Looking for a "new" game to play.

[Shrapenel92]

I recently started playing Tomb Raider Anniversary after having never played a TR game before, it's really fun, it's nice to play something adventure-y, that relies on well-done puzzles too. I recommend it

 

[Quantum Star]

Infamous 1 and 2 are fantastic PS3 games and probably the best sandbox games ever made this generation (Yes, much better than GTA and Saints Row.)

 

[DeathSwitch109]

Mass Effect 2 & 3

So... you never played ME 1? If that's the case, I'd strongly recommend that. And then go on and use that Shep for ME 2 & 3, if you're one to replay games.

Portal 2 is well worth playing, is different to everything you listed there and should be fairly cheap by now.

Also, Portal 1. Looks a tad cheaper, but it's equally great at least.

Apart from that, I had a blast playing Prototype. Running up and down skyscrapers, gliding over Central Park and hitting people with other people who you then proceed to eat is great fun!

I have Mass Effect 1 on Steam...my PC died to I had to switch over to my PS3 because it's more cost efficient. That being said it's an excellent game.

Portal 1: I got really far with it back when I had the Orange Box in 07 but I lost interest in it...I wish I hadn't.

Never had much interest in Prototype but I did enjoy inFamous 1 back in 09.

Someone had also mention the two Batman games. I had both but ended up selling them to purchase other games (don't plan on playing them anymore) but they were great.

 

[Altorin]

I'm playing Heroes 6 and enjoying it a lot, although lots of people seem to hate it, it was just what I ordered

 

[kingthrall]

myth 2 soulblighter, 10 dollars to buy and years worth of replay value