IGN Top 25 360 Games

[FROGGEman2]

Wait...

so Gears doesn't even permeate the list?

WHAT NO YOU'RE DOING IT WRONG.

 

[Uszi]

It'll be fun to see where Batman AA lands. I'm betting top 5.

...I wonder if Orange Box counts as a game...?

AA is a great game.
But once you've beaten it once it's pointless. I didn't really enjoy playing through it again.

My first play through was really exciting: I kept wondering what was going to happen next.

My second I abandoned because I had done it all before.

And the challenges are annoying as hell. Especially the Combat Challenges.

 

[squid5580]

Why do they make these lists? It just makes people angry.

 

[Marowit]

It'll be fun to see where Batman AA lands. I'm betting top 5.

...I wonder if Orange Box counts as a game...?

AA is a great game.
But once you've beaten it once it's pointless. I didn't really enjoy playing through it again.

My first play through was really exciting: I kept wondering what was going to happen next.

My second I abandoned because I had done it all before.

And the challenges are annoying as hell. Especially the Combat Challenges.

Very true, but that doesn't mean it should not be in the top 5 in my opinion. The voice acting was spectacular (mostly because of Mark Hamill) , the combat was fun and fluid, the story was great fun, the riddles for the most part were really well done, and the tape recordings scattered about the island was the icing on the cake for someone who's never read the comics (I'm just assuming all that info you find out in the real comics though I may be wrong).

Should it be #1, probably not, but I'm also not sure what I'd put as my #1. (I agree for the most part what they've put down already).

 

[Awexsome]

What the hell is Halo doing out of the top 5 and Orange Box even doing that high on the list? It's crap on the 360.

I know Halo isn't "teh greatest game evar" but when you consider 360 only I'd call it that.

 

[slipknot4]

Why is it called a xbox 360 list when there is only multi platform games.

 

[THEMANWHOIS]

Mass Effect was good, but by no means number 1. I believe that title should go to either Modern Warfare or Fallout 3.

 

[Mr.Black]

Mass Effect was good, but by no means number 1. I believe that title should go to either Modern Warfare or Fallout 3.

Probably because it was exclusive.

 

[THEMANWHOIS]

Mass Effect was good, but by no means number 1. I believe that title should go to either Modern Warfare or Fallout 3.

Probably because it was exclusive.

But it came out for the PC too. And there were multiple console non-exclusives that made the top 5. And Mass Effect is coming to the PS3 as well. So what makes Mass Effect special?

 

[Mr.Black]

Mass Effect was good, but by no means number 1. I believe that title should go to either Modern Warfare or Fallout 3.

Probably because it was exclusive.

But it came out for the PC too. And there were multiple console non-exclusives that made the top 5. And Mass Effect is coming to the PS3 as well. So what makes Mass Effect special?

Well in that case, nothing I guess. You can't trust half the stuff IGN or Gamespot spew out anyawys.

 

[dancinginfernal]

Fuck yes.

It's about time Mass Effect gets the recognition it deserves. I've played that game at least 15 times over.

 

[ProfessorLayton]

That's a pretty terrible list. I guess I'll have to wait until it's completely finished but so far that list is awful. I mean, BioShock and the Orange Box ranked lower than Halo 3? NHL 10 is higher than Dead Rising and Dead Space? And a crappy console RTS with a Halo skin is a better game than Borderlands? I can understand opinions, but seriously....

 

[drisky]

crap they brought the list here, to many people complaining that it doesn't match their opinions and its following me damn it.