I never thought of the "no homo" thing as an insult towards gay people. I thought it was a way to say "in a non-romantic, non-sexual way" faster, since not being gay automatically means it's not in a romantic or sexual way. Doesn't mean that if you were gay it automatically would be, though.
Case in point: when I read the title, which had been edited by then, I assumed the person meant they had a crush on Bob (although I didn't assume they were gay because I didn't assume a gender). So there you go. "In a platonic way" might have hit a nerve less than "no homo" though I guess.
Anyways. I really like MovieBob. He's intelligent and cultivated, and I like hearing his opinion even when I disagree with him. Unlike some other posters, I'd love to hang out and talk about stuff, I think it would be really interesting for me (probably less so for him. Then again, he'd probably enjoy the attention and being able to talk about stuff he likes for hours). I always look forward to more stuff from him. I think what I prefer is the Big Picture. Reviews are nice and all but they can be reviews of something I'm not interested in at all to begin with AND he says sucks, so in the end the review ends up useless. I'm more interested in more general comments, or more factual descriptions of a story, etc.
The Game Overthinker is cool too. I'm not too interested in the story but I like the content so I figure I'll stick around and maybe I'll warm up to the story or something.
American Bob is okay. In theory it could interest me a lot but a lot of what he says, I'm just "duh" except some stuff for which I think "lolwut". Either way, it's not really making me think about stuff much, but maybe it will with different subjects in the future.
And finally, I think I like his written stuff best. Well with a few exception. His favourite piece of mine was the one about the Oscars shunning Batman. I love what he says and I love the way he says it. And I love how he gets so passionate that he loses his fake accent to go back to the real one.
Oh, side note, awesome long coat that he's got. I really dig it.
To answer your question, I think Bob has a lot of fans. We're nothing special or unique or anything like that. He could probably start a cult if he wanted.