IOwnTheSpire said:
So an alien with godlike powers who doesn't know where he comes from, who knows he'll always be different from the people who share the planet he calls home, wonders what his purpose in life is and weighs the consequences of the revelation of his existence... therefore, he's emo? Superman has every right to brood, moreso than Batman. This interpretation of Superman is just as valid as the versions you enjoy, so get over it.
Someone disagrees with you on the internet? Why don't you get over it (it being that I would prefer a mainstream portrayal instead of these director's "inspired versions")? Look, don't tell me what to do. Keep it at why you think I'm wrong. Let's keep this directed at our positions, eh?
He's emo because he hovers around in the dark and broods. Keep in mind I'm talking 2006, not 2013.
The idea is that they are shooting themselves in the foot. You may just adore emo superman and I'm glad they made movies that you enjoyed. But it clearly didn't work.
Then they made action hero superman which did work but for the wrong reasons (panned critically but fun to watch). It worked as an action film but it could have been any superhero that could fly and had super strength and absolutely place no value on the mass murder of humans during battles being fought.
So they're appropriating the brand name to carry out a drastically different version of Superman. You're right that it's their prerogative to do so as they please, but they are evidently missing out on a significant market opportunity of traditional fans. Customers who have gone a tremendous way to reward Marvel for their work. Now, perhaps Marvel's characters just lend themselves to film well. Maybe, but it'd be nice to see a movie once in a while where the hero is just a good guy and the bad guys are just bad. There's a lot of fun to be had by demonstrating the superman of wonder and love of mankind. There's a lot of meat on those bones that I don't think have ever been tackled.
Batman, I understand why he's where he's at and I'd say his darker form has always been under the surface even in Adam West days even though the comics white washed everything to the point of extreme campiness. The flash on TV is doing a pretty darn good job of the Flash along those lines. A little brooding here over his past and the we're back to the story and his humor.
If they're just going to take Aquaman and make him into Namor, then so be it. At least they're doing it with a very unpopular character (to the point of being a laughingstock) and before Marvel gets to it.