I've spent years amassing a collection of anime DVDs...and now I'm questioning that choice.

Recommended Videos

Imperioratorex Caprae

Henchgoat Emperor
May 15, 2010
5,499
0
0
Years ago I had a collection of great anime ranging from the 80s/90s to 2003-2004 era of US releases. Some were subbed, some dubbed (I'm of the mind that as long as I can reasonably enjoy it, sub or dub quality isn't an issue, sue me if you don't like it). I'd say it was roughly $2000 worth of DVDs and VHS that I watched regularly, but then financial times hit hard. Very fucking hard. I had to make the choice of selling them or some other things that meant a lot less and dammit I went with the anime because I was feeling like I basically had hit the end of my time with it. I regret that choice, even though I pretty well have sworn off anime at this point. I'd still love to have that whole collection back because of the sentimental value.

I usually don't put much stock in material stuff, but there's a few small things that I either have, have lost, have had stolen, or got rid of that I really really did not/do not want to part with. When I gave up MtG 10 years ago and gave away one of the most awesome (and frustrating to play against) mill decks I've ever made (along with a collection of cards ranging back to the Revised days)... well I regret that decision but at that time I was very very depressed and not in a right state of mind. While I regret that decision and some of the things that happened post-decision, the whole situation got me to accept help I desperately needed and get some things straightened out that really needed to be.

So my advice, if the collection means something to you, even if you feel you might have either outgrown anime or just don't have the time for it, I'd say keep it around. And just because anime is prolific online doesn't mean you'll always have access to it. You never know whats around the corner for you, if you're going to move to an area where internet sucks or you have a huge life change that puts you in a position to downgrade or even get rid of internet in your budget (which I've had to do multiple times). Having a physical collection of stuff is valuable in an age where things of that nature seem to be downsizing heavily.

I am of two minds on this, I feel that yes digital distribution is a good thing but it has to be tempered with a prolific internet availability in terms of speed and physical access (and a bit of loosening the grasp of draconian DRM). I'm not totally against companies protecting assets and such, but I also remember a very profound quote from Leia in A New Hope that works fairly well when paraphrased... I'm sure I don't need to mention it. Anyway... sorry for the digression.

TL;DR - Keep your collection, you never know exactly what will happen in your future and you might come to regret decisions made in haste.
 

VanTesla

New member
Apr 19, 2011
481
0
0
The Rogue Wolf said:
My advice: Keep them. You never know when you might end up without Internet (or living someplace that has metered Internet) and want to watch your old shows.

(Also, be glad you have them in a format you can still watch. I've got about eighty VHS tapes from my anime days sitting in a box in my living room.)
Well for the VHS depending on what country you live in you can still easily get a VHS/DVD converter to solve your VHS box problem for not that much money if you know where to look. Then if you have a decent computer with high storage you can have all digital back up copies which if they are all stuff you purchased and you are not going to say try and sell any of the copies you are in your legal right to do so.
 

JohnnyDelRay

New member
Jul 29, 2010
1,322
0
0
Keep them! You don't want your collection to be dependent upon other things. I have a backup of all my GOG.com games for that very reason, wish I could say the same about Steam. Even though they will probably never go down in my lifetime, I still wish my internet was a bit more reliable (or accessible from anywhere).

And yes, who knows how much they will be worth if one day they reach vintage status and you are sure you'll never watch them again.
 

EHKOS

Madness to my Methods
Feb 28, 2010
4,815
0
0
I'd say sell them if you could use the money. I have a Borderlands 2 ULC I've been trying to move, Gamestop offered $40. If they put a one in front of that I'd think about it. If you can sell for a fair price and you could use a buffer on your bank account then do it. I used to collect all the cool, unique items that came with video games. The only one I think I'll always keep is the Fallout 3 Lunchbox and Bobble-head. The rest could go for the right price. The whole PS1/2/3 library really, barring the games I haven't beaten yet. Heck, I did sell over half the PS1 collection when my coffers were empty. I only feel bad about not being able to look at Tomba 2's perfect cover art in pride. And being prideful over possessions is all sorts of silly. Especially when I could be using those assets. (The Taco Bell people know my name)
 

Ambient_Malice

New member
Sep 22, 2014
836
0
0
When licensing bullshit purges your favorite anime from the face of the internet, those physical copies will come in handy.
 

White Lightning

New member
Feb 9, 2012
797
0
0
I only but DVD's for Anime I really like, like Cowboy Bebop and Hellsing Ultimate. Sell the ones you don't care about and hold on to the rest. Also Sword Art Online isn't nearly as good as everyone makes it out to be. Watch Space Dandy instead.
 

