I am now convinced that youtubers thrive on controversy and negative press.

Recommended Videos

IceForce

Is this memes?
Legacy
Dec 11, 2012
2,384
16
13
Because this controversy has it all; A major publisher being idiotic and tone-deaf, gaming media labeling gamers "entitled", gamers lashing out and hitting back, "censorship" with negative comments being removed and deleted, and even a possible case of "collusion" between Youtube and Blizzard with regards to dislikes being stealthy removed from the official Diablo Immortal video.

It should come as no surprise to anyone that all of the above are huge dog whistles to the you-know-who crowd whom we can't mention here anymore. And of course any Youtube channels catering to that crowd are going to capitalize as much as they can on it.
 

The Rogue Wolf

Stealthy Carnivore
Legacy
Nov 25, 2007
17,491
10,275
118
Stalking the Digital Tundra
Gender
✅
trunkage said:
As much as you can blame the 'journalist', you can also blame us as a society. Every piece of work is written for an audience and that means journalists need to write what interests us. They would not be able to earn money if we didn't want this controversy.
As I've said many times before: The problem with the media is that it gives us exactly what we want.
 

Drathnoxis

I love the smell of card games in the morning
Legacy
Sep 23, 2010
6,023
2,235
118
Just off-screen
Country
Canada
Gender
Male
Samtemdo8 said:
The Rogue Wolf said:
And this is different from traditional media... how?
Its because these guys like the claim that they have better standards then traditional media. That they have journalistic integrity and some other nonsense I was fed with.
That was before they realized how much money they could make from controversy. Integrity always gives way to money.
 

Elfgore

Your friendly local nihilist
Legacy
Dec 6, 2010
5,655
24
13
Well yeah... It was a few years back there was actually a whole big argument about it after Markiplier I think made a video saying he disliked YouTube drama. Which spawned about a dozen plus videos from big YouTubers either agreeing with him or disagreeing. And that's just YouTube drama.

I subbed to YongYea for like a year and every damn day it was another negative video. Saying the doom of video games were coming because of X. I finally had enough when he took something that was an obvious joke and tried to turn it into an insult and something that was world ending big. It's what he does, it's what makes people click. Plus content, man would only put out a video a month if he was positive. Gotta get that ad revenue and Patreon bucks.
 

bluegate

Elite Member
Legacy
Dec 28, 2010
2,424
1,033
118
Took you long enough, but good that you saw through it.

Now just slowly step away from these kinds of people on YouTube.
 

BrawlMan

Lover of beat'em ups.
Legacy
Mar 10, 2016
31,484
13,014
118
Detroit, Michigan
Country
United States of America
Gender
Male
Elfgore said:
Well yeah... It was a few years back there was actually a whole big argument about it after Markiplier I think made a video saying he disliked YouTube drama. Which spawned about a dozen plus videos from big YouTubers either agreeing with him or disagreeing. And that's just YouTube drama.

I subbed to YongYea for like a year and every damn day it was another negative video. Saying the doom of video games were coming because of X. I finally had enough when he took something that was an obvious joke and tried to turn it into an insult and something that was world ending big. It's what he does, it's what makes people click. Plus content, man would only put out a video a month if he was positive. Gotta get that ad revenue and Patreon bucks.
EDIT (stupid Google speak):
I just subscribed to Yong a couple of months ago and I think I'm starting to regret it now. Granted, he is useful for some information, but it's at that point where I can find stuff out on my own now. so far it's been nothing but videos about Diablo or bethesda's shit. He's had some positive stuff in before, but his reporting adds nothing to the discussion that hasn't already been said already. I avoid most YouTubers in general on a principle that most of them are looking for some type of drama controversy. I remember one called review tech USA. I used to enjoy his stuff but later, on he got more controversial and up his own ass. What didn't help those that he encouraged the harassment of another YouTuber [Yoshiller] just because the guy decided to wear a Yoshi hat at Nintendo's E3 2013. The dude refused to apologize about it and I told myself well fuck you Rich (review tech USA real name). what's scary is that him and his followers probably already forgot about that situation and moved on to other "controversial" topics. Also, stay away from a YouTuber called NoBullshit. He sells nothing but shit.
 

