Kiefer13 said:
Yes, it's a good idea and it'll probably never happen, for just the reasons you stated. People don't like the idea of playing as the "bad guys", especially if they're the nazis, probably about the closest to completely morally black group of people we've had in real life.
People don't like playing bad guys?
There are lots of popular games where you play thieves, assasins, mobsters etc.
And even when you're one of the good guys in a game you're still often a mass murderer, but with a flimsy story as a 'justification' for your killing spree.
No, i think no game developer dares to make a serious WW2 game where you play on the axis side. To make the game realistic the majority of nazi people and soldiers would have to be not evil. Most of them were not sadistic or anything like that and probably fought because they had to, or because they really believed they were doing the right thing.
Such a game would be popular (if it were any good that is), but soon there would be accusations of the developers being 'nazi sympathizers'. And certain powerful lobby groups would throw there weight around to get the game banned.