I?ll just start by saying, that making my eyes water is no great feat. Movies and television especially, has an ability to screw with me. If I like a character, make them go through hardship(or even sometimes resolution) and queue the right music, and you´ll hear mw quietly sniffing and trying to discreetly dry my eyes.
I love that. Sure I might be a little silly sometimes. And it can be very embarrassing in the company of the wrong people, but I love have my emotions messed with. If I cry(or get angry, depressed or whatever) it means that I?m emotionally invested. And the fact that something can get me emotionally invested makes it art. Or at least good storytelling. (Kinda over- simplifying art here?but there you go.)
And a lot of games have made me tear up. I happens so often that I?ll just mention a few.
There may be spoilers.
The Darkness, while not being perfect, has some pretty emotional scenes.
Mass Effect (both of them) has a lot. They do such a good job at making you like the characters, that you want to see them safe. And while some of their problems might seem sort of silly sometimes, you don?t really notice, because you care about them.
In ME1 when you have to sacrifice a crewmember, really made me frustrated(in a good way) and almost made me paralyzed with indecision.
And in ME2 during the Joker Descend part. Every crewmember that got taken, made me want to charge the Collectors with suicidal abandon.(Again...this was a good thing)
The whole Final Fantasy series have kinda the same thing. But I actually thing that sometimes the music sort of ruined the mood(especially in the ?older games?)
I could go on?but I won?t.