'veritable hub of autism, fanboys and TVTropes editors. Presumably, the members also have short term memory loss, as "X VS Y"[1], "Am I the only one?" and "How do I get a girl to like me?"[3] frequently return to the active topics.'
does have a certain ring of truth to it. But the moderation here is not 'tightassed' at all. If it were, we wouldn't have all those repeat threads, and all of the lovely posters who can't seem to be able to grasp the basic tenets of thinking and typing properly would ridiculed and booted off.
If you want to see what strict moderation looks like, and what it results in, take a gander at the PWOT forums.