Least/Most Cliched Protagonists

Recommended Videos

-Drifter-

New member
Jun 9, 2009
2,521
0
0
Every now and then a game comes along featuring a main character who breaks the mold, someone who is in possession of an actual personality and traits that go beyond having really shiny armor. On the other hand, there are also games where the protagonist is so generic, so bland and overused that you could replace him with a main character from another game and no one would even notice.

What is, in your own opinion, one of the least cliched protagonists in gaming? Or, alternatively, the most?

As far as least cliched goes, I'd probably say Jade. First off, she's... well, a she. Secondly, she doesn't dress like a stripper, something that seems to be a rarity when it comes to female characters. Thirdly, she's not white. I don't think it has to do with racism (at least not on a conscious level) but you don't really see a whole lot of non-white main characters, and what few there are are usually stereotypes. It's refreshing to see a character who is neither white nor a stereotype from time to time.


As for most cliched, Marcus Fenix seems like the obvious choice. Unlike Jade, he is male, is white, and is thicker than a tree. Pretty much his only form of communication is growling bad-ass one-liners and he's encased inside a suit of armor that even a man of his gargantuan proportions would have trouble standing up in. It's hard to picture Marcus living any sort of normal life, to the point where you have to wonder what he did before the war broke out. Chainsaw carvings, maybe?

 

Raziel_Likes_Souls

New member
Mar 6, 2008
1,805
0
0
Faceless Space Marine that cracks one liners. Or Marcus Fenix, as you said.

Least cliched though? I don't know, the Chrono Trigger type of silent protaganist, where the main character only has choices, so you fill in the blanks yourself.
 

godofallu

New member
Jun 8, 2010
1,663
0
0
I was going to say Marcus for most cliched, but you beat me to it.

Oh and I disagree with your least cliched pick, she DOES dress slutty and she IS white. At least based on the picture you posted.
 

-Drifter-

New member
Jun 9, 2009
2,521
0
0
godofallu said:
Oh and I disagree with your least cliched pick, she DOES dress slutty and she IS white. At least based on the picture you posted.
I fail to see how she dresses slutty. Because her shirt shows her midriff? Perhaps you're just a prude.

As for her being white, there's not much I can say aside from "no, not really."
 

godofallu

New member
Jun 8, 2010
1,663
0
0
-Drifter- said:
godofallu said:
Oh and I disagree with your least cliched pick, she DOES dress slutty and she IS white. At least based on the picture you posted.
I fail to see how she dresses slutty. Because her shirt shows her midriff? Perhaps you're just a prude.

As for her being white, there's not much I can say aside from "no, not really."
She isn't exactly wearing jeans and a shirt. More like a bra and an open jacket. As far as white goes she is clearly white in that picture. Granted she is a bit tan, but clearly white. I get that you are biased because you love this character, but come on man.
 

WanderingFool

New member
Apr 9, 2009
3,991
0
0
Most cliched, I would go with the male lead that uses a big ass sword, looking squarely at Cloud Strife.

Least cliched... not a fucking clue...
 

maturin

New member
Jul 20, 2010
702
0
0
godofallu said:
Oh and I disagree with your least cliched pick, she DOES dress slutty and she IS white. At least based on the picture you posted.
She doesn't dress modestly, but you aren't from Saudi Arabia, are you?

There may be some backstory somewhere stating that she's Latina in a universe where most people are anthropomorphic pigs and cows, but I couldn't tell otherwise.
 

Anarchemitis

New member
Dec 23, 2007
9,102
0
0
That Picture of Fenix is even clichéd. Look at the color intonation; Teal and orange, it's as generic as action movies and games can be.
 

Dannyboy1186

New member
Jul 14, 2009
226
0
0
Not sure if I thought this through but I think Alister from Dragon Age is not a cliched male character.

The most cliched character I can think of is Cloud from FF7. (Although was he the first of his kind?)
 

Terminate421

New member
Jul 21, 2010
5,773
0
0
Kharloth said:
Most Cliched: Soap from Modern Warfare 2:
Mohawk, trying to hard to be badass, cracking one liners and spouting military jargon.

Least:
Can't think of any right now.
I agree with that

as for least cliched, Isaac clarke maybe?
He's just an engineer stuck in a shit situation. Same goes with Alan Wake.
 
May 23, 2010
1,328
0
0
Lest cliched: The Space Gnome from Samerost 2


Most cliched: I'd actually go with Dom, not Marcus. Sure Marcus' last name is Pheonix, but Dom's wife dies and we're supposed to find that sad.

Whenever people say Soap, do you thing COD, or Lock, Stock, and Two Smoking Barrels? It's a good way to judge your worth as a person.
 

Brazilianpeanutwar

New member
Jul 29, 2010
278
0
0
Least cliched : got to be Abe from abes oddysee,how many other leads are green/blue with stitches on their mouth and a freaky little ponytail? Plus he talks like a mouse farting through a trumpet and he can possess you and make your head asplode *kapow!*

Plus he farts....alot...


Most cliched : dayumn where do i start? How about every single final fantasy character in the past ten years? They all seem to have been built upon the last one.

Yeah i went there!
 

-Drifter-

New member
Jun 9, 2009
2,521
0
0
godofallu said:
-Drifter- said:
godofallu said:
Oh and I disagree with your least cliched pick, she DOES dress slutty and she IS white. At least based on the picture you posted.
I fail to see how she dresses slutty. Because her shirt shows her midriff? Perhaps you're just a prude.

As for her being white, there's not much I can say aside from "no, not really."
She isn't exactly wearing jeans and a shirt. More like a bra and an open jacket.
Actually, she is wearing jeans and a shirt. Maybe said shirt is a bit revealing, but it's hardly a bra.
 

godofallu

New member
Jun 8, 2010
1,663
0
0
maturin said:
godofallu said:
Oh and I disagree with your least cliched pick, she DOES dress slutty and she IS white. At least based on the picture you posted.
She doesn't dress modestly, but you aren't from Saudi Arabia, are you?

There may be some backstory somewhere stating that she's Latina in a universe where most people are anthropomorphic pigs and cows, but I couldn't tell otherwise.
Oh I have no problem with a girl dressing provocatively. I just thought it was funny that the OP used her, and then followed with two examples that were clearly wrong.

The anime esque skinny punkish white girl in revealing clothing is pretty damn cliche.
 

DeadMix

New member
May 30, 2010
114
0
0
Terminate421 said:
Least: Isaac Clarke

Most: Marcus Fenix but even then, he was meant to be that way.
Why's your least Isaac Clarke? That's the guy from Dead Space, right? He doesn't talk?

OT: I don't have a least, just a favorite: John Marston.

Clichéd: The Silent Protagonist. It was OK in BioShock and Half-Life, bun anywhere else just bothers me.
 

Sacman

Don't Bend! Ascend!
May 15, 2008
22,661
0
0
Least- Roxas...
Most- there are so many I don't even know where to start... Master Chief perhaps...
 

Superhyperactiveman

New member
Jul 23, 2009
396
0
0
Most Cliched: War from... I don't even remember the name of the game. Yahtzee reviewed it. End of the world. 4 horsemen of Apocalypse. Like God of War, but... He looks like someone started drawing him and never stopped.

Least cliched: Does not compute. Does not compute. Error! Error!