Is a fanfiction depicting the murder of Randy Pitchford ok?

Recommended Videos

IamLEAM1983

Neloth's got swag.
Aug 22, 2011
2,581
0
0
If it had been structured like your average Borderlands 2 plot point - maybe. God knows that series treats casual murder of hundreds upon thousands of pseudo-innocent humans, creatures and androids like some casual and light-hearted fun. :)

It isn't, though. This more or less feeds into the "gamer rage" problem Jim's mentioned in his video, in that we've turned depictions of violence into such an acceptable form of expression - and Anita has as well, by the looks of it, being a gamer herself - that we're okay with writing down fantasy murder sprees that would make even H.H. Holmes do a double-take and say "Whoa, son. Simmer down a little, why don'tcha?"

To me, though, this is more a generational issue than a cultural one. We've been exposed to horror movies and violent games; we're the ones who were targeted when the nineties started to bring forth its Darker and Edgier superheroes, sociopathic antiheroes get all the love and even their own video game (i.e. Deadpool) and we celebrate wanton sociopathy because it's just that zany and opposed to our boring, productive, safe lives (i.e. Saints Row The Third and onwards).

I don't think her little fanfic ties into her being a researcher into Women's Studies and Feminism in general. It just happens to be a little ultraviolent ditty that's been put together by someone who maybe excessively values TVTropes as research material.

I mean, it's a great casual resource and us casual viewers won't mind her using it, but the thing is, TVTropes doesn't have a chance in Hell of being considered academically noteworthy, unlike Wikipedia. I'm sure some serious literary scholars plunked down a few thousands words under the guise of a Troper alias - but the acceptance just isn't there. Insofar, it's just a fun tool to go "Oh, hey; ever noticed how there's always this or that reoccurring motif in our favourite cultural productions?"

TVTropes' closest literary noteworthy cousin probably is anything from the French Structuralist school of literary analysis. Take a class on Ferdinand de Saussure or Julien Greimas and you'll realize the Tropes are treading old ground to mine old favourites and Pop Culture standbys for increased relevancy - which is admirable but difficult to bring forward in an academic context.
 

nuttshell

New member
Aug 11, 2013
201
0
0
firmicute said:
so, context is important.
If you bothered to read the intro to the "game", you would discover, that the game part really isn't what's important.

and the idea that there are no games where you can hit women?
Did you misread that part, or don't you understand the meaning of "imbalance"?

...the "game" is only a symptom of hate against that person.
Does it make it less true? It even explains itself.

but i cant remember seing so much hate and vitriol against any other male person.
There are countless examples, but you do remember George Bush, right?

and also, as i said-I think that art should be allowed to do almost everything (as long as it doenst hurt real people, like enslaving someone for an art action against this persons will) but that doenst mean that i have to approve that.
That's great and you have every right to do so. Just don't judge too easily.
 

The Random One

New member
May 29, 2008
3,310
0
0
This kind of makes me want to write a series of fanfiction in which a disgruntled gamer kills all the big developers. I think I'll name it The Entitled Avenger.

Oh, and OP is a massive hypocrite for calling Anita out on it while being a fan of a medium that subsists almost entirely on fictional murders. Tata now.
 

GoaThief

Reinventing the Spiel
Feb 2, 2012
1,229
0
0
itsthesheppy said:
the murder of prominent game developers are very rare occurrences in real life. A woman getting beaten bloody is something that is literally happening in more than a few places in the world right now as I type this. That's the difference.
I'll see that and raise you 77% of murder victims being male vs 23% female. No doubt that in some countries it's much higher and also probably happening now. Murder is also a very real thing and I'd say much more serious than spousal abuse though the two can be tied of course.

I don't really care much about Anita but your argument is bollocks. ;-)

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/1635092/
 

Lilani

Sometimes known as CaitieLou
May 27, 2009
6,581
0
0
redmoretrout said:
If you get offended by cartoons your opinion isn't worth hearing. That is all.
1. Fanfictions are not cartoons. Well, not usually. Certainly not the ones we're talking about here.

2. This isn't about anybody being "offended," this is about people who are basically writing murder stories about real people OJ Simpson style, except the murder hasn't happened...yet.

3. Threatening people is never okay. It isn't about "objectionable content," or being "offended," it's about being a decent human being. Plus, I'm pretty sure it's also illegal. I don't see how any court of law would see this as anything but making personal death threats.
 

glider4

New member
Mar 27, 2012
38
0
0
Oh my God. She's such a horrible person that it baffles me that anybody could support her. Even hardcore Feminists. I mean I knew she was a terrible person but this is an all new low. She deserves all the hate directed at her
 

MammothBlade

It's not that I LIKE you b-baka!
Oct 12, 2011
5,246
0
0
I like the irony of using a male power fantasy to carry out a deranged fangirl's work...
 

rbstewart7263

New member
Nov 2, 2010
1,246
0
0
MammothBlade said:
I like the irony of using a male power fantasy to carry out a deranged fangirl's work...
lmao too true. I suppose it is hypocrytical. If I wrote a fanfiction where anita died for the "crappy work she done" I imagine Id be another footnote example on her twitter of rampant misogyny.