If You Could Have One Thing From ANY Piece Of Fiction, What Would It Be?

Recommended Videos

Bara_no_Hime

New member
Sep 15, 2010
3,646
0
0
At the moment...?

A Uterine Replicator (from the works of Lois McMaster Bujold).

If you don't know what that is, then you should read one of her Vorkosigan Saga books. Really good sci-fi series.
 

Da Orky Man

Yeah, that's me
Apr 24, 2011
2,107
0
0
Rowan93 said:
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
I just spent the last several hours looking through tvtropes to see if there was a mention of something that gives you more than three wishes, because I didn't think three wishes was enough.

I suppose I could just say d&d, because one probably exists. There's definitely a ring of unlimited wishes in some sourcebook or other.

Anyway, besides that (wish-granting items in general are kind of a cop-out) there are of course a lot of other tempting choices:

- The Pick Of Destiny (already mentioned in the thread, I don't even know if it has actual powers besides being awesome, but you know that we'll be rocking cause it's fuckin insane.)

- The briefcase from Pulp Fiction - also saw this in the thread and though "Damn. I want that." despite the lack of actual world-changing power.

- An ACU from Supreme Commander. In Supreme Commander, the crazy-fast build times of your typical rts are actually justified in-universe because of the advanced nanotech they have, so this thing is a 20-metre-tall giant robot that also happens to be able to build an army in a couple of hours.
You would chhose this:


Over this?


Yeah, I went there. The ACU can be taken out by a single nuke, and is therefore not good for taking over the world. Try nuking that thing, and it'll throw them straight back at you.
If I wanted a nukeproof mecha of destruction, I'd have asked for an Evangelion. About a billion times as manouverable, and it can actually be piloted by one individual.

The point of the ACU is the ability to build things - to get from nothing to a well-defended base with an ICBM silo and hundreds of tanks takes about two hours. That it's a kick-ass giant robot is just a bonus.
I'd still choose the Titan over the Evangelion. The whole life-force eating thing is a bit of a downer, and it doesn't look as intimidating. Giant half-biological robots are all well and good, but compared to a walking battle-cathedral with guns everywhere they could fit them, including a nova cannon crotch?
 

White-Death

New member
Oct 31, 2011
223
0
0
Rowan93 said:
White-Death said:
The power armor from Vanquish.
I'm not too fond of Vanquish,in fact, I think its a pretty bad game, especially the writing.I could have the same combat if I increase mass effect 1s game speed.
But still, I LOVE the artist who designed the armor and weapons for vanquish.
BEST POWER ARMOR EVER.
It's a bit overly cluttered, I can see a number of weak points (back of knees, neck, hands, back of head), that aerial is going to be snapped off five minutes into any battle, and the only part of the helmet that has glass visible is the bit covering the wearer's mouth and nose. Plus I'm not sure what that is on the suit's ass (power pack?) but sitting down will be pretty uncomfortable.

Sorry, but once you said "best ever" a large, evil part of me was compelled to destroy.
None taken, I myself love to criticize everything.I Do agree it is over cluttered.The things on the hips are power packs and rocket booster of some sort.I think the helmet uses some fancy technology Mcguffin that lets the wearer see through the metal plate using cameras & stuff.The suit is made to be light and maneuverable, not going straight into a fight guns blazing(Well, it does that, but in a quick and agile way)It is about 1000X more maneuverable than the average power armor.
 

ADDmuse

New member
Oct 17, 2011
62
0
0
I would ask for the wish muffin. Then I would wish for immortality(where you live until you die), link my brain to a supercomputer, unlimited resources, and the evil talking skull Murray; because every evil organization needs a figurehead.
 

Rowan93

New member
Aug 25, 2011
485
0
0
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
-SNIPEROO-
If I wanted a nukeproof mecha of destruction, I'd have asked for an Evangelion. About a billion times as manouverable, and it can actually be piloted by one individual.

The point of the ACU is the ability to build things - to get from nothing to a well-defended base with an ICBM silo and hundreds of tanks takes about two hours. That it's a kick-ass giant robot is just a bonus.
I'd still choose the Titan over the Evangelion. The whole life-force eating thing is a bit of a downer, and it doesn't look as intimidating. Giant half-biological robots are all well and good, but compared to a walking battle-cathedral with guns everywhere they could fit them, including a nova cannon crotch?
It doesn't eat life force. I'm pretty sure you're thinking of Bokurano, which I, and subsequently you, only know about because of tvtropes describing it as "Like Evangelion but even more depressing".

Intimidation factor is... well, for one thing, any sane person should consider it almost a non-factor, writing it at the bottom of his list of "things to think about when choosing/designing a weapon" while waiting for all of the other, more important things to fill that space up. On top of that, anything 60 metres tall has an intimidation factor that's so off the charts the measuring device exploded and the person holding it crapped their pants.

