I've been both. I bought Rogue Galaxy and Mana Kahemia at a local PlaynTrade and loved both the games and played them to the end. I also unfortunately bought Ephemeral Phantasia and Unlimited Saga the worst games I've ever played. From what I can tell the first game is a bard with a talking guitar? (string instrument of some kind)trying to write a song for a king and his queen and playing it via guitar hero but minus the fun or directions and then you walk around lost in a city until you become bored and take the disc back to the store. Imagine playing monoply and every other time you roll the dice you either land on someone else's property with a hotel, go to jail space, or chance card that makes you pay money. Unlimited Saga is not nearly that much fun.