I Knew It!

[Omikron009]

Of course its steve blum every single day. Also sgt. foley from mw2 is Goliath in gargoyles!

He is also Captain Anderson from Mass Effect, and the Arbiter from Halo 2 and 3.

 

[Vanguard_Ex]

When I saw that woman in Fable II, was it Theresa?...Well whatever her name was, I instantly saw that woman from KOTOR 2. The hood, the dodgy eyes, the voice, everything.

 

[Fappy]

Brought my 3-year old brother to Frog Princess and fifteen minutes into the movie I told my sister the bad guy was Kieth David. Sure enough the credits confirmed that the Voodoo baddie was in fact Captain Anderson.

 

[magnuslion]

That Joker from Mass effect was seth green.

 

[Jedamethis]

I swear that women in fable two ( forget her name) always makes me think of Kreia from Knight of the old republic 2. For like the whole game I was expecting her to turn on me.

Theresa? Me too...

 

[Fappy]

The same guy who voiced Captain Anderson from Mass Effect also voiced Sgt. Foley from Modern Warfare 2. First line he ever said I knew it was him.

The guy who did Admiral Hackett in ME also did the voice of General Sheperd.

 

[AngloDoom]

Clap Trap. I knew, especially when he went off saying "doo doo doo doo doo" that he was, indeed, voiced by the same guy who voiced Gir in Invader Zim.

After about ten hours of playing, I had the same realisation.

Then about five minutes after that I was watching Invader Zim again.

 

[Kuchinawa212]

I swear that women in fable two ( forget her name) always makes me think of Kreia from Knight of the old republic 2. For like the whole game I was expecting her to turn on me.

Theresa? Me too...

Yeah that's her, granted even at the end of the game she's all like " And now the spire belongs to me" Which I thought was going to lead to a evil laugh

 

[Durxom]

Spoiler: Kyle Hebert (Wario from There will be brawl)

is also..

Spoiler

and the DBZ announcer

 

[Axeli]

Uncharted 2 is full of moments like these. It usually surprised me more if that flag pole I was climbing didn't break, the boulder fall on me or that structure I was crawling through start to crumble. Not quite as predictable as huge windows in old Resident Evil games, but pretty close.

I swear that women in fable two ( forget her name) always makes me think of Kreia from Knight of the old republic 2. For like the whole game I was expecting her to turn on me.

I recall Kreia's voice is a British actress who has done very little voice acting, at leat in video games. Kreia's her only video game role, if I remember correctly. (Well, a quick check on the wiki page shows she also voiced some minor roles in Shattered Union).
I find it unlikely she was in Fable 2 if she's not credited.

 

[TPiddy]

The same guy who voiced Captain Anderson from Mass Effect also voiced Sgt. Foley from Modern Warfare 2. First line he ever said I knew it was him.

Keith David does Captain Anderson. I knew him from watching him in the movie Crash... since then I've heard him in Mass Effect, as Julius in Saint's Row 1 and 2, and as the Arbiter in Halo.

OT: My girlfriend has a lot of these moments, like The Elven leader in Dragon Age is also Tuvok in Star Trek: Voyageur... or the Brotherhood leader in Saint's Row 2 is actually Worf from Star Trek: The Next Generation...

I also picked out Neil Patrick Harris as Veteran Child in Saint's Row 2.

 

[metalmmaniac]

for xmas i got uncharted 2, and shadow complex. i played shadow complex right after i finished uncharted 2. same voice actor as both the main characters.

 

[Erja_Perttu]

Claudia Black has an awesome voice.

Very very true. Gotta love her.

Aaaaaannnnd that Ratchet and Tidus are both voiced by James Arnold Taylor.

My 'I knew it!' moment is connected to this. I was watched the Detective Story segment of The Animatrix and I knew I recognised the voice of the detective. Low and Behold, it be James Arnold Taylor.

 

[MiracleOfSound]

Dragon Age: Origins ...

Inon Zur rips himself off.

Some of the ambient samples on the soundtrack are exactly the same ones he used in Fallout 3.

Noticed it after a few minutes.

Dick move, especially form such an amazing composer.

 

[Toasty Virus]

I was playing Escape from Butcher Bay, and heard a guard that sounded quite like the voice actor of Jack Cayman, Bender, and Marcus Fenix, John Di Maggio. Lo and behold, I was correct.

And then my life went back to being mundane and boring.
[sub]Yay?[/sub]

He also voiced Wakka in FFX =D

 

[Rhayn]

I was watching Stargate SG-1 a few weeks after I got Dragon Age, when I mused myself with the thought that the female character on screen was actually Morrigan, not due to her voice, but due to the way she acted. Funnily enough I didn't make the connection until a week or so later when I read something on the Escapist that involved Claudia Black.

I was quite amused by myself.

But as for a more "I knew it!" moment, was when I noticed Al Mualim and Duncan were voiced by the same actor.