One of the many things that matter more than intimidation value is actual combat value, and the Evangelion has super-strength relative to some hypothetical human that was scaled up to 60 metres tall, as evidenced by their mad jumping skillz and that time Asuka throws a warship at a tank division. So yeah, in melee it can simply humiliate the Warlord.
Outside of melee? It has an impregnable forcefield. Yeah, good luck with that.
 

Rowan93

New member
Aug 25, 2011
485
0
0
White-Death said:
Rowan93 said:
White-Death said:
The power armor from Vanquish.
I'm not too fond of Vanquish,in fact, I think its a pretty bad game, especially the writing.I could have the same combat if I increase mass effect 1s game speed.
But still, I LOVE the artist who designed the armor and weapons for vanquish.
BEST POWER ARMOR EVER.
It's a bit overly cluttered, I can see a number of weak points (back of knees, neck, hands, back of head), that aerial is going to be snapped off five minutes into any battle, and the only part of the helmet that has glass visible is the bit covering the wearer's mouth and nose. Plus I'm not sure what that is on the suit's ass (power pack?) but sitting down will be pretty uncomfortable.

Sorry, but once you said "best ever" a large, evil part of me was compelled to destroy.
None taken, I myself love to criticize everything.I Do agree it is over cluttered.The things on the hips are power packs and rocket booster of some sort.I think the helmet uses some fancy technology Mcguffin that lets the wearer see through the metal plate using cameras & stuff.The suit is made to be light and maneuverable, not going straight into a fight guns blazing(Well, it does that, but in a quick and agile way)It is about 1000X more maneuverable than the average power armor.
Well, I suppose after all that my next objection would be "so why not Iron Man's armour?"

Since, besides anything else, I don't see how you can choose power armour that can fly better than an F22 over power armour that doesn't.
 

ablac

New member
Aug 4, 2009
350
0
0
Either the Pika Pika no mi or the Hana Hana no mi. Or a TARDIS or Immortality (though with death on demand). If two id have one of my original with immortality, life would be sweet.
 

Da Orky Man

Yeah, that's me
Apr 24, 2011
2,107
0
0
Rowan93 said:
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
-SNIPEROO-
If I wanted a nukeproof mecha of destruction, I'd have asked for an Evangelion. About a billion times as manouverable, and it can actually be piloted by one individual.

The point of the ACU is the ability to build things - to get from nothing to a well-defended base with an ICBM silo and hundreds of tanks takes about two hours. That it's a kick-ass giant robot is just a bonus.
I'd still choose the Titan over the Evangelion. The whole life-force eating thing is a bit of a downer, and it doesn't look as intimidating. Giant half-biological robots are all well and good, but compared to a walking battle-cathedral with guns everywhere they could fit them, including a nova cannon crotch?
It doesn't eat life force. I'm pretty sure you're thinking of Bokurano, which I, and subsequently you, only know about because of tvtropes describing it as "Like Evangelion but even more depressing".

Intimidation factor is... well, for one thing, any sane person should consider it almost a non-factor, writing it at the bottom of his list of "things to think about when choosing/designing a weapon" while waiting for all of the other, more important things to fill that space up. On top of that, anything 60 metres tall has an intimidation factor that's so off the charts the measuring device exploded and the person holding it crapped their pants.

One of the many things that matter more than intimidation value is actual combat value, and the Evangelion has super-strength relative to some hypothetical human that was scaled up to 60 metres tall, as evidenced by their mad jumping skillz and that time Asuka throws a warship at a tank division. So yeah, in melee it can simply humiliate the Warlord.
Outside of melee? It has an impregnable forcefield. Yeah, good luck with that.
I thought at AT field could be brought down by a railgun. Ok, maybe a railgun with the entire power supply of Japan behind it, but still a gun. And in melee, the titan comes with either a powerfist or a chain-wolverine thing. Plus, titan gets void shields.
 

Rowan93

New member
Aug 25, 2011
485
0
0
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
-SNIPEROO-
-Let me tell you a little story about a man named SNIP-
I'd still choose the Titan over the Evangelion. The whole life-force eating thing is a bit of a downer, and it doesn't look as intimidating. Giant half-biological robots are all well and good, but compared to a walking battle-cathedral with guns everywhere they could fit them, including a nova cannon crotch?
It doesn't eat life force. I'm pretty sure you're thinking of Bokurano, which I, and subsequently you, only know about because of tvtropes describing it as "Like Evangelion but even more depressing".

