It's load better than the other two, but still not great, and I think these are the reasons why:
1) He's on the screen. Of the other popular videos on this site, the only ones with people actually in, are the ones where the people are bubbly, not to mention pretty, girls. The episode where Yahtzee unveiled himself was disappointing, and luckily he didn't include that in his videos since. Similarly, MovieBob's Escapist videos are more accessible than his Overthinker series, because of the animation, and lack of, well, MovieBob
2) The British camp thing doesn't work well with the image. A dictator style podium, simple but bold back drop, and the aggressive name don't match the personality. People could forgive the fact that the name doesn't match the content if the content was really good regardless.
3) A lot of this stuff has been said before. Everyone on this site has a niche, such as scathing criticism, reviews on movies, lectures on gaming concept, a list show, a comic strip, a "lets play" style show featuring only unskippable scenes, a reality tv show with porn stars, a bizarrely out of place show that drops stuff... and all (or most) of those guys cover topics like the ones addressed here, in their written columns. A video of it seems rather moot and unoriginal, no matter what your approach or individual take on events are.
4) The paintshop effects and use of memes needs to change or improve. Sorry, it just contrasts too harshly with the fine tuned, and polished (although deceptively simple) efforts of the other contributors.
I guess this is too much like a youtube blog to be taken seriously, at least by me. The other contributors stand out, and give me something to look forward to every week, like a great television show. This is a bit like something I might stumble across on youtube, and while I may enjoy it, or agree with points made in it, I wouldn't book mark it.
tl;dr This show feels like it lacks professionalism in the production department, and won't be enjoyed, regardless of content, until this issue is addressed.
Sorry