This is ridiculous, yeah the guy is an idiot and an A-hole, but I can't believe this is actually going through...
Sounds about right. There's no shortage of people saying the most horrible crap on the internet, but noone cares. Instead you just get told to get 'tougher skin' or not to 'feed the trolls'. And now suddenly everyone thinks that this kid deserves fucking jail time. Disgusting.Balimaar said:So next time an American person says to me that he will rape my entire family and burn my house and the houses of all my relatives down... I can have him arrested?
Tomorrow's headline:
Half the Online Population of the USA is in Prison
"You can say whatever you want but If you do I'll throw you in jail" Is not freedom of speech...valium said:This idiot is being made an example of. Doesn't matter if everyone and their second cousin's girlfriend's mother knows this idiot was not being serious about shooting up a school, what he said was unlawful and they need to set precedence in going after people who make threats.
Look, freedom of speech does not mean freedom from consequences. You say something, and you have to live with the consequences.
Just to repost...since it's apparently still very relevant months after the fact.LostGryphon said:As Justice William J. Brennan, Jr. wrote in the 1989 Texas v. Johnson decision...
"if there is a bedrock principle underlying the First Amendment, it is that government may not prohibit the expression of an idea simply because society finds the idea offensive or disagreeable."
Some of you people being all right with this, or even calling for punishment, for a tasteless off-hand joke, are, in my opinion, much more deserving of evaluation than this poor sod.
As has been stated before, likening this sarcastic statement, made on facebook, to yelling "bomb" in an airport is just disingenuous and, frankly, a false comparison. If this guy had walked into a school and loudly proclaimed he'd shoot up the place, then you would have a point.
As it stands, this is a gross overreach of police power and a violation of numerous rights afforded to a U.S. citizen.
By all means, investigate the kid. But that is all. Going to these lengths, setting the bail so high, placing the kid in solitary, only after he was beaten by other inmates, and not holding a hearing for months, even as their investigation turned up absolutely nothing of value...
How can any of you defend something so reprehensible? Gods above, I certainly don't hope something so terrible should befall any of you lot.
What do you mean no sympathy for him? Most people agree that the joke was tasteless, but the punishment is far from acceptable, yet alone necessary and are advocating for the kid to be released and all charges dropped.Kungfusam said:I bet if it wasn't a white male you're talking about then EVERYONE would agree this is unjustified, but it is a white dude, so no sympathy for him