affected are those who are of weak mind, chemically imbalanced or just plain stupid who cannot create thoughts of their own. The true source of all this crap is bad child-rearing, hysteria and all those "save the children" idiots who banter on about "corrupting the fundamental values of..."

End of rant

Thank you for those who actually read this... you are a determined person XD
 

chadachada123

New member
Jan 17, 2011
2,310
0
0
Stall said:
Ah ha ha! So the good old Tetris Effect is getting some lovin', eh?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetris_Effect

The Tetris effect occurs when people devote sufficient time and attention to an activity that it begins to overshadow their thoughts, mental images, and dreams. It is named after the video game Tetris.

People who play Tetris for a prolonged amount of time may then find themselves thinking about ways different shapes in the real world can fit together, such as the boxes on a supermarket shelf or the buildings on a street.[1] In this sense, the Tetris effect is a form of habit. They might also dream about falling Tetris shapes when drifting off to sleep or see images of falling Tetris shapes at the edges of their visual fields or when they close their eyes.[1] In this sense, the Tetris effect is a form of hallucination or hypnagogic imagery.
It's been around for ages really. It's nothing new. Video games have always had this effect on people, as far back as Tetris.

Also, the OP needs to learn what a straw man is because his thread shows absolutely no grasp on the word.
As a cashier, I had a particularly awesome week once after an unusually grueling month-long Tetris obsession, having to make sure that every item fit the bag perfectly. Heh.

I used to, for a good year or so, picture Tetris blocks when I closed my eyes. I was basically playing the game in my mind constantly.

I haven't read the article, but I feel like that is what an article SHOULD explain. For example, I sometimes picture just using a grenade launcher to blow a hole into a wall if I need to get to the other side because of Battlefield. That doesn't mean that I'm going to, only that the video game is making my imagination steer in a certain direction.