Treefingers said:
My real point is that how the average person eats, especially in relation to meat, is unhealthy. Not that eating meat in itself is, but rather what it's become. The industry pumping out excessive amounts of sub-par quality flesh from animals forced to roll in their shit all day and our subsequent over-consumption of it. It's fucking up ourselves and our environment. That's the real issue.
For the record, I agree with you on this front. There is far too much factory farming in the US resulting in poor use of land, poor treatment of animals, and animals being pumped full of hormones and steroids to fatten them up. There's also far too many people who are eating processed meats which are so far from what nature intended I hesitate to call it food anymore, but that's a slightly different issue.
Treefingers said:
Also, I was quoting from the American Dietetic Association. Not the American Diabetic Association.
Wow, my bad. Completely misread that in your original post, so my apologies.
As to the claims made by the Dietetic Association, from what I can gather from reading their site, they recommend the same low fat high carb diet as the government does, and think weight loss is a simple matter of calories in and calories out. Both are false and have never been based on good science. Following the government recommendations for diet, particularly the part about having several servings of grain everyday is a recipe for getting fat, sick, and feeling hungry all of the time. It's even worse for young children because they need saturated fat for proper brain development, but the government recommendations would have them eating small quantities of lean meat. Much less meat and leaner meat than our ancestors thrived on for the better part of a million years.
Weight loss isn't about some simple relationship of calories in and calories out. If you aren't controlling insulin by preventing spikes in blood glucose then you aren't going to have a lot of success with weight loss unless you cut calories so much you go into starvation mode. Then you get to experience the joys of feeling hungry all of the time and gaining all of that weight back and then some once you go back to eating a normal amount of food and your insulin sensitivity is through the roof.