I don't now about some of you guys out there but I have yet to have girls start fighting over me. Or really show any sort of interest in me as a potential boyfriend at all. I think some have but considering that I tend to overthink things like this too much I don't know if that was just me jumping at false starts. 'Course I'm too afraid that if I read the messages wrong and think that she does like me, then I'm making a fool of myself. See what I mean with the overthinking?
As for not thinking myself not that attractive, it's probably because - I'm not that attractive. At least when I grow my hair and beard out I'm probably not that attractive. To give you an idea as to how I look, I've earned the nicknames "Caveman" and "Jesus" when I just let things grow. As to when all my hairs are nicely trimmed and combed, I probably don't look half bad. I know I'm no movie star but I also know I'm not butt-ugly.
When it come to the male psyche as a whole, we probably don't generally think ourselves as good-looking for the same reason women don't: commercial standards that have been set too high. All us average looking people see those really attractive and idealed bodies and say to ourselves: "I don't look as good as them. I must be some hideously deformed freak." I know that it's a bit of an exageration but you get my point.