Christ, what a flawless post. I agree with you 100% AND you dropped a totally relevant strip on the thread.NeutralDrow said:That part's a given. Either way, I answered the thread question ("No way in hell would I want this").Dulcinea said:Wouldn't you just not watch it then?NeutralDrow said:No, because I can't even imagine the reclusive and legendarily anti-merchandising Bill Watterson coming out of seclusion to draw more comics for any reason, let alone approve of any sort of adaptation.Dulcinea said:Wouldn't you just not watch it and potentially enjoy the renewed attention the characters receive, possibly resulting in more comics and better shows?NeutralDrow said:I certainly don't. I love the comic too much to easily trust its material to someone else.
Particularly due to the comic's multiple-demographic appeal.
The end of the comic was one of the saddest moments of my childhood, but I certainly respect Watterson's dedication and his reasoning for ending it on a high note, specifically to prevent it from becoming a franchise and live far past its effective lifespan. My suspension of disbelief for this thought experiment only stretches so far, and without creator involvement, I honestly can't see an adaptation as anything but a doomed endeavor.
![]()
As for myself? Like I said, NO. No, I would not. I'm the most optimistic guy on the planet but something deep in me just KNOWS this would not work. What we have in collected editions of the strip is literal magic on paper.
Leave it as it is.
edit
I get mad enough as it is when I see stickers with calvin Praying on the back of trucks. But then, I think about this strip...

And it's sorta ok, ironically. As for merchandising...well...I know Waterson was against it but I do really want a Hobbes doll. I don't mean like fucking Tigger either, I mean Hobbes as a doll, not a Tiger.