If you died and God said...

[Hyper-space]

Minecraft.

Basically whatever god is playing.

 

[Pyrokinesis1019]

Canabalt... or Tetris... or...or...or... Tetris. The music would either keep me busy humming for eternity, or it would build up in my brain (conscience? spirit?) until I just exploded. I would have died twice.
But multiplayer is what makes a lot of games so replayable.

Wait... Unreal Tournament 2004. Definitely.

 

[CarbonEagle]

Garrys Mod. I could make any scenario i felt like, and lots of cool contraptions.

 

[Olrod]

I'd have to choose either Final Fantasy VII or The World Ends With You.

 

[ethaninja]

Does this computer come with notepad++?

 

[Sinclair Solutions]

For all eternity? Civilization. I think i could actually play that game for all eternity. Playing as all the different races and trying out all different strategies...it could work.

 

[Squeaky]

Men Of War, id have enough time to get good with the mod tools and make some great reconstrutions and might be able to do the first Allied Mission..... eventually.

 

[Slythernite]

Either Minecraft or Garrys Mod, as long as updates can still come out.

 

[TOGSolid]

Minecraft, no contest.

 

[Theron Julius]

No multiplayer? I guess minecraft. Imagine the grand structures built in the eternity I shall have? I'd probably start with the Hanging Gardens of Babylon. Maybe build a couple of floating cities forged of mighty obisidian.

 

[Vault101]

Fallout 3 with a secret door to oblivion...

 

[Snake Plissken]

I Wanna Be the Guy, as long as I got a controller with it and not a keyboard. There would then be no excuse for me not to beat it.

 

[ReaperzXIII]

Mass Effect, if I'm dead then I would want to remember my individuality for as long as possible

 

[The-Jake]

If I had to spend eternity with one game, it would have to be one with procedurally-generated content. No matter how expansive or how much of a masterwork a game is, if it has the same content every playthrough, one eternity later you'll be violently sick of it. (Remember, Eternity Is Longer Than You Think It Is.)
For me, picking a candidate that fits that bill would be a toss-up between Spelunky, NetHack, Disgaea, and Dark Cloud 2.

I could just keep modding them... I could be as a god in the game... heh...

Something's starting to make me wonder if "God" is really God, or someone who was asked this question him/her/them/itself an eternity or so ago...

I would say "Then this isn't heaven and you're not god.".

If you make God vanish in a puff of logic, then you're stuck with no game for eternity.

 

[Tdc2182]

I morally could not enter Heaven and would try my hardest to dethrone the deity in question, so I can't really answer such.

You must be very popular at social gatherings.

OT: Halo: Reach.

You wanna know why? I am assuming Forge World would have unlimited credits on the greatest gaming server ever, so I would make my own Planet in Halo.

Eventually, I will attempt to make a Computer in the game out of Forge. From there, I will master Computer tech and try to create a living breathing AI.

And then I will let it create for itself from there.

 

[Death God]

SSBB. I haven't completed all the achievements and this way I could interact with humanity on online multiplayer mode. Or and Civilization game. I could play those for hours on end with no stop.

 

[Masterninjaz12]

For me I'd go with Brutal Legend over the fact how great I thought the game was and the soundtrack is very good in terms of some of the bands I like. The first thing that would probably go out of my body would be my eyes from staring at the tv for eternity without blinking once.

 

[Darzen]

Minecraft. Nuff said

 

[Ace of Spades]

Either Dragon Age: Origins, or Fallout 3. Both are games I can play indefinitely without getting bored.

 

[DarkPanda XIII]

Saints Row 2, definitely, due to the fact that I can continue to build character after character and just have fun :3.