CaitSeith

Formely Gone Gonzo
Legacy
Jun 30, 2014
5,374
381
88
CoCage said:
Elfgore said:
Well yeah... It was a few years back there was actually a whole big argument about it after Markiplier I think made a video saying he disliked YouTube drama. Which spawned about a dozen plus videos from big YouTubers either agreeing with him or disagreeing. And that's just YouTube drama.

I subbed to YongYea for like a year and every damn day it was another negative video. Saying the doom of video games were coming because of X. I finally had enough when he took something that was an obvious joke and tried to turn it into an insult and something that was world ending big. It's what he does, it's what makes people click. Plus content, man would only put out a video a month if he was positive. Gotta get that ad revenue and Patreon bucks.
I just subscribed to Yong a couple of months ago and I think I'm starting to regret it now. Granted, he is useful for some information, but it's at that point where I can find stuff out on my own now. so far it's been nothing but videos about Diablo or bethesda's shit. He's had some positive stuff in before, but his reporting adds nothing to the discussion that hasn't already been said already. I avoid most YouTubers in general on a principle that most of them are looking for some type of drama controversy. I remember one called review tech USA. I used to enjoy his stuff but later on you got more controversial and up his own ass. What didn't help those that he encouraged to harassment of another YouTuber [Yoshiller] just because the guy decided to wear a Yoshi hat at Nintendo's E3 2013. The dude refused to apologize about it and I told myself well fuck you Rich (review tech USA real name). what's scary is that him and his father is probably already forgot about that situation and moved on to other "controversial" topics. Also, stay away from a YouTuber called NoBullshit. He sells nothing but shit.
Oh, yeah. Good old Rich. Let's see if he has improved since last time I glanced at his channel... oh, 6 Diablo videos. Well, surely his other videos are more insigh... oh... nevermind. *sigh*
 

BrawlMan

Lover of beat'em ups.
Legacy
Mar 10, 2016
31,484
13,014
118
Detroit, Michigan
Country
United States of America
Gender
Male
CaitSeith said:
CoCage said:
Elfgore said:
Well yeah... It was a few years back there was actually a whole big argument about it after Markiplier I think made a video saying he disliked YouTube drama. Which spawned about a dozen plus videos from big YouTubers either agreeing with him or disagreeing. And that's just YouTube drama.

I subbed to YongYea for like a year and every damn day it was another negative video. Saying the doom of video games were coming because of X. I finally had enough when he took something that was an obvious joke and tried to turn it into an insult and something that was world ending big. It's what he does, it's what makes people click. Plus content, man would only put out a video a month if he was positive. Gotta get that ad revenue and Patreon bucks.
I just subscribed to Yong a couple of months ago and I think I'm starting to regret it now. Granted, he is useful for some information, but it's at that point where I can find stuff out on my own now. so far it's been nothing but videos about Diablo or bethesda's shit. He's had some positive stuff in before, but his reporting adds nothing to the discussion that hasn't already been said already. I avoid most YouTubers in general on a principle that most of them are looking for some type of drama controversy. I remember one called review tech USA. I used to enjoy his stuff but later on you got more controversial and up his own ass. What didn't help those that he encouraged to harassment of another YouTuber [Yoshiller] just because the guy decided to wear a Yoshi hat at Nintendo's E3 2013. The dude refused to apologize about it and I told myself well fuck you Rich (review tech USA real name). what's scary is that him and his father is probably already forgot about that situation and moved on to other "controversial" topics. Also, stay away from a YouTuber called NoBullshit. He sells nothing but shit.
Oh, yeah. Good old Rich. Let's see if he has improved since last time I glanced at his channel... oh, 6 Diablo videos. Well, surely his other videos are more insigh... oh... nevermind. *sigh*
What's really sad is that I used to watch his channel mainly for reviews on computer technology and software. After that he became nothing more than another clickbait/tabloid YouTuber.

PS - I decided to unsubscribe from YongYea.
 

jademunky

New member
Mar 6, 2012
973
0
0
IceForce said:
Because this controversy has it all; A major publisher being idiotic and tone-deaf, gaming media labeling gamers "entitled", gamers lashing out and hitting back, "censorship" with negative comments being removed and deleted, and even a possible case of "collusion" between Youtube and Blizzard with regards to dislikes being stealthy removed from the official Diablo Immortal video.