Intimidation factor is... well, for one thing, any sane person should consider it almost a non-factor, writing it at the bottom of his list of "things to think about when choosing/designing a weapon" while waiting for all of the other, more important things to fill that space up. On top of that, anything 60 metres tall has an intimidation factor that's so off the charts the measuring device exploded and the person holding it crapped their pants.

One of the many things that matter more than intimidation value is actual combat value, and the Evangelion has super-strength relative to some hypothetical human that was scaled up to 60 metres tall, as evidenced by their mad jumping skillz and that time Asuka throws a warship at a tank division. So yeah, in melee it can simply humiliate the Warlord.
Outside of melee? It has an impregnable forcefield. Yeah, good luck with that.
I thought at AT field could be brought down by a railgun. Ok, maybe a railgun with the entire power supply of Japan behind it, but still a gun. And in melee, the titan comes with either a powerfist or a chain-wolverine thing. Plus, titan gets void shields.
Yeah, impregnable never actually means impregnable because of stuff happening. But it can handle nuclear weapons, so it's pretty much impregnable. Plus, an Evangelion is human shaped, so unlike a titan it can actually take cover pretty effectively if things are getting hairy.

Yeah, the Warlord has some melee weapons, but it's way slower than the Eva. Hence humiliate - it's not going to get into a brawl and win by giving more punches than it takes, it's going to dance rings around it, jump up into the air, the Warlord will look around and not realise the Eva is on its back, etcetera. It's got crazy amounts of manoeuvrability. By the end, the titan will have its face in the dirt and be trying futilely to right itself, and the Eva will be standing on top of it doing a tap-dance.
 

DasDestroyer

New member
Apr 3, 2010
1,330
0
0
Rowan93 said:
DasDestroyer said:
Rowan93 said:
DasDestroyer said:
The Sphere from Michael Crichton's, well, "Sphere". After entering it I would be able to control reality simply by thinking about it. I would then proceed to acquire all the awesome stuff people have listed in this thread :D
I haven't read the book, but I've seen the movie and... most of said movie is made of reasons why you don't want The Sphere.
Of course there are downsides... But I feel like things wouldn't have gone as bad if only one person had discovered the Sphere.
Maybe not as bad, but you probably don't want it. Mostly, just don't go to sleep while in control of the sphere's power.

Oh, and don't think too much about what might happen if you do go to sleep, or otherwise let the sphere get to you. Or about what happens when you think about what'll happen if you go to sleep. Or about... yeah, I think you can get where this is going.
Well I could just use the Sphere to remove my need for sleep altogether, although I agree that perhaps this isn't as great a choice as I initially thought, although it is still pretty good. Too bad we never find out what happens to Beth after they are lifted to the surface, since she actually kept her powers.
 

Da Orky Man

Yeah, that's me
Apr 24, 2011
2,107
0
0
Rowan93 said:
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
Da Orky Man said:
Rowan93 said:
-SNIPEROO-
-Let me tell you a little story about a man named SNIP-
I'd still choose the Titan over the Evangelion. The whole life-force eating thing is a bit of a downer, and it doesn't look as intimidating. Giant half-biological robots are all well and good, but compared to a walking battle-cathedral with guns everywhere they could fit them, including a nova cannon crotch?
It doesn't eat life force. I'm pretty sure you're thinking of Bokurano, which I, and subsequently you, only know about because of tvtropes describing it as "Like Evangelion but even more depressing".

Intimidation factor is... well, for one thing, any sane person should consider it almost a non-factor, writing it at the bottom of his list of "things to think about when choosing/designing a weapon" while waiting for all of the other, more important things to fill that space up. On top of that, anything 60 metres tall has an intimidation factor that's so off the charts the measuring device exploded and the person holding it crapped their pants.

One of the many things that matter more than intimidation value is actual combat value, and the Evangelion has super-strength relative to some hypothetical human that was scaled up to 60 metres tall, as evidenced by their mad jumping skillz and that time Asuka throws a warship at a tank division. So yeah, in melee it can simply humiliate the Warlord.
Outside of melee? It has an impregnable forcefield. Yeah, good luck with that.
I thought at AT field could be brought down by a railgun. Ok, maybe a railgun with the entire power supply of Japan behind it, but still a gun. And in melee, the titan comes with either a powerfist or a chain-wolverine thing. Plus, titan gets void shields.
Yeah, impregnable never actually means impregnable because of stuff happening. But it can handle nuclear weapons, so it's pretty much impregnable. Plus, an Evangelion is human shaped, so unlike a titan it can actually take cover pretty effectively if things are getting hairy.

Yeah, the Warlord has some melee weapons, but it's way slower than the Eva. Hence humiliate - it's not going to get into a brawl and win by giving more punches than it takes, it's going to dance rings around it, jump up into the air, the Warlord will look around and not realise the Eva is on its back, etcetera. It's got crazy amounts of manoeuvrability. By the end, the titan will have its face in the dirt and be trying futilely to right itself, and the Eva will be standing on top of it doing a tap-dance.
The kind of cover you need against Titan weaponry is, say NORAD. And how long can an Eva last on batteries? If I remember, it's about three minutes.
 

