Is witcher 3 has worst combat ever?

[SolidState]

I respect your opinion my friend but its factually correct that witcher 3 combat is not very good.

I respect your opinion my friend

No, you don't.

Calling someone else's views and opinions "factually incorrect" each time someone disagrees with you (like you tend to do), is a 'I'm-right-and-everyone-else-is-wrong' mindset, which is the complete opposite of respect.

And I refuse to believe that you're not aware of yourself doing this, because this happens in every one of your threads.

 

[infohippie]

Nope, I rather liked Witcher 3 combat. Much better than the average "action" game where it's all about how fast you can mash the attack button. Not as in-depth as some games, and that's okay, TW3 is about MUCH more than the combat.

BEST combat in any game, in my opinion, was probably the old Mechwarrior games. Now that was FUN.

 

[IceForce]

Nah OP, Doom has the worst combat ever. It's just point-and-click, how boring is that?

In contrast, Candice Debebe's Incredibly Trick Lifestyle has some of the best combat you'll ever see in a video game.
If you disagree you are factually wrong.

 

[B-Cell_v1legacy]

I never played the first two Witcher games because I heard about how awful their combat was, but the combat in Witcher 3 is one of the many reasons it fast became my favorite game of all time. In Death March difficulty, the amount of quick-thinking involved in staying alive was (in my opinion) on par with Dark Souls. Unfortunately, you become pretty OP about halfway through Witcher 3, but before you reach level ~15, combat was very Souls-esque in both execution and urgency.

come on my dear friend, it seem like you have not played much games if you think witcher 3 combat is any good. even those who give it GOTY think its combat suck but they love story, presentation stuff.

the controlling is also terrible. It apears that they design with controller in mind. gerald of rivendale can barely navigate a ladder.

Yeah, I've only been playing video games since my mom and I spent nights battling for high scores in Pitfall on our Atari 2600 back in 1982. What would a newcomer like me know about combat systems? How could someone like me actually have an informed opinion about my subjective taste in video games and the mechanics I enjoy in each?

I'll leave my opinion up to professionals next time.

---------------------------

FOR REALSIES, I still think Witcher 3 had some of the most enjoyable combat of any game I've ever played. I over-leveled at times because I got sucked into running around killing mobs rather than questing.

I dont think witcher 3 in general is a bad game infact i beat it twice my friend. and i give it 6 or 7/10. its average. its not Assassins creed quality of bad. what i meant is that its nowhere near as good as reviewers claim and even slapping 10/10 to a game that has AWFUL controls. and dialouges are so boring that i forced to skip over and over again. Ciri parts are pretty bad. just hack n slash which is poorly done.

plus too many awful useless sex scenes which not needed in this game....

 

[B-Cell_v1legacy]

But compared to other games? It is a 9... and I do not give 10s. The best game of the last 8 years and the best game of last year (easily) IMHO.

in last 8 years??!!

Stalker, Crysis, Deus Ex HR, witcher 2, dishonored, Metro, shadow warrior etc completely OWN this game in every single way.

 

[B-Cell_v1legacy]

Shadow Warrior or the rest.

Shadow warrior sword play could teach witcher 3 how to do a good combat.

 

[Adam Jensen_v1legacy]

Witcher 3 is easily my favorite game of all time. I love the combat as well. It's not a deep combat system, but it's IMO very fun and addictive. It really makes me feel like I'm controlling a master swordsman who's faster and stronger than regular humans. That was their goal and they've accomplished it as far as I'm concerned.

 

[Pseudonym]

I wondering.is grammerr has kill?!?can threabe write with modicum of efert while insult other taste

OT: Well, everything I don't like at the moment is obviously the worst thing ever. I haven't played witcher 3 but I didn't really like witcher 2 so obviously witcher 3 is a terrifying abortion of a game that should never have existed.

Just a tiny bit of nuance allong with some better grammar would be much appreciated OP.

 

[Casual Shinji]

plus too many awful useless sex scenes which not needed in this game....

You mean the sex scenes you have to actively pursue? You don't want sex in this game and it won't force it on you, so I don't know what the problem is there.

 

[DoPo]

plus too many awful useless sex scenes which not needed in this game....

You mean the sex scenes you have to actively pursue? You don't want sex in this game and it won't force it on you, so I don't know what the problem is there.

Oh, come on - you know that if he stick to the "factually correct" stuff, he wouldn't have anything to say, right?

 

[SecondPrize]

Clearly you've never played the Witcher 2. When you do that and comment on how that one is indeed the worst ever, then you need to play the Witcher. CD PRoject Red doesn't make Western-style Action RPGs, they make pure cRPGs that just happen to look enough like Western RPGs that it tricks you into thinking you're there for anything but the characters and the story. You're not.

 

[Silverbeard]

Bah.
Witcher 3's combat was functional at worst and heart-pounding at best. What's the real difference between Witcher 3's combat and Dark Souls in terms of pure mechanics? Both games play with the same mechanics: dodge your enemy when it attacks, attack while said enemy is recovering, block/parry judiciously. Rinse and repeat. So why aren't there dozens of threads decrying Dark Souls' combat as being abject shit?
At least TW3 shakes up the formula by allowing players to use cool bombs and combat magic.

 

[Bombiz]

I have one question for you b-cell. When does shadow warrior get good? Every time I play it I can't get past the second mission because I'm so bored with the gameplay. When b does using sword only get/feel good?

 

[Spushkin]

Witcher 3 is indeed has well combats.

There, I think that settles it. It's Sunday, can't exert myself too many, lol.

 

[Drops a Sweet Katana]

I am utterly convinced B-Cell is just fucking with us at this point. Unless they've had a stroke recently, I can't think of any reason for the sudden and complete loss of ability to English.

 

[Mcgeezaks]

But compared to other games? It is a 9... and I do not give 10s. The best game of the last 8 years and the best game of last year (easily) IMHO.

in last 8 years??!!

Stalker, Crysis, Deus Ex HR, witcher 2, dishonored, Metro, shadow warrior etc completely OWN this game in every single way.

According to metacritic they don't, what do you have to say about that?

I am utterly convinced B-Cell is just fucking with us at this point. Unless they've had a stroke recently, I can't think of any reason for the sudden and complete loss of ability to English.

Well duh, I hope you're ready to get a warning for pointing it out, though.