NiPah

New member
May 8, 2009
1,084
0
0
White Lightning said:
I only but DVD's for Anime I really like, like Cowboy Bebop and Hellsing Ultimate. Sell the ones you don't care about and hold on to the rest. Also Sword Art Online isn't nearly as good as everyone makes it out to be. Watch Space Dandy instead.
Everyone certainly does not make Sword Art Online out to be good, every time the show is brought up you get people coming out of the woodwork complaining about how bad it was (funny enough they almost always start off with how much people like it).

Honestly I never saw the merits of telling people how bad something is, better off spending time telling people why Space Dandy is instead of wasting your breath being SAO hater number 4,532.
 

Julius Terrell

New member
Feb 27, 2013
361
0
0
I'd kill for my YuGiOh(Duel Monsters) back! I don't care what you guys say about the show. I watched that show till the DVDs nearly melted. Somehow that show disappeared, but I loved listening to dvd menu music and looking at the cards in the extra menu. I got that show in my early 20s and I still reminisce about watching that some 10+ years later. You can't get those kinds of experience with just watching shows online. I had a rather sizable VHS collection before DVDs came in style. Those were the fucking days! :) :) :) :) :)
 

Slenn

Cosplaying Nuclear Physicist
Nov 19, 2009
15,782
0
0
Keep them! It's the same reason why I still hang onto my old Playstation 2 and the many games that are with it: Because they're timeless classics that you cherished! I always collect old anime shows because I also want to support the hard work put into them. You could have retro nights with your friends watching them.
 

Elementary - Dear Watson

RIP Eleuthera, I will miss you
Nov 9, 2010
2,980
0
0
Oly J said:
I went through the same thing as you, dude. I have over 600 DVDs, and I loved buying them. I bought films if they were cheap, and I wanted to watch them, and if I liked a movie I watched on TV I would buy it on DVD as I liked having it.

Recently I realized how much I had spent on my collection, and the ridiculous physical space it takes up. I also realize how I now rely on Netflix and Amazon prime now, and I rarely need to put a DVD on. I even have wanted to watch a film, and then watched it on Netflix, even though I have the DVD, because it's easier.

I had to make the choice, and I have totally stopped with the obsessive DVD buying now. I still have them, and I will still watch them when I want to eventually, but I don't need new ones any more. I don't have as much time for films any more, and I know I will never watch everything, so I run off of Amazon/Netflix lists now, or make sure I catch a film at the cinema with friends for that extra experience.
 

likalaruku

New member
Nov 29, 2008
4,290
0
0
I've been there. I've been watching anime since 1989 or 1990, though my interest has severely waned due to my near intolerance of modern otaku & hatred of moe dominance in newer animes.

Anyway, I had a ton of VHS, manga, & some DVDs. I had soundtracks from animes so old they were on cassette & vinyl. Pointless since I can read manga & watch anime online. It's like collecting decades old consoles when you can just emulate them; you're buying something that takes up space, more & more space as time goes on. I even stopped buying physical discs & learned to love direct downloads.

You have to look at your collection & honestly ask yourself "When am I ever going to watch this again? Will it be next year? 5 years? 10 years? Is my collection getting out of hand? Do my friends joke that my house looks like it belongs on an episode of Hoarders?"

I can tell you that the resale value compared to the cost is bupkis unless the series is trendy.
 

White Lightning

New member
Feb 9, 2012
797
0
0
NiPah said:
White Lightning said:
I only but DVD's for Anime I really like, like Cowboy Bebop and Hellsing Ultimate. Sell the ones you don't care about and hold on to the rest. Also Sword Art Online isn't nearly as good as everyone makes it out to be. Watch Space Dandy instead.
Everyone certainly does not make Sword Art Online out to be good, every time the show is brought up you get people coming out of the woodwork complaining about how bad it was (funny enough they almost always start off with how much people like it).

Honestly I never saw the merits of telling people how bad something is, better off spending time telling people why Space Dandy is instead of wasting your breath being SAO hater number 4,532.
Must of misread my post, I didn't say it was bad. I just said it isn't as good as people tend to say it is. Maybe I shouldn't of said "everyone" but the only reason I watched it was because everyone I knew said it was amazing. Literally. ALL the people I have ever known told me to watch it.
 

FPLOON

Your #1 Source for the Dino Porn
Jul 10, 2013
12,531
0
0
I'll just be echoing what most people are saying in this thread in terms of keeping one's physical collection, however I want I add in the fact that, for the most part, DVD/Blu-Ray copies in comparison to their digital counterparts usually comes with bonus/extra features that are only available on the physical copy... For me, that's one of the main reasons why my DVD/Blu-Ray collection holds up more than my "digital collection" outside of the obvious notion of holding said physical collection in my hands and shit...

Other than that, I got nothing... I just hope whichever decision you end up making in terms of your anime DVD collection makes you happy in the long run...