It should come as no surprise to anyone that all of the above are huge dog whistles to the you-know-who crowd whom we can't mention here anymore. And of course any Youtube channels catering to that crowd are going to capitalize as much as they can on it.
In the case of Blizzard-YouTube collusion, I don't think so. Blizzard just took the video down and reuploaded it to hide the dislikes.
 

Mothro

New member
Jun 10, 2017
101
0
0
Samtemdo8 said:
Because holy hell these guys are still uploading the same repetitive content about the Diablo/Blizzard controversy.

YongYea made 7 videos about it.

HeelsvsBabyFace made 11 videos about it.

Every other Youtuber in the gaming scene made 1 or 2 about it themselves.

And I have seen this same outbreak of videos with similar controversies in anything about Videogames and movies. Like Mundanematt made practically 50 videos about the whole fallout from The Last Jedi.

At this point I am convinced they are all doing this more to generate that youtube monies they make with ads. And the people in the comment sections eats it all up. I mean these guys never made videos of this sheer volume and press coverage for anything positive.
Complaining about the complainers doesn't give you the high ground.
 

Samtemdo8_v1legacy

New member
Aug 2, 2015
7,915
0
0
Mothro said:
Samtemdo8 said:
Because holy hell these guys are still uploading the same repetitive content about the Diablo/Blizzard controversy.

YongYea made 7 videos about it.

HeelsvsBabyFace made 11 videos about it.

Every other Youtuber in the gaming scene made 1 or 2 about it themselves.

And I have seen this same outbreak of videos with similar controversies in anything about Videogames and movies. Like Mundanematt made practically 50 videos about the whole fallout from The Last Jedi.

At this point I am convinced they are all doing this more to generate that youtube monies they make with ads. And the people in the comment sections eats it all up. I mean these guys never made videos of this sheer volume and press coverage for anything positive.
Complaining about the complainers doesn't give you the high ground.
I never claimed I have the high ground.
 

PFCboom

New member
Sep 20, 2012
187
0
0
I'm seeing a lot of negativity. Like, WAY too much. It's 50% "OP IS FIGURING THIS OUT JUST NOW LOL I KNEW THIS WAY BACK IN THE DAY" and 50% "LOL YOUTUBE AND YOUTUBERS ARE GARBAGE LIKE DUH." Okay, now I'm going to step back and see if I can't see another angle.

I get that some YouTubers make the same point over and over again. "PC gaming is dead because blah," and then they spend 15 minutes talking about it, and then do the same thing next week. Sometimes, a single story has a central issue plus a lot of other related issues to unpack.
The shitstorm surrounding Diablo Immortal is a terrific example: The way it was announced was mishandled at best, the immediate response from fans was exaggerated - as exemplified by that skidmark who said "is this an out-of-season April Fool's Joke?" and got lots of internet high-fives - Blizzard's response to that response was awful, the backlash against that response was just as loud and angry as the first round of boos, and that's just the first week of news.
Notice that none of that has to do with the game itself, the monetization within said game, the people making the game, the people who asked the people to make the game, or even the overlord parent company who told Blizzard to tell the other people to make the game that everyone is losing their shit over.
None of THAT touches on the toxic microtransactions frequent in mobile games, which is another story in itself that can be examined from seven angles.
Hopefully, by now, y'all're getting that first point. The same thing can apply with Star Wars, Fallout, or fucking anything that has a die-hard fanbase. A single problem isn't isolated to a single "this one thing is pissing me off." Nearly every time something angers someone, it's because there's the one thing, bolstered by seven other things; something something subconscious iceberg something.

Humans are social animals; part of that is an instinctual desire for attention. Even the ones who think they can get by on their own, the super-introverts who work alone and live alone and die alone, those guys get hungry for talk every once in a while. I'm one of those guys, and lemme tell you, if I get you in a car, I will talk and talk and listen and talk and talk and listen and listen and talk.
It's not perfect, but YouTube is a platform where people can say a thing and then thousands of people listen, and that kind of attention can be intoxicating. I mean, shit, if I get seven likes on one of my comments, you can bet your kissable lips I'll be making more comments just like that one.
And that's why some people will upload a half-dozen videos about a single topic. "Oh gee, I talked about Leia having Force powers in this video and it got 6,000 views, better talk more about The Last Jedi so I get 7,000 views on my next one!"

