Is is wrong to pirate games during a time of war?

Recommended Videos

ookie37

New member
Jul 31, 2009
34
0
0
o_O.... !!!! Take that back! or better yet, give me all of your Square Enix games!!!!! i loves me some Square Enix.
 

s0p0g

New member
Aug 24, 2009
807
0
0
Katana314 said:
"Sir, put in an order for the factories to produce 100 more armored tanks to bring to the front lines."
"I'm sorry, sir. I can't do that."
"What?"
"I just got off the line with the armor factories. They refuse to work because our check bounced."
"Wh-...How did that happen? We HAVE been getting revenue from our video game companies, haven't we?"
"About that, sir....it seems that people have been pirating our video games."
"NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO"
LOL made my day ^^

also, it's not just right to pirate games of the opposing nation, it's MANDATORY - or should be, at least - for every patriotic gamer, and there should be severe punishment (see your nation's penal laws for further information) for actually buying these games, as that is high treason (supporting the enemy? son of a...!)
 

The Gnome King

New member
Mar 27, 2011
685
0
0
thaluikhain said:
I was wondering what people thought about pirating games owned by nations your nation was at war with. Would people be in favour of this, and, if so, would this require a Email of Marque or somesuch, to distinguish game piracy from game privateers?

Secondly, would the IP of games be something a nation could demand in war reparations, or take from a defeated enemy?

[small]Possibly the source code of captured games would have to be hidden in a server on some tropical tax haven, or somesuch[/small]
Um... I know this makes me unpopular but I believe it's wrong to pirate games because artists and programmers have a right to make money off their intellectual property.

The one case where I can see bending my stance on this is for games no longer in production, like old Commodore 64 games - sometimes piracy is the only way to GET some of this IP.
 

Mckeown

New member
Jan 8, 2011
57
0
0
Dr. McD said:
Mckeown said:
That's my point, war could result in SE weaponizing the shittiness of Final Fantasy, on the other hand, no war, no weaponized Final Fantasy, FF slowly dies out and is forgotten because nobody buys it.

And yes, it is wrong to pirate games in a time of war, because it shows that their product is better than your own country's product.
i don't think it really matters what country a game is from. if it's good, then you should play it. and besides, if you buy another country's game, then you're not saying that their games are better, just that they're good. still, the last good FF (in my opinion)was IX. X was okay, good gameplay, but bad story and characters, but X-2 was an abomination and XII was medeocre at best. i haven't played XIII, but i don't hold much hope and definately not for XIII-2 which i've heard rumours of. XIV isn't even worth discussing.

here's hoping people come to their senses soon.
 

barbzilla

He who speaks words from mouth!
Dec 6, 2010
1,465
0
0
Please allow me to answer your question with another question. Are you personally responsible for your government's actions? Didn't think so, so why hold a video game company responsible for theirs? The people there work just as hard to make a video game as the developers in other countries. Honestly the only time I can justify downloading a game you don't own is if the game is so old that it is completely out of print and can't be found in stores.
 

ZtH

New member
Oct 12, 2010
410
0
0
The comparisons to privateers during the European expansion to the Americas in the OP are brilliant. I say pirate away in this case. Legally sanctioned pirating in the name of the war effort sounds absolutely ridiculous and thus pretty awesome.
 

LiudvikasT

New member
Jan 21, 2011
132
0
0
Can we end these topics. Lets get this straight:
1. Pirating is always a crime.
2. Pirates are not out there to eat your kids.

I hate how escapist has this trend of looking at pirating with wide eyes, like it's some big black monster in the corner of the room. Pirates, me including, most likely don't have money to buy games, often they don't even have a way to buy (game digital distribution is surprisingly accessible to me, so I use steam on occasion), but if I want to buy movies/music/books often importing is the only option and that is expensive (how can anyone be surprised of pirating, when the price is highest in lowest income areas, is beyond me).
 

RA92

New member
Jan 1, 2011
3,079
0
0
thaluikhain said:
I was wondering what people thought about pirating games owned by nations your nation was at war with. Would people be in favour of this, and, if so, would this require a Email of Marque or somesuch, to distinguish game piracy from game privateers?

Secondly, would the IP of games be something a nation could demand in war reparations, or take from a defeated enemy?

[small]Possibly the source code of captured games would have to be hidden in a server on some tropical tax haven, or somesuch[/small]
That was... a pretty brilliant, I would say. ^_^

Those taking the default 'piracy-is-bad-at-all-times'... for Cthulhu's sake, people kill each other at times of war and decimate entire civilizations. Like anyone would adhere to (relatively) petty moralities of copyright laws at such desperate times.

The video game industries support their respective governments through taxation, and a warring nation will try to hurt its opponent through any means necessary.

DISCLAIMER: Not promoting piracy here.
 

Caer Seraphim

New member
Mar 1, 2011
28
0
0
Anyone remember the trade sanctions against Iraq and how they weren't allowed to import PS2s from Japan because they are powerful enough to be reprogrammed into military computer for missile launch centers, etc? Hell, if you're actually in the center of "real" war (as in, on the bad side of it), and you can get stuff like this on the black market, then no super-morality of international copyright law can possibly justify itself in the face of thousands of people starving to death and being denied medical care because some rich ____ is fighting with some other rich _____ somewhere else in the world. The lack of existence of morality behind copyrights in the face of war is absolute bull, and elitists who don't experience war should try living under extreme conditions before they criticize the victims for such a non-offense. What doesn't kill people... doesn't kill people.