White-Death

New member
Oct 31, 2011
223
0
0
Rowan93 said:
White-Death said:
Rowan93 said:
White-Death said:
The power armor from Vanquish.
I'm not too fond of Vanquish,in fact, I think its a pretty bad game, especially the writing.I could have the same combat if I increase mass effect 1s game speed.
But still, I LOVE the artist who designed the armor and weapons for vanquish.
BEST POWER ARMOR EVER.
It's a bit overly cluttered, I can see a number of weak points (back of knees, neck, hands, back of head), that aerial is going to be snapped off five minutes into any battle, and the only part of the helmet that has glass visible is the bit covering the wearer's mouth and nose. Plus I'm not sure what that is on the suit's ass (power pack?) but sitting down will be pretty uncomfortable.

Sorry, but once you said "best ever" a large, evil part of me was compelled to destroy.
None taken, I myself love to criticize everything.I Do agree it is over cluttered.The things on the hips are power packs and rocket booster of some sort.I think the helmet uses some fancy technology Mcguffin that lets the wearer see through the metal plate using cameras & stuff.The suit is made to be light and maneuverable, not going straight into a fight guns blazing(Well, it does that, but in a quick and agile way)It is about 1000X more maneuverable than the average power armor.
Well, I suppose after all that my next objection would be "so why not Iron Man's armour?"

Since, besides anything else, I don't see how you can choose power armour that can fly better than an F22 over power armour that doesn't.
I'm more of a stealthy person.I'd rather glide/slide at 200MPH rather than fly and be shot at by every single AA gun, then again, Iron man can throw missiles back.
Still, I love the armor,Just fits me.
 

WindKnight

Quiet, Odd Sort.
Legacy
Jul 8, 2009
1,828
9
43
Cephiro
Country
United Kingdom
Gender
Female
A VF-1 Valkyrie, from Macross.

Well, assuming I can get some piloting lessons for it
 

weirdee

Swamp Weather Balloon Gas
Apr 11, 2011
2,634
0
0
being able to change things by zapping them

fun fact: the popular thread blurb on the front page shows this as "if you could have one thing from ANY pie"

my answer to that would be real fruit
 

The Great JT

New member
Oct 6, 2008
3,721
0
0
Here's my top 5 "Things From Fiction I Would Want".

#5: Telekinesis
#4: An Omni-Tool (Mass Effect)
#3: The Golden Elixir of Immortality
#2: A Green Lantern Ring
#1: The M.E.G.A.S. (M.E.G.A.S. XLR)
 

Vigormortis

New member
Nov 21, 2007
4,531
0
0
Easy. This:
Failing that, either of these:
Failing that, one of these:
Failing THAT, this:
Failing that...well...after four failed attempts I'm not really getting "any" fictional item I want, am I?
 

Rowan93

New member
Aug 25, 2011
485
0
0
DasDestroyer said:
Well I could just use the Sphere to remove my need for sleep altogether, although I agree that perhaps this isn't as great a choice as I initially thought, although it is still pretty good. Too bad we never find out what happens to Beth after they are lifted to the surface, since she actually kept her powers.
I only saw the movie once, a while back, so I don't know that much of the specifics... to the point where that's not even much of a spoiler I guess, nevermind. Yeah, I suppose omnipotence is still pretty good, and actually on-topic *glares at everyone saying they want powers and not actual things*

Da Orky Man said:
The kind of cover you need against Titan weaponry is, say NORAD. And how long can an Eva last on batteries? If I remember, it's about three minutes.
Yeah, the batteries are a problem, but the MP Evas don't need them, nor does Unit-01 after it eats Zeruel. Also the MP Evas (MP= Mass Production. There are nine of them in End Of Evangelion, SEELE owns them) can fly and regenerate. I'd probably go with an MP Eva.

As for cover... I don't think NORAD is a thing you can use for cover, it's an organisation. You could be thinking of whichever mountain, but if so, just name a mountain. Apart from that, mountains are basically what constitutes cover for an Evangelion anyway, or at least hills.

White-Death said:
I'm more of a stealthy person.I'd rather glide/slide at 200MPH rather than fly and be shot at by every single AA gun, then again, Iron man can throw missiles back.
Still, I love the armor,Just fits me.
I think if you fly low at 200mph it's actually more stealthy than moving on land at 200mph, because you don't leave as much of a trail of destruction (in terms of stuff that gets in your way, actual targets will be destroyed no matter how you're moving past them).