And then, yes, there's a financial angle to all this. We live in a capitalistic society which was built at least marginally off the Puritanical belief that monetary value is equivalent to moral and social value. In other words, whether we like it or not, whether we know it or not, we westerners associate dollar value with self-worth, and we definitely judge other people on how much cash money they have. The idea of "okay, you have a lot of money, but how you spend it is just as important" is actually a relatively new concept, which is why the wider media lost their damn minds over Felix "PewDiePie" Kjellberg making $7,000,000, while the rest of the Internet was like "that's nice, at least he's not buying yachts."
So, yeah, if someone on YouTube is making videos for views for ad-sense dollars, is that something anyone can say "tsk-tsk" over? For some people, it's a living, or a supplementary income that provides fun-money; can any of us stick our noses in the air because some guy on YouTube is trying pay bills, and then have something left over to buy high-quality (product you, the reader, personally value)?

Finally, a pre-emptive rebuttal to some hyperbolic counter-arguments:
Well I don't believe that an issue should be rehashed seven times or more. Once you talk about something, that's all that needs to be said about it.
You are a narrow-minded moron who doesn't understand that opinions are malleable and can change whenever new information is incorporated.
Well I don't believe that an arbitrary dollar amount stored digitally by a corporate entity should be considered. Anyone who does think in terms of "how much money will I make?" is a greedy a-hole undeserving of the money they want to make!"
You are not even living in the same reality as the rest of us. Try to use your moral high-ground as currency literally anywhere, let us know how that goes.
Well I don't believe that YouTube views is a good substitute for real social interaction! People who do anything on YouTube "for the views" is pathetic and need to get out more!
YouTubers with millions of subscribers save hundreds or even thousands of people from total despair, and sometimes suicide, because sometimes, the very illusion of someone talking to them is all it takes for someone to say "nah, it's not worth it to self-destruct just now." And that relationship is two-way. A couple hundred views on a video means a couple hundred people who have heard a person's voice; a few comments saying "OMG ur right blizzard has lost ther way!!!" can save lives. Anyone who has a problem with that needs to re-examine their own priorities.
 

Agema

Overhead a rainbow appears... in black and white
Legacy
Mar 3, 2009
9,917
7,080
118
It's not just the negativity, but that so many people can't do it well.

Have you ever wondered by educational videos by groups like the Khan Academy are only 5-10 minutes long? It's because research shows that people mentally switch off after about 6-7 minutes, so every minute after that is a minute it's far less likely anyone cares or takes it in.

The same applies for online rants. Listening to someone rant, ***** and moan for an extended period of time is just a tiresome drone. At minimum, they need to vary the pace... and frequently don't.
 

Abomination

New member
Dec 17, 2012
2,939
0
0
Agema said:
It's not just the negativity, but that so many people can't do it well.

Have you ever wondered by educational videos by groups like the Khan Academy are only 5-10 minutes long? It's because research shows that people mentally switch off after about 6-7 minutes, so every minute after that is a minute it's far less likely anyone cares or takes it in.

The same applies for online rants. Listening to someone rant, ***** and moan for an extended period of time is just a tiresome drone. At minimum, they need to vary the pace... and frequently don't.
But if they make it short they can't waffle on in a way to make themselves sound like genuine intellectuals.
 

Agema

Overhead a rainbow appears... in black and white
Legacy
Mar 3, 2009
9,917
7,080
118
Abomination said:
But if they make it short they can't waffle on in a way to make themselves sound like genuine intellectuals.
If there are any intellectuals on YouTube, I've never found them - although I've never looked very hard.

More problematic is that in many years of people trying to prove their points with YouTube videos, pretty much no-one's ever supplied support from an intellectual, either: "Hey, here's a random member of the public saying just what I want to believe - PROOF I'M RIGHT!"